The Confessor
Doesnt play well with others
This is a great point and one I have brought up previously when the Manning to Miami first started during the season. You have to remember with Peyton that the Colts don't sign free agents. They draft guys and coach them up within their system, and the coach of that offense is Peyton Manning. Guys like Clark, Garcon, Wayne, have been playing under coach Manning since they got into the league. He's been pushing them to do it his way and really molded them into his weapons. The Colts players talked during the season about how one of the biggest problems they faced with Curtis Painter is that he just couldn't run the offense the way Manning does. That they just weren't on the same page with him with the calls and all of that even though he's been in that system for years now.
You can't just plug and play Peyton Manning and expect to get that Colts offense.
I think that if you plug a healthy Peyton Manning into the Phins current roster, you get an offense better than that of the Colts. There is already a MUCH better running game, he has some very good receivers, shore up the RT position, and he could kill some numbers IMHO.
I don't think he will ever play again either though. Too bad, easily a top 4 QB I have ever seen play the game. Right up there with Montana, Johnny U and of course Dan.... Guess top 5, cause I would put 2 Dan's in that list.