kiper vs McShay

[SR 7]

is it me or is Kiper giving off an aura and face of i wna shoot myself on ESPN when they go at it 1 on 1 vs McShay (SP). Everytime they go at it McShay puts kipers "facts to crap and proves him wrong" and he gets depressed loll looks like he hates his life.

neone know the stats on accuracy in picks chosen from kiper and McShay?
Kiper said talib is goin to be a top 10 pick. lolll

 

[Nappy Roots]

mchsay seems to make more sense sometimes, but then again, kiper doesnt seem to follow everyone else either. kiper saying he just think flacco or henne is very good, in which i agree, takes some balls consider they are everyones sexy picks.

a day after the season, they were 4th round QBs, now their 2nd rounders. and according to some people 1st rounders.

i like Kiper better because hes a lil more out of the box type, Mcshay is probably overall smarter though.

 

[X-Pacolypse]

I don't like either one of them.

 

[B.Sebo]

Between the two I would say Kiper . . . although I really don't agree with the top of his board this year . . . it seems to be set up so that he can rip the Phins apart for taking the fourth or fifth or sixth best player with the first pick (last year repeating three times that "you just don't take the fifteenth best player with the ninth pick").

I swear by Scott Wright that does nfldraftcountdown.com, over the past three or four years he seems to know more than the other guys.

 

[zach8111]

mcshay by far is the best. kiper sometimes lives in dream world especially since he predicted that the ravens would trade down twice and take flacco in the first round (late). ya right

 

[Splat]

is it me or is Kiper giving off an aura and face of i wna shoot myself on ESPN when they go at it 1 on 1 vs McShay (SP). Everytime they go at it McShay puts kipers "facts to crap and proves him wrong" and he gets depressed loll looks like he hates his life.

neone know the stats on accuracy in picks chosen from kiper and McShay?
Kiper said talib is goin to be a top 10 pick. lolll

http://www.finheaven.com/forums/showthread.php?t=218383

Here is the link to Zonkman's post that links to the report that shows the accuracy of these experts. So far Kiper has been better than McShay.

 

[BARF]

kiper sounds like he is about to have an orgasm everytime he talks about a player. thank god mcshay is out there now he the new gen. kiper but better

 

[ChambersWI]

http://www.finheaven.com/forums/showthread.php?t=218383

Here is the link to Zonkman's post that links to the report that shows the accuracy of these experts. So far Kiper has been better than McShay.

McShay also hasn't been doing this as long as Kiper nor does he have the inside info Kiper does.

Trust me when I say, McShay made a huge improvement from last year. He just didn't do a good job evaluating some of the players (though he nailed Brady Quinn falling). McShay was brought in though because he is knowledgable about the draft, and most of the guys on ESPN don't know jack about the draft (case in point a couple years ago, they were leaking picks to Berman and others so they could sound like they knew what they were talking about. They stopped doing this because viewers started to complain.)