Matt Schaub for a 2nd rounder? | FinHeaven - Miami Dolphins Forums

Matt Schaub for a 2nd rounder?

He must not really fit that system. You would think they should be able to get a first rounder for him
 
Dol-Fan Dupree said:
He must not really fit that system. You would think they should be able to get a first rounder for him
Click to expand...

First Rounder is such a big statement these days. You rarely get a first rounder especially for a non-starter. T.O. went for a second, Surtain second their are a few others I can't think of right now...

If we could get him for a second I would go for it. I have watched him a few times and he seems pretty good..:dolphins:
 
Hes ok, but I think we need to keep our picks that we have. We only have a few picks this season after the trade AJ and the suplimental pick. We need all of the picks to fill our holes. I just dont think Schaub is our answer
 
finsfanrm said:
First Rounder is such a big statement these days. You rarely get a first rounder especially for a non-starter. T.O. went for a second, Surtain second their are a few others I can't think of right now...

If we could get him for a second I would go for it. I have watched him a few times and he seems pretty good..:dolphins:
Click to expand...

You rarely get a trade now of days.
 
If Saban and co feel that he has the tools to be the long term answer i'm for it. if his talent level in a workout is marginal no way. a second pick can turn out to be a great long term player.this is a decision that will be crucial. i don't want another second dumped for an aj feely quality. but i have a firm believe saban has a better evaluation of talent than wanny.If Saban does decide to do it, i would have a lot more believe in Schaub's ablilities.
 
No he isnt worth a second rounder. He has less TDS then INT's in his career so far. He hasnt posted anything amazing except 1 game against the Pats. The same pats that Gus lit up for 300+ yards. NO, Schaub is not a good fit for us and not worth a 4th rounder let alone a 2nd
 
I think Schaub can and will be a good starting QB in the NFL. He has the tools, he is a good passer who can escape from the pocket if he needs to. He looked like Vick a little when playing after Vick got injured. He also has good height.
 
playmaker1 said:
Hes ok, but I think we need to keep our picks that we have. We only have a few picks this season after the trade AJ and the suplimental pick. We need all of the picks to fill our holes. I just dont think Schaub is our answer
Click to expand...
We already paid for the AJ trade. He cost us a 2nd rounder in the 2005 draft.
 
Dolfan4life! said:
We already paid for the AJ trade. He cost us a 2nd rounder in the 2005 draft.
Click to expand...
exactly and we have 8 draft choices this year and the only round we don't have 1 in is the 5th and we got M.Wright in that round
 
Dolfan4life! said:
We already paid for the AJ trade. He cost us a 2nd rounder in the 2005 draft.
Click to expand...

Yep, I also agree. SI and Yahoo seem to have forgotten that the man who gave up a second rounder for Feeley isn't around anymore...and I doubt that Saban would let himself be baited into giving up more than his market value.
 
playmaker1 said:
Hes ok, but I think we need to keep our picks that we have. We only have a few picks this season after the trade AJ and the suplimental pick. We need all of the picks to fill our holes. I just dont think Schaub is our answer
Click to expand...

So wasting a draft pick on a QB that has NFL experience is considered a waste and using that same draft pick on a rookie college QB isn't? :confused:

We need a QB. We will draft a QB. Trading a draft pick for a QB is the exact same thing.
 
nick1 said:
exactly and we have 8 draft choices this year and the only round we don't have 1 in is the 5th and we got M.Wright in that round
Click to expand...

We don't have a 6th either. We traded it for Cleo Lemon.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top Bottom