Ok my list is updated: The 50 Greatest Dolphins of all Time | FinHeaven - Miami Dolphins Forums

Ok my list is updated: The 50 Greatest Dolphins of all Time

jg772006

FinHeaven VIP
Joined
Nov 19, 2006
Messages
472
Reaction score
210
Age
39
Location
Scranton, Pennsylvania
A Couple of days ago, I put out a thread suggesting my top 30 Dolphins of all time. Some people did not like the number 30 and suggested I go higher, maybe to 50...which I now have done. I got a lot of complaints claiming I left out a lot of players. So I worked even harder on it, thought real hard, and did even more research. Keep in mind these are the Greatest "Miami Dolphins" of all time. Its players, owners, and coaches, that spent their entire career or the majority of their career with the Dolphins. I judged them on credentials, contributions, memorable moments, consistency, stats, titles, and integrity throughout their careers not just with the Dolphins, but with football in general. And since I even thought about it even more with more players, I even jumbled up the order a little bit more (however my top 16 remained the same). I put alot of effort and time in this, and if you dont like it, i would like to see you come up with a better list, or a list of your own in general. At the same time, I hope you enjoy this one last time, and let me know what you think please. If you didnt see the one I put up before, enjoy this one. Thank you and enjoy.

50. Jim "Crash" Jensen 11...Quarterback/Wide Receiver/Tight End/Running Back (1981-1993)...I was really hesitant to put Jim on this list. In 12 years with Miami as a Wide Receiver, Tight End, and Running back, he only hit just about 2,300 career yards of offense with only four TDs. However, he certainly was one of the most versital players ever with Miami, and showed a lot of heart in trying out for all these positions just to be a part of the Dolphin Organization. Because of his heart, certainly a top 50 in my book, but barely.

49. Larry Seiple 20...Punter/Tight End (1967-1977)...Ok, he is the Dolphins all time leader in punts with 633 punts and he is also one of the big reasons why Miami beat the Steelers in the 1972 AFC Championship Game. Remember his 37 yard run on a fake punt that set up Miami's first TD? Probably the best play of the year that year. Larry had a lot of guts doing that play.

48. Oronde Gadsden 86...Wide Receiver (1998-2003)...He was perhaps the most talented and sure handed receiver we may of had. His one handed grabs were incredible, especialy the one against Oakland in the 2000 Divisional Playoff loss, and the 2002 home game against the Jets if you can remember. And here is something interesting about Oronde. He is credited with catching Dan Marino's last TD pass. Not a top 30 on my previous list, but certainly worthy of Top 50.

47. David Woodley 16...Quarterback (1980-1983)...Was part of Miami's one-two quarterback punch with Don Strock called "Woodstrock". Was the starting quarterback for the Dolphins that bridged Bob Griese and Dan Marino together. Led the Miami Dolphins to Super Bowl XVII, and even threw a 76 yard TD pass in that game, but John Riggins and the Redskins were too much for the fish. But even though we lost, we have to appreciate David getting us to our fourth Super Bowl.

46. Vern Den Herder 83...Defensive End (1971-1982)...Bill Stanfill's opposite. A tremendous pass rusher along with Bill and were an incredible defensive end duo in the 70s. He was not as good as Bill, but was definitely more consistent. Recorded an unofficial 64 sacks with Miami, putting him fourth on the all-time list.

45. Wayne Moore 79...Offensive Tackle (1970-1978)...One of Miami's unsung heros on the offensive line in the 70s. Was a part of perhaps the greatest offensive line in NFL history with Langer, Little, and Kooch. He was selected to his lone Pro Bowl in 1973, which is pretty good considering that most of your line teammates are superstars.

44. Pete Stoyanovich 10...Kicker (1989-1995)...I do not consider Pete better than Olindo or Garo, but definitely a top 50 player. He was a great long distance kicker, but was extremely inaccurate at times. I remember two of his kicks, one was incredible, and one was heart breaking. His booming 59 yard field goal he made against the Jets in 1989 (which was 3rd longest in NFL history at the time), but his heartbreaking 42 yard miss against San Diego in the 1994 Divisional Playoffs against San Diego. In team history, he is 2nd in FGs made (176 of 222), 2nd in accuracy (79.3%), and 3rd in scoring (774 pts.).

43. Bruce Hardy 84...Tight End (1978-1989)...He retired as the Dolphins all time leader receiver for a Tight End. One of Dan Marino's favorite targets in his early days, and sometimes Bruce Hardy would even call the offensive plays in the huddle when Marino did not have the offense down pat yet. A great veteran with 256 Receptions for 2,465 Yards and 25 TDs.

42. Brock Marion 31...Safety (1998-2003)...One of Miami's best defensive backs in the late 90s into the early 00s. With Sam Madison and Patrick Surtain, they were one of the best complete secondaries over a five year span. With Miami he recorded 20 Interceptions and scored on three defensive TDs, along with being a three time Pro Bowler with Miami (2000, 2002-2003). One key defender that Miami should of never got rid of.

41. Tim Ruddy 61...Center (1994-2003)...Another one of Miami's most underappreciated offensive lineman ever, but he was certainly one of our most popular. Made very few mistakes and certainly was very reliable. He started 140 of his 156 career games with Miami, and finally was rewarded with a 2000 Pro Bowl Selection.

40. Tim Bowens 95...Defensive Tackle (1994-2004)...One of Miami's bestest run stuffers ever. He kept ALOT of offensive linemen off of Zach Thomas so he could make plays. He was the 1994 NFL Defensive Rookie of the Year, and a two time Pro Bowl selection (1998, 2002). His unselfishness helped Zach become one of the best middle linebackers today. It is too bad his back problems forced him to retire early.

39. Sam Madison 29...Cornerback (1997-2005)...I know it is hard to put a player on this list that was called for so many penalties, and gave up too many big plays for us late in his career with Miami, but lets give credit where credit is due. Sam Madison was one, if not the best, cover corner we ever had on the Dolphins. 31 Career Interceptions, four time Pro Bowler (1999-2002), and NFL Alumni Association Defensive Back of the Year (1999). Although he is on the decline now with the Giants, we must never forget all the great plays he made for us on defense over the years we had him.

38. Trace Armstrong 93...Defensive End (1995-2000)...He was Jason Taylor's opposite on the defensive line for four years. Served as a great veteran mentor to Jason Taylor. He recorded 56.5 Sacks and 7 Fumble Recoveries with Miami, including leading the NFL in sacks in 2000 with 16.5, en route to his lone Pro Bowl selection. He is barely under the top five all-time sack leaders list in team history.

37. Jim Kiick 21...Running Back (1966-1974)...Part of that triple back attack that launched Miami into three straight Super Bowls. Showed great character and unselfishness in sharing carries with Eugene "Mercury" Morris and Larry Csonka. Also selected to two AFL All-Star Games (1968-1969).

36. Earl Morrall 15...Quarterback (1972-1976)...He has never been given enough credit for what he did in 1972. When Bob Griese went down with a broken leg, he kept our destiny of perfection alive. He did not lose a single start in 1972 making him the 1972 NFL Comeback Player of the Year. When Don Shula replaced him with Griese in the 1972 AFC Championship Game against the Steelers, he showed class by telling Shula, "I don't agree with the decision, but I do respect it." A true teammate and a great class act was Earl Morrall. Thank you for 1972 Earl.

35. Norm Evans 73...Offensive Tackle (1966-1975)...One of Miami's unsung heros on the 1972 Undefeated Team. Yes we give all the credit to Larry Little, Jim Langer, and Bob Kuechenberg who are in the Hall of Fame (put Kooch in the Hall of Fame already committee, you bunch of dumb***es) as well we should, but Norm Evans along with Wayne Moore and those three HOFs were arguably one of the greatest offensive lines assembled in NFL history. A two time Pro Bowler (1972, 1974) and two time All-AFC choice is certainly remarkable, especially when you are put on a team filled with superstars.

34. Eugene "Mercury" Morris 22...Running Back (1969-1975)...Was part of that three back punch with Kiick and Csonka that help Miami get to three consecutive Super Bowls, including going undefeated in 1972. Morris and Csonka became the first running back duo in NFL history to each rush for 1,000 yards in a single season. Career stats with Miami include 3,877 Rushing Yards, 46 Receptions for 491 Yards and 30 total TDs, along with being a three time Pro Bowl selection (1971-1973).

33. Kim Bokamper 58...Linebacker/Defensive End (1977-1985)...Another one of Miami's most versital defensive players ever, playing both linebacker and moving down to defensive end. Was part of that famed "Killer B's" defense. Recorded 12 Sacks, 6 Interceptions, 3 Fumble Recoveries, and 1 defensive TD. Selected to his lone Pro Bowl in 1979, but should of been selected to more. Trust me.

32. O.J. McDuffie 81...Wide Receiver (1993-2000)...One of Marino's favorite targets. Recorded 415 Receptions, including a single season team record of 90 in 1998, which led the NFL (he was the first, and still is the only, Dolphin to ever lead the NFL in Receptions). He finished with 5,074 yards and 29 TDs. Although he never went to a Pro Bowl, he certainly was a top 50 Dolphin in my book.

31. Don Strock 10...Quarterback (1973-1987)...The best relief quarterback Miami ever had in the 80s and served as a great mentor to our boy Dan Marino. Was part of a one-two quarterback punch with David Woodley called "WoodStrock". Who can ever forget his legendary performance in "The Epic in Miami" game in the 1981 Divisional Playoffs against the San Diego Chargers. Down 24-0, Shula replaced Woodley with Strock, and Strock went on to have the game of his life. He threw for 403 Yards and 4 TDs in a 41-38 overtime losing effort. He said that was the game of his career, and he is right.

30. Manny Fernandez 75...Defensive Tackle (1968-1975)...I know I didn't put him in my top 30 list before and there are reasons why. He did not put up gaudy stats, and never was selected to a Pro Bowl, however he is certainly worthy of my top 50 list, and now that I adjusted my order a little bit, now he is in my top 30. I know Manny is a popular player, especially with the older generations of Dolphin fans. His performance in Super Bowl VII was absolutely super. He recorded 17 total tackles, and 11 of them were unassisted. With that kind of performance to help your team win a Super Bowl, puts you on my top 50 list.

29. Ed Newman 64...Guard (1973-1984)...Along with Dwight Stephenson, were two of the best interior lineman Miami had in the 80s to help them get to two Super Bowls in the 80s. Terrific run-blocker, and hardly ever gave up sacks on Dan Marino. Selected to four straight Pro Bowls (1981-1984) ain't bad either.

28. Bob Baumhower 73...Defensive End (1977-1986)...Another member of the famed "Killer B's" Defense that was the biggest ball hog at the time. His 16 Career Fumble Recoveries, 1 INT, and 2 Defensive TDs are proof of that. A five time Pro Bowl selection (1979, 1981-1984) and two time First Team All-Pro as well. Sadly both he and Betters ended their careers when Marino was beginning to come around. Makes you wish that some of these "Killer B's" players coincided with Marino's career a lil bit longer.

27. Doug Betters 75...Defensive End (1978-1987)...One of the best inspirational players Miami ever had. The uncanny leader of Miami's famous "Killer B's" defense of the 80s. Recorded 43.5 sacks in his career (65.5 unofficially because of sacks becoming offical stats in 1982), and was the 1983 Defensive player of the Year with 16.5 sacks, was also selected to his lone Pro Bowl that year. Probably Miami's best pass rusher ever not named Jason Taylor or Bill Stanfill.

26. Bill Stanfill 84...Defensive End (1969-1976)...Miami's first true dominant defensive player. Recorded an unofficial 69.5 sacks (Sacks became official in 1982) including two 5-sack games, one against the Jets in 1973, and one against Buffalo in 1974. Set team single season record with 18.5 Sacks (since tied by JT in 2002), selected to 1 AFL All-Star game (1969) and four Pro Bowls (1971-1974). A two-time All-NFL choice is certainly worthy of anyones top 50 greatest Dolphins ever. Probably Miami's greatest pass rusher ever not named Jason Taylor.

HALF WAY HOME!!!

25. Olindo Mare 10...Kicker (1997-current)...OK, OK. Lay off. Yes he has missed numerous game winning kicks for us, and yes he is inconsistent at times, but lets be honest, other than Garo Yepremian, what other great kicker have we had in our history, and don't tell me Pete Stoyanovich, because although he was a great long distance kicker, he was even more inconsistent than Olindo. Even so, Olindo is currently Miami's All Time leading scorer, has made over 80% of his field goals (245 of 303 FGs made) and was the NFL Alumni Association Special Teams Player of the Year and First Team All-Pro, as well as Pro Bowl starter in 1999. Yes we all remember his missed kicks in the infield against New England in 2003, but what about his 49 yarder he made in the 2000 season ender against New England to help us win the division? What about the booming 53 yarder he made in Denver in 2002 at the last second? For all you Olindo haters out there, please dont give up on him yet.

24. Patrick Surtain 23...Cornerback (1998-2004)...I have said it to myself every single day since Miami traded him. It was arguably one of the biggest mistakes EVER by miami front offices and management to trade him to Kansas City. He was considered "SAM MADISON's" partner in crime, however Patrick certainly was better than Madison, largely impart because he was not called on penalties alot. Madison was. However is does not ruin the fact that with Madison, they were one of the best cover corner tandems in the NFL for about six or seven years. A two time First or Second Team All-Pro and two time Pro Bowl selection (2002-2003), and NFL Alumni Association Defensive Back of the Year in 2002. 29 Career interceptions with Miami puts him 5th on the all time team list. And he is still producing well in Kansas City. Again I ask, WHY DID MIAMI GET RID OF HIM???!!! It breaks my heart he is gone.

23. John Offerdahl 56...Linebacker (1986-1993)...We all know about Hall of Fame linebacker Nick Buoniconti of the 70s. We all know about the current great linebacker we have in Zach Thomas of the late 90s to 00s. But some of us tend to forget the two great linebackers we had between these two greats. One is John Offerdahl. In eight years, he went to five Pro Bowls (1986-1990) and arguably (in my opinion) was perhaps the greatest Dolphin defender during Dan Marino's tenure with the team. Quite frankly, he was the ONLY great Dolphin defender during Dan Marino's tenure.

22. Garo Yepremian 1...Kicker (1970-1978)...I know he is the third kicker on my list, but he was one of the premier kickers of his time. His selection to the 1970s All-Decade Team is proof of that. Yes he made a total goof of himself when he attempted a pass in Super Bowl VII, and almost costing us the perfect season, and his efficiency was not that good, but he certainly was clutch for us in the 70s. Example: Kicking the game winning field goal in the longest game ever played against Kansas City in 1973. And here is something I bet you did not know about Garo. Other than Ricky Williams who won it in 2002, Garo Yepremain is the only other Dolphin Pro Bowl MVP. He kicked 5 field goals to help the AFC defeat the NFC 15-13 in the 1974 Pro Bowl.

21. Paul Warfield 42...Wide Receiver (1970-1974)...My first Hall of Famer on the list. To many of you, this might seem too low to be on my list, but he was only with Miami for five years. Certainly an all time Dolphin Great, but his best years were not with Miami because Miami was a running team when he joined. Most of Paul's best years were with Cleveland. However, helping Miami to an Undefeated Season certainly will get you on this list. His 20.1 Yards per catch average is sensational. Arguably a great Dolphin with five straight Pro Bowls (1970-1974) and a six time All-NFL selection. However in my opinion, he was not the best wide reciever Miami ever had, but certainly one of my top 50 of all time.

20. A.J. Duhe 77...Linebacker (1977-1984)...Along with Offerdahl, here is the other linebacker we tend to forget between Buoniconti and Thomas. But I guarantee you, you mention the 1983 AFC Title game to any Jet fan, they will begin to grind their teeth, grumble under their breath, and maybe even throw a tantrum. Just tell them four syllables: A...J...DU...HE!!! A.J. Duhe makes this list simply because of that game. What he did to our pain in the *** rivals, those Green puke buckets - the Jets, brings a smile to my face everytime I think about it. 3 Interceptions, returning one for a TD and single handedly putting Miami into Super Bowl XVII, and breaking the hearts of jet fans everywhere...aaaaa I LOVE IT!! Oh and by the way, 1977 NFL Defensive Rookie of the Year and 1984 Pro Bowl selection ain't to shabby either.

19. Reggie Roby 4...Punter (1983-1992)...Dolfans must never forget this man. Along with Ray Guy, they were the best punters of their generations. Reggie Roby was an innovator of a Punter, popularizing the two step approach and becoming the first punter ever to wear a stop watch to gauge his hangtime. Still to this day he holds the Pro Bowl single game record of 10 punts. Was selected to the All-Decade Team of the 1980s, and also a two time Pro Bowl selection with Miami (1984, 1989). It is a damn shame that he and Ray Guy are not in the Hall of Fame because they both should be. They both have been the superior standards to punters today. God bless you and R.I.P Reggie Roby. You have always been missed and your a top 50 Dolphin in my book.

18. Nat Moore 89...Wide Receiver (1974-1986)...Maybe Miami's first great Wide Receiver that we were able to see his full ability. Nat Moore came to the Dolphins at a time when Miami was slowly turning into a passing team. Retired as the Dolphins all time leading receiver at the time in catches, yards, and TDs, but most importantly, he was a true class act and a great teammate. You want proof? Look closely at the years he was with Miami. What two receivers came to Miami around the end of his career that he mentored, which became two all time greats in Dolphin history? I'll give you a hint. They are futher down on this list (but i bet you already knew that).

17. Bob Kuechenberg 67...Guard (1970-1984)...This man gets robbed of the Hall of Fame year after year after year, and it makes me sick to my freakin stomach. Yes he stirs up controversy, and yes he overexpresses his opinions of the Dolphins like he did this year claiming the Dolphins have no heart. But look at it this way. He wouldn't of said it, if he didn't care. As much as many Dolfans would disagree, Bob cares about our franchise. I am sure he would love to see this franchise become great once again, almost to the form it once was in the 70s. He was a huge success with the dolphins in the 70s. Was a part of all five of Miami's AFC Championships, including their Super Bowl championships, and absolutely kicked Alan Page's butt in Super Bowl VIII. Watch that game and just watch Bob on Alan. A three time First or Second Team All-Pro and six time Pro Bowl Selection (1974-1975, 1977-1978, 1982-1983), and he is still not in the Hall of Fame? The Hall of Fame committee better wise up in the next couple of years and put him in, otherwise Bob is going to have to wait as a Senior Nominee and possibly wait even longer.

16. Jake Scott 13...Safety (1970-1975)...One of the most underappreciated players in Dolphin history. People considered him to be in the shadow of Dick Anderson. Although, he and Dick were the most feared safety tandem in the 70s. Rumors of Jake and Coach Shula's relationship going combustable are still brought up today, but no one can deny his contributions to the Dolphins. The Dolphins all time Interceptions leader with 35, a five time Pro Bowl selection (1971-1975), and Super Bowl VII MVP when he picked off two passes.

15. Richmond Webb 78...Offensvie Tackle (1990-2000)...The best left offensive tackle Miami has ever had. He protected Dan Marino's blind side for ten years and is one of the main reasons why Dan Marino was as successful as he was. He pretty much kept Marino's jersey clean, not giving up many sacks. Started a Dolphin record 114 straight games (will be broken next year by JT), and has been to a Dolphin record seven consecutive Pro Bowls (1990-1996). Selected to the 1990s All-Decade Team, and is eligible for the NFL Hall of Fame this coming year.

14. Mark Duper 85...Wide Receiver (1982-1992)..."Super" Duper was one half of one of the most dynamic receiving duos known as the "Marks Brothers". Granted he had some off field problems after he retired which might have some reason why he has not been heavily considered for the Hall of Fame, but his exciting performances he had for the Dolphins will never be forgotten. Who will ever forget his game winning 50 yard TD catch from Marino with less than a minute left against the Jets in 1985? A game in which the previous seven weeks he was sidelined with a broken leg. A three time Pro Bowl selection (1983-1984, 1986), and one of Miami's all time leading receivers with 511 catches and 59 TD catches.

13. Dick Anderson 40...Safety (1968-1977)...Why this man is not in the Hall of Fame as well, I will never know. With Jake Scott, they were the most feared safety tandem in the 70s. Who can forget Dick's incredible 4 INT game against Pittsburgh in 1973? One of the true mainstays on Miami's 1972 Undefeated Season, he was the 1973 NFL Defensive Player of the Year, selected to three Pro Bowls (1972-1974), and he was selected to the 1970s All-Decade Team. Hopefully he will get in the Hall of Fame someday as a senior nominee because he sure as hell deserves it.

12. Mark Clayton 83...Wide Receiver (1983-1992)...If Terry Bradshaw can have his Hall of Fame receiver's Swann and Stallworth in the Hall with him, if Joe Montana and Steve Young can have their Hall of Fame receiver Rice in the hall with them (we all know Rice will get in), and if Troy Aikman can have his drug taking, hooker ****ing, Hall of Fame receiver Irvin in the hall with him, then Dan Marino deserves to have his receiver Mark Clayton in the Hall with him as well. Mark Clayton, a five time Pro Bowl selection (1984-1986, 1988, 1991), caught more TDs from Dan Marino than any other receiver with 79. His 18 TD catches in 1984 is still an AFC record today. With his partner in crime Mark Duper and Dan Marino throwing the ball, they changed the way and set the standard for quarterbacks and receivers for years to come. Many people, including Dolfans, say that Marino complemented Clayton and Duper. Maybe he complemented Duper, but not Clayton. Clayton was every bit as good as any top receiver back in the day. Hopefully someday, the Hall of Fame will realize what he did back in the day and put him in, because he deserves it just as much.

11. Larry Little 66...Guard (1969-1980)...Probably the best all around offensive lineman Miami ever had, proof of that is the fact he was voted NFL PA AFC Lineman of the year three times. Selected to five Pro Bowls (1970, 1972-1975), a seven time First or Second Team All-Pro, selected to the All-Decade team of the 1970s, and selected to the NFL Hall of Fame in 1993. Oh and he to was also apart of Miami's Championship years including 1972.

10. Dwight Stephenson 57...Center (1980-1987)...Quite honestly the most classy guy that Miami has ever had. Dwight Stephenson is also one reason why I can not stand the Jets. What happened to him in 1987 was absolutley tragic. His former college teammate Marty Lyons from Alabama (who played for the Jets), did an illegal chop block at his right knee and turned it into a mangled mess of torn knee ligaments and nerve damage, forcing him to retire early. But that did not keep him out of the Hall of Fame when he was elected in 1998. A five time Pro Bowl selection (1983-1987), and five time All-AFC selection who was recognized as the premier center of his time, in being selected to the All-Decade Team of the 1980s.

9. Jim Langer 62...Center (1970-1979)...Dwight Stephenson was not the first great center Miami was put with. Jim Langer was the undisputed leader of that great 1970s Miami offensive line. Played in a Dolphins record 128 straight games (will be broken by JT this coming year), was a six time Pro Bowl selection (1973-1978), six time First or Second Team All-Pro, and selected to the All-Decade Team of the 1970s. Being a part of Miami's glory days in the 70s helped with his induction into the NFL Hall of Fame in 1987.

8. Jason Taylor 99...Defensive End (1997-current)...What? Were you reading down this list and wondered where good ol' JT would be? Of course I was going to put him in this list. I bet you did not expect that I would put him this high. I have him this high, because he is already considered one of the best defensive players today, and if he continues to keep doing what he is doing, he could go down as not only the greatest defensive player in Dolphins history, but one of the greatest in the history of the NFL. He is currently the Dolphins all time sack leader with 106 (and counting), has scored seven defensive TDs which is tied for most ever by a defensive lineman, including another tied NFL record with five of those TDs coming on fumble returns, and he is also the biggest ball hog on the Dolphin defense with 23 Career Fumble Recoveries (and counting). A five time Pro Bowl selection (2000, 2002, 2004-2006), four time First or Second team All-Pro, and of course, the 2006 NFL Defensive Player of the Year. And guess what guys...He ain't done yet. His resume keeps getting heavier and heavier for Hall of Fame consideration when he retires. He is one of two players currently on the Dolphins that have made that team remain competitive for the last decade (you know who the other player is, and I'm getting to him), and I will cry my eyes out on the day Jason retires. Notice I said retire, not leave the Dolphins, because I do not want to see Jason in a different football uniform. I want him to retire a Dolphin.

7. Bob Griese 12...Quarterback (1967-1980)...The first great quarterback Miami ever had. Was the undisputed leader of the Dolphins in the 1970s, and was certainly the most unselfish player in Dolphins history. Bob did not care if he threw 30 passes in a game or just 8 (like he did in Super Bowl VIII). His job was to hand the ball to his beast of a fullback in Larry Csonka and let him do all the work. When he was told to throw the ball, he did it accurately and efficiently. 25,092 Passing Yards and 192 TD Passes ain't bad for a run-first offense. Selected to two AFL All-Star games (1967-1968), six Pro Bowls (1970-1971, 1973-1974, 1977-1978), two time All-Pro, and three time All-AFC, Bob Griese is also one of only three players in team history to have his jersey number retired. A 1990 NFL Hall of Fame selection ain't bad either.

6. Nick Buoniconti 85...Linebacker (1969-1976)...I wish Nick Buoniconti spent his whole career with Miami. It pains me to say he played for...*ahem* the patriots...because statisticly he had a better career with them, mainly because he was in his prime. However on a brighter note, it shows how stupid the Patriots Organization was back then for sending him to Miami. He was like a fine wine, he only got better with age. Leader of our "No Name" Defense made his presence felt for many years in the 70s, helping Miami to its Super Bowl Titles and its 1972 Undefeated Season. A two time Pro Bowl selection (1972-1973) and was also voted to the All-Time AFL Team in 1970. As a senior nominee he was also selected to the Hall of Fame in 2001...I had the pleasure of being there as well.

5. Larry Csonka 39...Fullback (1968-1974,1979)...He was a monster. A beast. An indestructable force who would punch you in the mouth if you got in his way. Defenders were scared to death to tackle him. To this day, Larry Csonka is the only running back ever to have an unecessary roughness penalty called on him because of a defender who got hurt while bringing down Larry Csonka on a tackle. The Dolphins all-time leading rusher was selected to five Pro Bowls (1970-1974), a three time All-Pro, four time All-AFC, and was also named Super Bowl VIII MVP when he just ran all over the Minnesota Defense. Had his jersey number 39 retired and was selected to the NFL Hall of Fame in 1987 along side his teammate Jim Langer.

4. Zach Thomas 54...Linebacker (1996-current)...As much as I love Jason Taylor (and believe me, I do...ALOT), I love Zach Thomas even more. I will be a man and admit that I will cry myself to sleep night after night when Zach Thomas retires. I'm sick of ESPN or any other sport show that give all the credit to that criminal Ray Lewis, Tedy Bruschi because he has Brady with him, and that steroid taking overhyped Shawn Merriman. Zach Thomas has been critisized his entire career about being too small and too short. Now hes just considered..too GOOD. Zach has done so much for this franchise on and off the field, and he is one of the classiest guys I have ever met in my life. He and Jason have made the Dolphin defense, let alone the entire Dolphin team, competitve for the last ten years. Ray and Tedi may have their rings, but look what they have been put with. Look who Zach has been put with. Jason Taylor...NOTHING MORE!! Zach has been the most consistent linebacker over his tenure with the Dolphins. He has started and played in more games than any other Dolphin defender in team history (163 and counting). A seven time Pro Bowler (1999-2003, 2005-2006), a seven time First or Second Team All-Pro, the 1996 AFC Rookie of the Year, and a two time NFL Alumni Association Linebacker of the Year (1998, 2006). And the best part is...like Jason Taylor...HE AIN'T DONE. No doubt Zach will (and he better) get Hall of Fame consideration when he is all said and done, and I hope it is not anytime soon. And like Jason, I want to see Zach retire a Dolphin, and not play for anyone else. The only thing missing on both their resumes is that elusive ring, and I'm not giving up hope that they can still get it.

3. Don Shula...Coach (1970-1995)...All great players need a great coach, and we sure did get one. One thing all Dolphin fans can appreciate is that we have had only seven head coaches in our franchise history (Cam Cameron is our seventh). One reason for that is the stability that our franchise endured under Don Shula. In 26 years with the Dolphins, Don only experienced two losing seasons (1976, 1988), he won 11 AFC East Division Championships (1971-1974, 1979, 1981, 1983-1985, 1992, 1994), 5 AFC Championships (1971-1973, 1982, 1984), and 2 Super Bowl Championships (1972-1973) including Miami's perfect 1972 Season. Selected to the Hall of Fame in 1997, Don Shula still to this day remains a part of the Dolphin Organization and still makes contributions to make this team better.

2. Joseph "Joe" Robbie...Founder/Owner (1966-1989)...Sometimes we forget that some of the greatest Miami Dolphins of all time...never played on the field nor coached our team. A lot of people forget on how great Joe Robbie was for the Dolphins. If it wasn't for him, we would of never had a football franchise in Miami. If it wasn't for him, the Dolphins would not of become the "AFL / AFC" juggernaut it was in the 70s. Joe Robbie also built the $115 Million Dollar stadium named after him, but today is now called Dolphin Stadium which I think is wrong. It should be the sole stadium for only the Dolphins (i can't wait till we kick the marlins out), but it should remain Joe Robbie Stadium because its the house he built. God Bless your soul Joe Robbie and thank you.

1. Dan Marino 13...Quarterback (1983-1999)...Was there ever any doubt who would be my number one Dolphin of all time? In my opinion, no single player in the history of this franchise has had more of an impact on the city of Miami, the franchise itself, and the fans of this great team than Dan Marino. Dan Marino for 17 years poured his heart, blood, guts, and soul for this team. For 17 years, Marino carried this franchise on his back and the success of this franchise weighed solely on his shoulders. And during his entire career, Dan Marino launched a 17 year assault on the NFL record books, that didn't cease until every meaningful mark was his, and in doing so, set the standard for generations of quarterbacks yet to come. I dont care if Brett Favre or Peyton Manning break Marino's records or not. Neither one of them can hold a candle to the type of methodical, consistent, and accurate throwing that Marino has done throughout his career. 61,361 Passing Yards, 4,967 Completions on 8,358 Attempts, 420 TD Passes, 147 Wins, 63 Games with 300 Yards Passing, 37 4th Quarter Come-from-behind wins, 5,084 Passing Yards and 48 TD Passes in a single season, are just a few of the many records that Marino accomplished and may never be duplicated again (Peyton and Brett did excede some of them). Marino retired as the NFL's most prolific passer in NFL history holding or being tied with more than 30 NFL Passing Records. He was the 1983 NFL Rookie of the Year, 1984 NFL MVP, 1994 NFL Comeback Player of the Year, a nine time Pro Bowl Selection (1983-1987, 1991-1992, 1994-1995), nine time First or Second Team All-Pro, six time All-AFC, and had his jersey number 13 retired. His induction in the NFL Hall of Fame in 2005 was one of the best celebrations I was ever a part of. No doubt in my mind, Dan Marino is, was, and will forever be, the greatest Miami Dolphin we may ever have had.
 
May I suggest the following additions to the list:

1. Does anyone remember who played LT before Richmond Webb? His name was John Giesler. He played at LT from 79 - 88 and was starting there when Dan had those two unbelievable seasons from 84 -86. I think he merits being in the top 50.

2. Not all of the credit for protecting Dan's blind side through the 90's should go to Richmond Webb. Certainly a vast majority but not all. He did have help on the left side all those years. During most of the 90's (90 - 97) that help was provided by Keith Sims. He belongs in the top 50 somewhere,

3. I noticed that out of the 50 there were only a few of safties listed. Scott and Anderson surely belong in the top 50. But how can you choose Marion without choosing one of the leaders of the "Killer B's" Glen Blackwood? (79 - 87) Along with brother Lyle considered the best Dolphin safety tandem since Scott and Anderson. Counting the strike shortened season of 82 from 80 - 87had 29 picks including (2) 6 pick seasons in 84 and 85. He also returned punts all 8 years with the team. If marion is at 42 G. Blackwood should be in the 38 - 40 range if not higher.
 
Don't like your list at all, but sincerely thank you for posting. IMO, you overrate kickers(Mare? lol) and current players.
 
May I suggest the following additions to the list:

1. Does anyone remember who played LT before Richmond Webb? His name was John Giesler. He played at LT from 79 - 88 and was starting there when Dan had those two unbelievable seasons from 84 -86. I think he merits being in the top 50.

2. Not all of the credit for protecting Dan's blind side through the 90's should go to Richmond Webb. Certainly a vast majority but not all. He did have help on the left side all those years. During most of the 90's (90 - 97) that help was provided by Keith Sims. He belongs in the top 50 somewhere,

3. I noticed that out of the 50 there were only a few of safties listed. Scott and Anderson surely belong in the top 50. But how can you choose Marion without choosing one of the leaders of the "Killer B's" Glen Blackwood? (79 - 87) Along with brother Lyle considered the best Dolphin safety tandem since Scott and Anderson. Counting the strike shortened season of 82 from 80 - 87had 29 picks including (2) 6 pick seasons in 84 and 85. He also returned punts all 8 years with the team. If marion is at 42 G. Blackwood should be in the 38 - 40 range if not higher.

No doubt both of those men were good for Miami, but thats all that they were good. Believe me when i tell you that I did not forget about those two indiviuals. But Brock Marion has been to three pro bowls with Miami, Lyle and Glenn combined - none. Jon Geisler i did not forget either, nor did I forget Keith Sims. One reason why I choose not to list Keith Sims was because many people say (and agree) that Webb complemented Sims, and he did. Even after SIms left the team and richmond was still there with a different person at his side, Rich was still protecting Danny better than ever. I respect your choices, and all three are worthy, just not worthy to me. i hope u understand.
 
Nice job man and a nice read. I can't say I agree with everyone on the list or where you placed them, but there is one or two glaring omissions IMO.

Where's Ricky? I know he's a topic for much debate on these boards but he's been nothing but stud on the field for us, racking up some monster numbers in a short time. I'm just saying....

No Richmond Webb?? He was essential in watching Dan's blind side for some 10 years or so. Seems he should have earned a spot on your list somewhere. I know he's on mine.

Someone above mentioned T-Buck... While I did love him while he was here, I think I see your reasoning for not including him.. He was only here for a short time and was used to transition Surtain into a starting role. Leaving him on more of a "mentor" role.

Anyways man... I'm not trying to criticize ya or anything. I applaud your dedication and effort and enjoyed the read.

:dolphins:
 
No doubt both of those men were good for Miami, but thats all that they were good. Believe me when i tell you that I did not forget about those two indiviuals. But Brock Marion has been to three pro bowls with Miami, Lyle and Glenn combined - none. Jon Geisler i did not forget either, nor did I forget Keith Sims. One reason why I choose not to list Keith Sims was because many people say (and agree) that Webb complemented Sims, and he did. Even after SIms left the team and richmond was still there with a different person at his side, Rich was still protecting Danny better than ever. I respect your choices, and all three are worthy, just not worthy to me. i hope u understand.

No problem everyone is entitled to their opinon.
 
Back
Top Bottom