BlueFin said:
...its the real thing that trips him up, and big games/playoff games are even worse...
So coaching, Defense, O-Line, and Special Teams played no part in these big game losses? Listen, I would LOVE to have a pro bowl QB in there, and if Feeley can somehow become that, then I am all for it. But Jay is not
THE reason the team is what it is today, therefore I really don't think the "Anybody but Jay" argument makes much sense. You saw what happened to Lucas behind that line, the next year you saw what happened to Griese. But of course, it can't be coaching, lack of o-line talent, or scheme, its ALL the QBs fault. Because Favre never throws a Pic, because Culpepper never overthrows a receiver, because Mcnabb never fumbles, and because Marino never took a sack.
Jay's biggest problem is his accuracy, that can be helped with coaching and work on Mechanics. If Trestman is as good as he is supposed to be then would it not stand to reason that Jay could come out in '04 as a much improved QB?
I'm not saying that it will happen, but I am also not willing to rule out the possibility(especially if D-Bos plays well).