MERGED: Thats why BMarsh was traded

[Roman529]

Seems like his new meds still don't help him catch TDs.

I would not be shocked at all if sometime between now and next week you hear about Marshall getting a DUI, being involved in a club shooting, getting arrested for doing something to his wife, or getting stabbed by her again.....WHY would anyone want a person like this on their team???

 

[hoops]

hot and cold yeah maybe...but wake me when one of our wrs puts up 9 catches 119 yards and a td in a game like marshall did in week 1...hell wake me when one of them puts up multiple tds period in a a 4 game stretch...

that guys easily going for double digit tds with cutler...easy

 

[Roman529]

hot and cold yeah maybe...but wake me when one of our wrs puts up 9 catches 119 yards and a td in a game like marshall did in week 1...hell wake me when one of them puts up multiple tds period in a a 4 game stretch...

that guys easily going for double digit tds with cutler...easy

Sorry, but one game like that doesn't make me a fan of Marshall's. I remember the game on Monday night a year or two ago when Revis shut him down early and Marshall was done for the rest of the game. I think Revis grabbed the ball right out of Marshall's hands on one play and ran it back. He can get up for meaningless Pro Bowl games where he got 4 TD's, but when it matters he can't be counted on.

 

[napsndreds]

Draft picks are so overrated. We have 11 rookie starting. That's horrible. These guys don't know anything about the nfl. I find it so hard to believe we don't have solid bets at all positions to help the young guys alot. We could have 20 picks in the draft. Ireland doesn't know anything of what he is doing. Instead of picking the obvious pick the most blatant talented individual we go for some no name guy that almost certainly will not pan out. I have no faith in Ireland. There's no reason to have faith with Ireland when it comes to drafting and creating a solid team.

 

[houtz]

Sorry, but one game like that doesn't make me a fan of Marshall's. I remember the game on Monday night a year or two ago when Revis shut him down early and Marshall was done for the rest of the game. I think Revis grabbed the ball right out of Marshall's hands on one play and ran it back. He can get up for meaningless Pro Bowl games where he got 4 TD's, but when it matters he can't be counted on.

If you are referring to the game Revis butt raped Marshall and got away with a P.I then yeah, he was "shutdown".

I loved when we traded for Marshall, could get behind the trade to Chicago. But like him or not he is a ELITE WR. Just my opinion of course.

 

[OrangeShorts]

Remember how many games we lost because of his "beast hands"? I was in the end zone Monday Night Football against the Colts when he dropped 2 TD passes. That game still haunts me as a fan and although I am not an Ireland fan, I think he got that trade right.

 

[The Tannehills Have Eyes]

If you are referring to the game Revis butt raped Marshall and got away with a P.I then yeah, he was "shutdown".

I loved when we traded for Marshall, could get behind the trade to Chicago. But like him or not he is a ELITE WR. Just my opinion of course.

He's elite but not top 10 elite

 

[dlockz]

He's elite but not top 10 elite

i would say top 10 just not top 5 it would be hard to name 10 receivers better than him

---------- Post added at 12:55 AM ---------- Previous post was at 12:54 AM ----------

Remember how many games we lost because of his "beast hands"? I was in the end zone Monday Night Football against the Colts when he dropped 2 TD passes. That game still haunts me as a fan and although I am not an Ireland fan, I think he got that trade right.

Well only if u like the buy high sell low approach of our trades. You cant look at trade in a bubble when we traded 2 2nds for him and gave him a ton of money

 

[Jamaicankid21]

Maybe we can package in the draft picks we got from the Marshall and Vontae trade to move up or get a big name player. As of right now I still don't like the Marshall trade besides a cap space point of view. Hes hot and cold, but look at the attention he was getting from the Packers. Look at the attention Michael Egnew gets from the inactive spot of the roster.

 

[The Tannehills Have Eyes]

i would say top 10 just not top 5 it would be hard to name 10 receivers better than him

In no order

Roddy White
Andre J
Megatron
Steve smith
Cruz
Fitz
Hakeem
Greg J
A.J
DeSean Jackson
Mike Wallace
Wes Welker

all of these before I get marshall. Not hard to name either when you realize he's a clear number 1 option and gets stats padded but drops easy TDs

 

[Rev Kev]

i would say top 10 just not top 5 it would be hard to name 10 receivers better than him

---------- Post added at 12:55 AM ---------- Previous post was at 12:54 AM ----------


Well only if u like the buy high sell low approach of our trades. You cant look at trade in a bubble when we traded 2 2nds for him and gave him a ton of money

1 Jennings
2 Megatron
3 J Jones
4 Roddy White
5 M Wallace
6 J Nelson
7 AJ Green
8. Welker
9. Maclin
10. Desean Jackson
11 Percy Harvin
12 J Maclin
13 D Bowe
14 M Austin
15 H Nicks
16 Fitzgerald
17 Victor Cruz
18 Colston


In no particular order

 

[dlockz]

In no order

Roddy White
Andre J
Megatron
Steve smith
Cruz
Fitz
Hakeem
Greg J
A.J
DeSean Jackson
Mike Wallace
Wes Welker

all of these before I get marshall

definately dont agree all of these players are better.
Nicks and Green still have alot to prove. Steve Smith not at this point, Desean drops alot of balls too basically hit or miss guy , favorite receiver but hard to say he is better. Cruz also has alot more to prove

 

[The Tannehills Have Eyes]

definately dont agree all of these players are better.
Nicks and Green still have alot to prove. Steve Smith not at this point, Desean drops alot of balls too basically hit or miss guy , favorite receiver but hard to say he is better. Cruz also has alot more to prove

Based on last year and their ages Cruz,Nicks,Green are all on locks before I take marshall, and I still stay with Jackson before I get marshall.

 

[Dolfan Dave]

I remember when I started a Brandon Marshall thread....that **** got moved right off the board since he isn't on Dolphins anymore

 

[dlockz]

Based on last year and their ages Cruz,Nicks,Green are all on locks before I take marshall, and I still stay with Jackson before I get marshall

well many a receiver has a good year or two but Marshall at his worst was an 81 catch guy . Hell Cruz dropped like 3 last week and nonbody is saying he sucks. 5 straight years over 80 receptions makes Marshall an elite receiver

---------- Post added at 01:22 AM ---------- Previous post was at 01:21 AM ----------

In no order

Roddy White
Andre J
Megatron
Steve smith
Cruz
Fitz
Hakeem
Greg J
A.J
DeSean Jackson
Mike Wallace
Wes Welker

all of these before I get marshall. Not hard to name either when you realize he's a clear number 1 option and gets stats padded but drops easy TDs

Dont get me wrong I would take any of them except Smith over Brandon long term but cant have guys with much less success ranked over him