Lets do another Jay vs AJ thing.!

[craig]

AJ. FEELEY!!!! end of story, i dont hate fiedler but he had his chance.. feeley needs the experience and we r not going 2 see that n a couple of games. look at how long it has taken other qbs! r oline was horrible , u cant judge sh** from that game.. until our line gives him more time,then we will see but even then if they dont block 4 him and keep letting him get killed.. how n the he** can he settle down and play if he has 2 run 4 his life.. thats all that needs 2 b said...AJ FEELEY IS MY VOTE ...

 

[Dolphins84]

AJ. FEELEY!!!! end of story, i dont hate fiedler but he had his chance.. feeley needs the experience and we r not going 2 see that n a couple of games. look at how long it has taken other qbs! r oline was horrible , u cant judge sh** from that game.. until our line gives him more time,then we will see but even then if they dont block 4 him and keep letting him get killed.. how n the he** can he settle down and play if he has 2 run 4 his life.. thats all that needs 2 b said...AJ FEELEY IS MY VOTE ...

i can judge that feely makes horrible decisions from both games. he is horrible. when he gets under pressure he just throws the ball to the other team so they can score a touchdown and he has no clue what is going on in the game. HE SUCKS.

 

[Phishstix]

i vote fiedler. i see no future in feeley and at least jay might be able to win some games

 

[YPF]

Jay Fiedler has won a lot of games for the Dolphins.He is no Marino but he is good.The other quarterback is not proven.He will have to learn before taking Fiedlers job.

 

[Va.fin fan]

both games were winnable until this great qb with all this so called potential cant seem to grasp what color jersey his teammates wear. news flash theres a reason he did'nt start in college and was a 3rd string in philly and dont give that poor excuse he didnt hold the ball for pat. he is a statue in the pocket and when he's not pressured he still makes bad decisions. leaf,george,shuler, feeley same thing in common good arms no head and feeley doesnt even beat out the first two as far as arm strengh. he did not beat out jay in the camps or pre season. and people want to just give this guy the pos. for the rest of the yr? add him to the list of griese,lucas and so on alot of the same people wanted these guys to start and you see what it got us, the same thing feeley offers. give me weak arm no talant but just seems to help this team win fiedler. i know we just won with def ,seems funny griese, lucas, and feeley cant. strange world it is.

 

[CrunchTime]

are you asking just for this week or the rest of the season ? please clarify.

OK I modified the question to include the entire season although with this OL its highly unlikely any QB could make it through alone without some injuries.

 

[Dolphin Clan]

Now that you changed the wording can I change my vote.Thinking it over a Wood strock type of quarterback rotation would not be a good idea.I want to change it to Jay.

 

[BlueFin]

So long as our oline sucks, it doesn't make much difference. Assuming Wade Smith being benched will make a major improvement, I'd pick AJ. I don't think our line will ever be right this year though. IMO, Jay makes better decisions, but AJ has the better arm. Jay is more mentally prepared for the pressure that defenses will be giving our QB this year. Assuming that the line doesn't improve, you only use AJ if you're throwing in the towel for the season, in order to get him some experience for the future of this team.

I think you have to take into consideration the teams chances of turning this thing around THIS year, when making the decision of who to start. Nobody knows what this line will be like in 5-6 weeks. More than likely, they won't be much better.

I think Jay Fiedler has zero chances of ever leading any team to any meaningful success, so to start him is a waste of time.

Start AJ and see if he grows, if he doesn't we'll know we need to find our quarterback next year.