MNF: Ravens @ Steelers | Page 2 | FinHeaven - Miami Dolphins Forums

MNF: Ravens @ Steelers

McNabb is top 5 cmon now the guy puts up huge numbers with no consistant running game and has taken his team to to NFC championships as well as a Superbowl. No legit top 5 leaves him out. You cant put EManning infront of him, thats just silly. I love Eli but he hasnt done much of anything so far hes been good for 8 games in his career thats not enough to be top 5.
 
finfansince72 said:
McNabb is top 5 cmon now the guy puts up huge numbers with no consistant running game and has taken his team to to NFC championships as well as a Superbowl. No legit top 5 leaves him out. You cant put EManning infront of him, thats just silly. I love Eli but he hasnt done much of anything so far hes been good for 8 games in his career thats not enough to be top 5.
Click to expand...
Eli hasn't been affored the situation yet but possibly will this year. McNabb folds in every big game he plays. Anyone can give me all the excuses you want, but as every non Dolphin fan says to me..excuses mean squat. I hate to compare but Marino could've did better with those teams as could Manning, Farve, etc..
 
NY_FinFan_72 said:
I didn't turn it on intil about 6:00 to go. This is a good game. Should be a good finish here... 3rd and 6...
Click to expand...

nice R&R graphic in your sig. i like it.
 
ether79 said:
Eli hasn't been affored the situation yet but possibly will this year. McNabb folds in every big game he plays. Anyone can give me all the excuses you want, but as every non Dolphin fan says to me..excuses mean squat. I hate to compare but Marino could've did better with those teams as could Manning, Farve, etc..
Click to expand...

"Eli hasn't been affored the situation yet " exactly, you dont know if he can get it done or not. I love Eli but putting him above Superbowl Qbs and guys that have been probowlers year in and year out is premature.
I dont know where on earth you get this McNabb folds in the biggames nonsense. He has taken his team to the NFC title game as well as the Superbowl. His playoff numbers are pretty good and he has had some huge games in the playoffs. Some bad ones but hes done enough to say he has played well in big games. That stuff about him not getting it done is just pure nonsense. What were his good receivers before Owens? I cant name one can you?
 
Baltimore put up a HELLUVA fight and almost stole that win IN PITTSBURGH. Ben Roethlisberger will never lose a game... only to New England. :rolleyes:
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top Bottom