MERGED: Kiper gave the Seahawks a B and Miami a B-? | Page 2 | FinHeaven - Miami Dolphins Forums

MERGED: Kiper gave the Seahawks a B and Miami a B-?

Kiper is a fool. The guy doesn't know any more than the average football fan but he's got a national venue. So all of a sudden he's an expert and he's got the right to grade each team based on their selections. Unless Kiper has inside information on each and every team's plans - that would make him more of a Dolphins fan than all of us, and all 31 others to boot - he's just guessing.

By the way, I grade Mel Kiper a D for being an annoying pud.
 
Be more interesting to see what he gives the Pats, seeing as though he choked on slagging the Mankins pick, after initially saying it was a 2 round reach.

I really like Mel but this year he was very poor.
 
Normally the highest grades are reserved for teams with multiple picks in the early rounds and a high number of picks overall. We had six picks.
 
Boomer said:
Be more interesting to see what he gives the Pats, seeing as though he choked on slagging the Mankins pick, after initially saying it was a 2 round reach.

I really like Mel but this year he was very poor.
Click to expand...

J/C, but a fool in what aspect? Was it his analysis, projections, or overall how he presented himslef in the draft coverage?
 
Honestly i think we had a good draft but not a top draft. We helped ourselfs out alot but i think we needed more offence. I give us a solid B and have no problem with a B-grade. Kiper for the most part knows his S*** and is pretty solid.
 
I dont care what Mel thinks of our draft. You can't tell if it's a good pick or not until they show their potential at training camp, preseason, and regular season.
 
Jimi said:
J/C, but a fool in what aspect? Was it his analysis, projections, or overall how he presented himslef in the draft coverage?
Click to expand...

I didn't call him a fool.

But he seems to have softened - 5 years ago he would slated the Pats, but he didn't. He seems to have bought in to the ESPN mantra - maybe almost losing his job there upset him.
 
Boomer said:
I didn't call him a fool.

But he seems to have softened - 5 years ago he would slated the Pats, but he didn't. He seems to have bought in to the ESPN mantra - maybe almost losing his job there upset him.
Click to expand...


They got to Kiper too, eh? lol

I cant understand the Pats picking Mankins that high, honestly. I dont claim to know more than Belichick, but it just puzzles me that they took him so early when IMO they coulda traded down to the mid-2nd and added additional picks to add youth at LB and DB and still gotten Mankins in the process.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top Bottom