Minkah -- Jevon | FinHeaven - Miami Dolphins Forums

Minkah -- Jevon

True. The problem is the results of the mikah trade. Everybody likes to say the theory of these trades were good jut the actual drafting was poor. But no matter how you look at it we traded mikah for the 18 pick which was austin jackson. No matter how you look at it is mikah for austin jackson. I like holland better but I hated trading proven players for picks that I knew we would screw up. Thankfully the tunsil trade we basically traded tunsil for waddle and holland. I guess that is a win. But mikah for jackson sucks then and sucks now. I knew we would blow the pick that is why I hated the trade when we made it and hate it now. Nothing to do with holland
 
Proved to be more valuable than Minkah?

I’m no fan of Minkah and say what you want; but the dude made 2 All Pros in his first 3 years. That’s on a HoF trajectory.

Jevon is coming on as a rookie but let’s cool the “more valuable”’comparisons until he starts pinning All Pros on his resume because Minkah already has a pair of them.
 
kellyh3034 said:
Should put to rest all you should've kept Minkah people. Jevon already has proved to be more valuable, more versatile, than Minkah. Imo. So far anyway.
Click to expand...
While I think Holland is a solid player for the Dolphins, Minkah is already a two time all pro safety. Also the player the Dolphins got in the trade with the Steelers for Minkah was Jackson and so far he has not come close to playing at a 1st round level.

I would prefer to have Minkah and Holland as the starting safeties for the Dolphins instead of Holland as one safety and Jackson starting at any position on the OL.
 
AMakados10 said:
Proved to be more valuable than Minkah?

I’m no fan of Minkah and say what you want; but the dude made 2 All Pros in his first 3 years. That’s on a HoF trajectory.

Jevon is coming on as a rookie but let’s cool the “more valuable”’comparisons until he starts pinning All Pros on his resume because Minkah already has a pair of them.
Click to expand...
Eh he "earned" his first all pro with all those right place right time takeaways. Interceptions literally falling into his hands like punts, fumbles rolling by him. Then his all pro and pro bowls after that were pretty much because his name and first all pro. He's going to get more accolades based on popularity and not necessarily because he's "elite". I still see him getting tossed aside and hesitating on tackles and without those said takeaways he's pretty average.
 
AMakados10 said:
Proved to be more valuable than Minkah?

I’m no fan of Minkah and say what you want; but the dude made 2 All Pros in his first 3 years. That’s on a HoF trajectory.

Jevon is coming on as a rookie but let’s cool the “more valuable”’comparisons until he starts pinning All Pros on his resume because Minkah already has a pair of them.
Click to expand...
So Minkah won 2 popularity contests...Means little.
 
1972forever said:
While I think Holland is a solid player for the Dolphins, Minkah is already a two time all pro safety. Also the player the Dolphins got in the trade with the Steelers for Minkah was Jackson and so far he has not come close to playing at a 1st round level.

I would prefer to have Minkah and Holland as the starting safeties for the Dolphins instead of Holland as one safety and Jackson starting at any position on the OL.
Click to expand...
Eh they both wouldn't be as effective as both play the same FS position.
 
Dolph N.Fan said:
Eh he "earned" his first all pro with all those right place right time takeaways. Interceptions literally falling into his hands like punts, fumbles rolling by him. Then his all pro and pro bowls after that were pretty much because his name and first all pro. He's going to get more accolades based on popularity and not necessarily because he's "elite". I still see him getting tossed aside and hesitating on tackles and without those said takeaways he's pretty average.
Click to expand...
I always thought that being in the right place at the right time means you are doing your job correctly. Howard was in the right place at the right time 10 times during the 2020 season and that’s why he had 10 interceptions.

It appears you have sour grapes about Fitzpatrick wanting to be traded. Because X has given up 7 TD passes this year and only has 2 ints and 2 fumble recoveries. So based on your criteria Howard is just an average CB because he has given up far more TD’s than he had turnovers.

I agree Minkah isn’t playing as well this year as he did the past two season but neither is Howard. It happens in the NFL.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top Bottom