Merged: Whos better...Chambers or Booker?? | FinHeaven - Miami Dolphins Forums

Merged: Whos better...Chambers or Booker??

Who would u get rid of? Booker or Chambers??

  • Marty Booker

    Votes: 62 59.0%

  • Chris Chambers

    Votes: 43 41.0%
  • Total voters
    105
i think the title and poll question being opposite will confuse some folk...

but i would get rid of booker, hes a good receiver, but he doesn't have the same skill set that chambers has...
 
Brilliant, cut the guy who produced more who makes 3 mil, and replace him with the guy who makes 7 mil who under produces ........
 
Get rid of both, you mix then together and it will came out, almost, a decent wr. Look at the draf, lots of good WR and maybe in FA. GO DOLPHINS!!
 
Thats a tough question... keep the guy that falls down when the wind blows or a blade of grass is out of place or keep the guy that can't catch easy passes and has very little passion/heart.... tough one.
 
Phantom said:
Brilliant, cut the guy who produced more who makes 3 mil, and replace him with the guy who makes 7 mil who under produces ........
Click to expand...
Moving Chambers back to the #2 spot will result in killing those worries. He will not make 7mil then, and he will go back to the position where he would well out shine Booker.
 
id love to just get rid of both and replace both with Randy Moss and Dante Stallworth.

Randy is NOT worth a 3rd rounder, nor is Stallworth. but i wouldnt mind trading one for one
 
Booker would be gone and Chambers would take his place with Ginn On the other side...Well...If I were GM.
 
MustangFinFan said:
id love to just get rid of both and replace both with Randy Moss and Dante Stallworth.

Randy is NOT worth a 3rd rounder, nor is Stallworth. but i wouldnt mind trading one for one
Click to expand...
It's hard for me to say let go of Booker and keep Chambers, but it's just realistic. If you check my post history, I've not been kind to CC or McMike. Hell, you should of included him too. I would send Randy back to Georgia, where he could be Alge Crumpler's back up.
 
IF CC would play with HALF of Welker's heart and intensity; he would be an amazing WR -- but like Moss .... it just isn't there -- IF someone could convince me that CC would have no problems going across the middle and would take a significant pay cut ... then I would say CC

For anything else, I would go with Booker ... not based on talent; but pure consistency and production. Booker has provided everything asked of him -- except for the injuries.
 
jason8er said:
Moving Chambers back to the #2 spot will result in killing those worries. He will not make 7mil then, and he will go back to the position where he would well out shine Booker.
Click to expand...
This isn't fantasy land, because you send him to #2 doesn't mean his contract is ripped up.........7 mil for a #2, like i said brilliant......
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top Bottom