Hah, I don't think it's a bad list, actually. Look at the talent above Pouncey - all those players, for the most part, had a more PRODUCTIVE season than Pouncey did.
Kiper says nothing outlandish about Pouncey either way in his little comment and gives him a fair grade when you can consider he has outstanding rookies like Torrey Smith well below Pouncey. Lot of talent this year, nothing wrong with what Miami got or what pick they got it with their first round pick - he was a good move for the team.