Leinart, Quinn or Young | FinHeaven - Miami Dolphins Forums

Leinart, Quinn or Young

SF Dolphin Fan

SF Dolphin Fan

Seasoned Veteran
Club Member
Joined
May 27, 2005
Messages
25,610
Reaction score
35,916
Assuming for a moment that both Brady Quinn and Vince Young decide to come out for the draft to join Leinart as top prospects. Who would you prefer? If both juniors enter, the price for Leinart and Rivers would likely drop and maybe Miami would have a better chance to swing a trade.

Or would you prefer to draft something other than qb in the first round (Lt, CB, DT, LB best player) and look at one of the second tier qb's like Jay Cutler, Brodie Croyle or Charlie Whitehurst?
 
IF they both came out. Young = WR...other than that my personal preference would be Quinn over Leinart, but I would definitely not lose sleep over getting Leinart. Other than the fact that I was so happy we did I couldn't sleep.
 
SF Dolphin Fan said:
Assuming for a moment that both Brady Quinn and Vince Young decide to come out for the draft to join Leinart as top prospects. Who would you prefer? If both juniors enter, the price for Leinart and Rivers would likely drop and maybe Miami would have a better chance to swing a trade.

Or would you prefer to draft something other than qb in the first round (Lt, CB, DT, LB best player) and look at one of the second tier qb's like Jay Cutler, Brodie Croyle or Charlie Whitehurst?
Click to expand...

I'd take Leinart or Cutler over the rest of them, of course the ranking could change dramatically by draft time, but to me Cutler is the total package that might be available for our pick, Leinart is probably out of reach.
 
ether79 said:
IF they both came out. Young = WR...other than that my personal preference would be Quinn over Leinart, but I would definitely not lose sleep over getting Leinart. Other than the fact that I was so happy we did I couldn't sleep.
Click to expand...

Young = WR?....O'Brother....the kid average's over 300 yds a game offense by throwing and running himself....and you think he's a WR? He's the future...better hope you can grab him. He has only two years of playing QB at Texas....and he already has broken many records....his play can only get better.

P A S S I N G E F F I C I E N C Y
(Minimum 15 attempts per game)

Rank Player G Att Comp CPct Int Yds TD Rating

1. Drew Olson, UCLA 10 322 218 67.70 3 2909 30 172.5

2. Vince Young, Texas 10 244 155 63.52 8 2414 22 169.8

3. Brian Brohm, Louisville 9 277 193 69.68 3 2664 17 168.5

4. Matt Leinart, Southern California 10 318 211 66.35 7 3017 23 165.5

5. Brady Quinn, Notre Dame 9 330 217 65.76 5 2931 27 164.3


Rushing Stats

Vince Young 117 carries 774 yds gained 6.68 ypc AVG.
Vince Young is the perfect weapon.
 
SF Dolphin Fan said:
Assuming for a moment that both Brady Quinn and Vince Young decide to come out for the draft to join Leinart as top prospects. Who would you prefer? If both juniors enter, the price for Leinart and Rivers would likely drop and maybe Miami would have a better chance to swing a trade.

Or would you prefer to draft something other than qb in the first round (Lt, CB, DT, LB best player) and look at one of the second tier qb's like Jay Cutler, Brodie Croyle or Charlie Whitehurst?
Click to expand...
Of the A-list here, I'd take Leinart hands down. Of the B-list, I like Whitehurst. I think he's a sleeper.
 
fishypete said:
Young = WR?....O'Brother....the kid average's over 300 yds a game offense by throwing and running himself....and you think he's a WR? He's the future...better hope you can grab him. He has only two years of playing QB at Texas....and he already has broken many records....his play can only get better.

P A S S I N G E F F I C I E N C Y
(Minimum 15 attempts per game)

Rank Player G Att Comp CPct Int Yds TD Rating

1. Drew Olson, UCLA 10 322 218 67.70 3 2909 30 172.5

2. Vince Young, Texas 10 244 155 63.52 8 2414 22 169.8

3. Brian Brohm, Louisville 9 277 193 69.68 3 2664 17 168.5

4. Matt Leinart, Southern California 10 318 211 66.35 7 3017 23 165.5

5. Brady Quinn, Notre Dame 9 330 217 65.76 5 2931 27 164.3


Rushing Stats

Vince Young 117 carries 774 yds gained 6.68 ypc AVG.
Vince Young is the perfect weapon.
Click to expand...

College production means nothing in the NFL, nothing.
 
If we are within 5 picks of drafting Matt Leinart, I think we must do whatever it takes to move up and get him.

On the other hand, If we can get Rivers or Carr, and then use the #1 on D'Brick, That would be a major boust to the future of the Dolphins.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top Bottom