*** OFFICIAL MIAMI DOLPHINS @ SEATTLE SEAHAWKS GAME THREAD *** WK3 | Page 7 | FinHeaven - Miami Dolphins Forums

*** OFFICIAL MIAMI DOLPHINS @ SEATTLE SEAHAWKS GAME THREAD *** WK3

Status
Not open for further replies.
Beach Bum said:
I could be wrong, and I would rather see Huntely, too, but the way 13Marino13 described the situation, it must be a rule that prevents us from playing Huntley first if Thompson goes down. I
Click to expand...
It is the rule. The 3 or emergency QB can only enter if both 1 and 2 are injured. If either 1 or 2 are cleared to return the they must also go back in the game.

But it is Miami's choice. On who is the #2. They also could have just dress all 3, but that would cost another roster spot.

Also the more I think about it, can we even designate Huntley as an emergency QB. Doesn't he have to be on the active 53 since we claimed him of Baltimore PS.
 
Mach2 said:
I realize that was "tongue in cheek", but do you really disagree with putting Tua on IR given the circumstances?

I don't.

It sucks from the POV that he, obviously, gives us a better chance of winning games but from a PR and optics perspective, I don't know that they had much real choice.
Click to expand...
it's hard for me to have a real opinion because I think Mike is more worried about perception than anything else.....first time Tua had one he came back quick and people were saying that Mike didn’t care and I think now he has a mental block....I'm not sure Mike can actually make the right decision now cause he's worried about what people will say. I'm also pretty sure mike didn’t make the decision alone so there's that buyt he's been babying these players since day one and I think that's one reason why the team hasn’t been ready to play the first two weeks.

Today will tell me/us a lot about Mike. I'm hoping he has the team ready for this one but we'll see.
 
To me, it feels like the leadership of this team took the easy way out by putting Tua on IR. They didn’t want to be asked the same questions over and over. They wanted the media focus off of Tua. It was a chickenshit move.
 
13marino13 said:

Found this, lists Huntley behind Thompson on the depth chart…​

Miami Dolphins Depth Chart​

3WR 1TE
QB
RB
WR
WR
WR
TE
FB
LT
LG
C
RG
RT

STARTER2ND3RD4TH
Skylar ThompsonTyler HuntleyTim BoyleTua Tagovailoa IR
De'Von AchaneRaheem Mostert DJeff Wilson Jr.Jaylen Wright
Tyreek HillMalik Washington DOdell Beckham Jr. OGrant DuBose IR
Jaylen WaddleDee EskridgeRiver Cracraft IRAnthony Schwartz IR
Braxton BerriosErik EzukanmaTahj Washington IR-
Jonnu SmithDurham SmytheJulian HillTanner Conner
Alec Ingold---
Terron ArmsteadPatrick Paul--
Robert JonesIsaiah Wynn OKion Smith IR-
Aaron BrewerAndrew Meyer--
Liam EichenbergLester Cotton--
Austin JacksonKendall Lamm--

Base 3-4 D
LDE
NT
RDE
WLB
LILB
RILB
SLB
LCB
SS
FS
RCB
NB

STARTER2ND3RD4TH
Zach Sieler---
Benito JonesBrandon Pili--
Calais CampbellDa'Shawn Hand--
Jaelan PhillipsEmmanuel OgbahMohamed KamaraCameron Goode O
David Long Jr.Anthony Walker Jr.--
Jordyn BrooksDuke RileyChanning Tindall-
Quinton BellChop RobinsonBradley Chubb OCam Brown IR
Kendall FullerSiran NealEthan Bonner-
Jordan PoyerMarcus Maye--
Jevon HollandElijah CampbellPatrick McMorris IR-
Jalen RamseyStorm DuckCam Smith IR-
Kader Kohou--
Click to expand...
Ya but the more I think about it, I believe Huntley has to be active not an emergency QB. As in since claimed of a PS he has to be part of the 53 man roster (not emergency QB), if he us not Baltimore has the right to claim him back to their PS.

I think we are just carrying 3 active QBs, not an emergency QB. So Huntley could actually enter and exit at any time.

I may be wrong but I believe that to be correct.
 
dan the fin said:
It is the rule. The 3 or emergency QB can only enter if both 1 and 2 are injured. If either 1 or 2 are cleared to return the they must also go back in the game.

But it is Miami's choice. On who is the #2. They also could have just dress all 3, but that would cost another roster spot.

Also the more I think about it, can we even designate Huntley as an emergency QB. Doesn't he have to be on the active 53 since we claimed him of Baltimore PS.
Click to expand...
Yes, Huntley has to be on the 53 since we pulled him from another team's practice squad.

I don't know that Huntley will be ready to go as QB2 given he's been here a week and they spent one day on a cross country flight. Also assume that Thompson was pretty much taking on the snaps this week.
 
dan the fin said:
Ya but the more I think about it, I believe Huntley has to be active not an emergency QB. As in since claimed of a PS he has to be part of the 53 man roster (not emergency QB), if he us not Baltimore has the right to claim him back to their PS.

I think we are just carrying 3 active QBs, not an emergency QB. So Huntley could actually enter and exit at any time.

I may be wrong but I believe that to be correct.
Click to expand...
ESPN depth charts I believe are just their assumptions.
 
Chargers look like. Different team with harbaugh. Ugh
I thought they would be wildcard team.
 
DrMultimedia said:
Willis has 72 yards rushing in the first quarter of the GB game. Rushing QBs can be useful. Huntley....come on down.
Click to expand...
Skylar can run. But seems like he never does
 
bane said:
Chargers look like. Different team with harbaugh. Ugh
I thought they would be wildcard team.
Click to expand...
Steelers look like the same team they always are. Good defense, horrendous offense. Somehow go 9-8 or 10-7 and get stomped in the first round of the playoffs.
 
brumdog44 said:
Yes, Huntley has to be on the 53 since we pulled him from another team's practice squad.

I don't know that Huntley will be ready to go as QB2 given he's been here a week and they spent one day on a cross country flight. Also assume that Thompson was pretty much taking on the snaps this week.
Click to expand...
I doubt he plays. I am just saying that I don't believe that the posters who believe he can't enter the game unless both Skylar and Boyle get hurt (emergency QB rule) are correct. The emergency QB is not actually part of the 53 man roster, he is an exception to the 53 man roster, who can only play in certain situations. Huntley I believe has to be on the actual 53 man roster.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top Bottom