My Player Ratings | FinHeaven - Miami Dolphins Forums

My Player Ratings

C

CChambers7284

The Biggest Fins Fan from CT
Joined
Jan 9, 2005
Messages
1,199
Reaction score
4
Age
35
Location
connecticut
Here are my ratings for our current roster (0-99, rating, like madden)

post yours and feel free to critizize mine

QB- Gus Frerotte- 80
Safe Rosenfels- 77
Cleo Lemon- 60

RB-
Ricky Williams- 89
Ronnie Brown- 87
Travis Minor- 75

FB
Barnes- 79
Morris- 76

WR
Chambers- 93
Booker- 86
Welker- 79
Gimlore- 73

TE
McMicahel- 89
Diamond- 70

Tackles
McIntosh- 83
Carey- 75
MacDougle- 80

Guards
James- 82
Hadnot- 85

Center
McKinney- 76
Emphriam- 71

Defensivee End
Carter- 89
Taylor- 98
Bowens- 80
Roth- 75

DT
Zgonina- 84
Traylor- 86
Holiday- 84

OLB
Seau- 86
Spragan- 78
Crowder- 84

MLB
Thomas- 97
Pope- 74

CB
Madison- 87
Howard- 75
Daniels- 78
Thomas- 75
Poole- 73

FS
Schulters- 88
Bell- 78

SS
Jones- 83
Tillman- 78

K Mare- 89
P Jones- 88

KR- Welker- 90
PR- Welker- 93

Coaching Staff- 94
 
I'd put Brown over williams. I mean he did get more yards rushing and recieving.
 
Aquanator B1000 said:
I'd put Brown over williams. I mean he did get more yards rushing and recieving.
Click to expand...
have you forgotten that ricky also played in like 4 less games than brown
 
considering fiedler was ranked at 84 previous madden's i think ferrotte should be an 84 too....
 
CChambers7284 said:
FB
Morris- 76
Click to expand...

WHAT? Are you forgetting that the man played out of position two seasons ago and made the best of his chance? He is a RB in a FB body, he plays special teams and levels people when they get the ball on special teams. The man is a all around team player, we just didn't see a lot of him or any FB for that matter when Scott L. was running offense because he doesn't like FBs, he perfers to use TE sets. If Sammy is still with us next season(which he should be or atleast I hope), we will probally see him doing some FB type of stuff like blocking and all that, and probally coming in on short yardage plays once in awhile. You may have based your rating of Sammy on what you've seen, but based on what I've seen when he was playing for another team, the man is damn good and deserves a higher rating then 76.
 
I'll put some up, of starters

Frerrote: 82
Brown: 88
Williams: 89
Barnes: 77
Morris: 78
Chambers: 91
Booker: 85
McMichael: 88
Carey: 83
Hadnot: 84
McKinney: 80
James: 87
McIntosh: 83

Taylor: 97
Carter: 90
Holliday: 87
Traylor: 93
Bowens: 81
Spragan: 81
Thomas: 98
Crowder: 84
Daniels: 79
Schulters: 91
Bell: 80
Madison: 89
 
I have a couple of disagreements with you.

Gus Frerotte was the 28th rated passer in the league so he is not an 80. More like a 70. I also dont think Ricky is a better runner then Ronnie Brown. Ronnie hit the rookie wall, but look for him to have a HUGE season next year. Both backs are great and averaged over 4 yards a carry. Both great backs but i give the nod to Ronnie.

Also Chambers had a big breakout year. I personally thikn he is a top 10 WR in the league. So i gotta give him a little higher rating. How about a 95?
 
CChambers7284 said:
Here are my ratings for our current roster (0-99, rating, like madden)

post yours and feel free to critizize mine

QB- Gus Frerotte- 80
Safe Rosenfels- 77
Cleo Lemon- 63

RB-
Ricky Williams- 91
Ronnie Brown- 90
Travis Minor- 72

FB
Barnes- 84
Morris- 76

WR
Chambers- 93
Booker- 86
Welker- 80
Gimlore- 73

TE
McMicahel- 90
Diamond- 70

Tackles
McIntosh- 80
Carey- 81
MacDougle- 78

Guards
James- 82
Hadnot- 85

Center
McKinney- 78
Emphriam- 71

Defensivee End
Carter- 89
Taylor- 96
Bowens- 78
Roth- 77

DT
Zgonina- 82
Traylor- 86
Holiday- 88

OLB
Seau- 87
Spragan- 78
Crowder- 85

MLB
Thomas- 97
Pope- 74

CB
Madison- 86
Howard- 72
Daniels- 80
Thomas- 75
Poole- 76

FS
Schulters- 88
Bell- 81

SS
Jones- 81
Tillman- 78

K Mare- 87
P Jones- 88

KR- Welker- 90
PR- Welker- 93

Coaching Staff- 91
Click to expand...

underline = decreased

bold = increased
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top Bottom