On paper, it looks like Miami is a better team than New England through three games.
- According to the SIMPLE RATING SYSTEM, Miami is a good team (7.1 rating) while New England is the worst team in the NFL (-18.5 rating). The SRS isn't a super in-depth tool, but it's been around forever and is typically pretty reliable for showing the relative strengths of football teams.
- In passing offense, edge to Miami. Miami is averaging 9.9 yards per attempt (2nd in the NFL), has a passer rating of 128.7 (3rd), and has 8 passing touchdowns (T-3rd). New England is averaging 6.4 yards per attempt (22nd), passer rating 93.9 (14th) and has 6 passing touchdowns (T-10th).
Worth noting that New England has not been prolific throwing the ball, but has still produced touchdowns despite a 1-2 record.
- In passing defense, Miami is giving up 7.6 yards per attempt (T-19th), but allowing a league-best passer rating of 65.6. Miami has allowed just 2 TDs (T-1st) and has scored 7 interceptions (T-1st). The Patriots allow 7.1 yards per attempt (T-13th), opposing passer rating 93.9 (17th), have given up 7 passing TDs (T-24th), and have 3 interceptions (T-8th).
Miami's pass defense has allowed yardage, but has been stingy in the red zone and has a lot of interceptions. I'll take that trade, personally. New England's pass defense has been average.
- Miami and New England have both been marginal running the ball. Both teams are tied for 17th in the league with a 4.0 YPC average.
- Miami is 2nd in run defense at 3.3 yards per attempt, while New England is tied for 22nd with a 4.7 Y/A against. Miami has allowed two rushing TDs to New England's one.
- Miami is averaging 25 points per game, New England only 19.
- Miami has allowed only 52 points in three games, while the Patriots have allowed 77 points.
Looking at everything, I think the big difference between the Patriots and the Dolphins is big plays. Miami has created big plays on offense, while New England has not. NE's longest passing play: 30 yards. Longest rushing play: 15 yards. Miami's also been intercepting the football at a ludicrous rate.
I think if this game was anything but "at the Patriots," we would have a much different feeling about it.