PFF/Scouting Megathread | Page 5 | FinHeaven - Miami Dolphins Forums

PFF/Scouting Megathread

i

8. Will Howard, Ohio State

Height: 6-foot-4 | Weight: 236 pounds
Class: Senior | Projected range: Mid Day 3

Best team fit: Las Vegas Raiders

Where he excels: There wasn't a prospect who did more for his draft stock during the College Football Playoff than Howard. Following his worst performance of the season against Michigan in the regular-season finale, he threw for 1,150 passing yards, eight touchdowns and two interceptions during the Buckeyes' four-game run to win the national championship.

Howard was comfortable in the pocket and scanned through his progressions efficiently. His accuracy impressed me the most, as he completed over 80% of his passes in two of the four games (Tennessee and Notre Dame). Howard's growth was evident, and he boosted his stock multiple rounds during Ohio State's championship run.

He took advantage of the Buckeyes' many playmakers in 2024 after transferring from Kansas State, throwing for 4,010 yards, 35 touchdowns and 10 interceptions. He added another seven scores on the ground. Howard is a dual-threat passer with a good enough arm and the mobility to be an extension of the run game. His 89.6 QBR led all passers in the FBS.

Howard performed a 65-pass script in front of all 32 teams at Ohio State's pro day. He showed efficiency down the field and over the middle, two types of throws that were emphasized during the workout. "He's big, mobile, and just look how that team responded to his hot run late in the year," an AFC scout said following the workout.

Where he needs work: Many of Howard's warts show up when defenses speed up his processing. He tends to drop his eyes and immediately look for running lanes. He must become more patient and read progressions even at the hint of pressure.

Another factor is how open the Buckeyes' targets tend to be when making completions, as 34.8% of Howard's attempts last season were deemed as wide open, the ninth-highest mark in the FBS. Scouts want to see more throws into tight windows or contested coverages because that's what he'll have to do in the NFL.

Howard struggled with his ball placement at the combine, especially on dig routes over the middle. The lack of familiarity with the receivers in Indy showed, as his accuracy was sporadic and he had trouble throwing to spots. QBs at the combine often struggle in syncing up with the timing of receivers they've never worked with, but Howard's issues are worth noting.
i

9. Dillon Gabriel, Oregon

Height: 5-foot-11 | Weight: 205 pounds
Class: Senior | Projected range: Mid Day 3

Best team fit: Miami Dolphins

Where he excels: Gabriel was one of the most productive quarterbacks in college football history, as the left-handed passer threw for 18,722 yards and 155 touchdowns over six college seasons, including stints at UCF (2019-21) and Oklahoma (2022-23) before he transferred to Oregon. He thrived with the Ducks, leading them to a 13-0 regular-season record and a Big Ten championship this past season.

His completion percentage increased each season of his career, and his 72.9% in 2024 ranked third in the FBS. Gabriel is at his best when he can attack underneath voids in defenses, which helps him take advantage of space in shallow areas while mixing in occasional deep shots.

He displayed those traits in the last two days of Senior Bowl practices. His touch, anticipation and accuracy were noteworthy, as he had multiple layered throws that caught my attention. He understands his limitations and is able to see windows before they open and throw the ball to spots he expects targets to reach.

Where he needs work: Gabriel has below-average arm strength and throws a lot of perimeter screens and short routes intended to generate yards after the catch. He averaged only 6.5 air yards per attempt, which ranked 122nd out of 129 qualified passers. These short passes are often easy throws, as Gabriel threw 36% of his passes to wide-open receivers, the fourth-highest rate in the FBS.

He didn't have a lot of velocity behind his throws at the combine, either, but his anticipation and drop timing were noteworthy. That anticipation -- which we saw with him throwing the ball prematurely on several routes in Indianapolis to time it up -- is necessary with his lack of arm strength.

He also endured an adjustment period at the Senior Bowl, struggling to take snaps cleanly from under center during the first day before playing better the next two. He will need to be in an offense that uses multiple RPOs and takes advantage of the middle of the field to capitalize on his quick release, accuracy and split-second decision-making.


i

10. Max Brosmer, Minnesota

Height: 6-foot-2 | Weight: 217 pounds
Class: Senior | Projected range: Late Day 3/UDFA

Best team fit: New Orleans Saints

Where he excels: Brosmer made the FCS-to-FBS transition quite nicely, throwing for 2,828 passing yards, 18 touchdowns and six interceptions this past season while showing steady growth. That followed a great career at New Hampshire, where he racked up 8,467 passing yards and 68 touchdowns in four seasons, including an FCS-best 3,459 yards in 2023.

Brosmer is a quick passer with unwavering confidence and a constant chip on his shoulder. He has an average arm but gets the ball out quickly. Both his completion percentage (66.5%) and off-target percentage (9.4%) ranked in the top 25 of the FBS and demonstrated his understanding of how to place the ball in tight coverage.

Brosmer had an impressive showing during the final two days of practices at the Shrine Bowl. His accuracy and decision-making in the red zone were among the best of the group. He consistently played on time and even squeezed multiple passes into tight windows against different types of coverages.

If I had to circle one QB who could be a popular candidate for a Round 6 or 7 flier, it would be Brosmer. He shares similar traits to longtime NFL backups who spend a decade or more in the league.

Where he needs work: Brosmer's inconsistent drive strength on throws shows on tape and was noticeable at the combine, as some of his passes tail off as they get closer to their targets, especially over the middle. He also is prone to hanging onto the ball too long when looking for a bigger play instead of checking down. That results in sacks, as he took 26 last season, 32nd most in the FBS.


i

11. Kurtis Rourke, Indiana

Height: 6-foot-4 | Weight: 220 pounds
Class: Redshirt senior | Projected range: Late Day 3/UDFA

Best team fit: Indianapolis Colts

Where he excels: Rourke has quietly created interest in NFL circles, as he racked up 7,651 passing yards and 61 total touchdowns (50 passing, 11 rushing) in five seasons at Ohio before transferring to Indiana. He had 3,042 passing yards, 29 touchdowns and five interceptions in 2024, helping lead the Hoosiers to their first College Football Playoff appearance. His 69.4% completion percentage ranked eighth in the FBS, and multiple NFL decision-makers I've spoken to have taken note of his improvement.

"Why aren't more people talking about this guy?" a scouting director for an AFC team said during the season. "He's had nothing but success on two levels, and there hasn't been any drop-off since he moved up."

Where he needs work: Rourke needs to be more efficient through his progressions. There are times when he gets stuck on the first or second read instead of eliminating them quickly based on pre- and post-snap structures. Hanging on to those routes with the hope they come open resulted in him missing other open options or being forced to escape avoidable pressure.

There are also injury concerns with Rourke, who played with a torn right ACL last season and underwent surgery in January. He did not throw at the combine, as he's still recovering from the surgery. He played all season on the injury, which was the second time he tore his right ACL. He originally injured the knee in 2022 while playing at Ohio.


i

12. Riley Leonard, Notre Dame

Height: 6-foot-4 | Weight: 216 pounds
Class: Senior | Projected range: Late Day 3/UDFA

Best team fit: Baltimore Ravens

Where he excels: Leonard spent the first three seasons of his career (2021-23) at Duke, where he passed for a combined 4,450 yards, 24 touchdowns and 10 interceptions. He transferred to Notre Dame with considerable expectations.

A dual-threat passer, Leonard finished his only season with the Irish throwing for 2,861 yards, 21 touchdowns and eight interceptions while adding another 906 yards and 17 scores on the ground. Leonard is a quick-game operator who thrives in a timing-based offense. He excels when he gets the ball out quickly, and his 78.7 QBR last season ranked 12th in the FBS.


He has more than enough mobility to escape and create outside of the structure of the offense. He's also a tough runner on designed QB runs. Excluding sacks, Leonard's 1,012 rushing yards were the eighth most among QBs.

Where he needs work: The Irish offense didn't venture to the intermediate or deeper parts of the field. Leonard averaged only 7.1 air yards per passing attempt (83rd in FBS), which shows that the team stayed in the underneath areas. He was asked to throw deeper passes at the combine, and the lack of drive strength on the throws was apparent, especially when he had to step into passes and display velocity.

When the initial option isn't open, Leonard tends to hang on to the ball or immediately drop his eyes to look for available running lanes. He needs to have more play patience by continuing to stay on schedule through the next steps of his progressions.
 
Nice Stuff. Question as I am having a case of de ja vu, all this info is copied from analysts etc from ESPN or NFL.com right?
 
Nice Stuff. Question as I am having a case of de ja vu, all this info is copied from analysts etc from ESPN or NFL.com right?
Insider, PFF, ToddMcShay and another paid scouting site. These are parts of the premium articles, just as much as I’m allowed to post anyone can pm me for the whole articles, not the free ones since everyone can see and has access to those.

BTW I’m doing them all in copy paste format so you and a few others don’t have to zoom in lol
 
It’s a good article, but the reason Nolen is ahead of Peebles is because he is 25 months younger. Teams see a guy who will turn 24 before his rookie season starts as pretty much maxed out potential wise.

The Emmanwori vs Winston Jr is a legitimate question though. Honestly I don’t think we draft a safety with our top picks either ways.
It may be one reason, but it's not the only reason.
 
4. CHOP ROBINSON, Penn State (6-3, 255, 4.51, 1): Third-year junior spent 2021 at Maryland and 2022-’23 in Happy Valley. “Love him,” one scout said. “I see Chop every bit as good as Turner. Sky’s the limit. He’s why coaches get paid. Now you’ve got some work to do with him. You get annoyed because he doesn’t have a (lot) of production this year (four sacks, 15 tackles in 10 starts) but he only played 50% of their defensive snaps. They rotate the hell out of guys.” Able to rush equally well from both sides. “Must be an ambidextrous kid,” a second scout said. “I’m telling you, you don’t find that. He’s got a burst off the edge that’s rare. This is one of the few players you will ever see that can slip and dip and make the L move at the proper angle and depth of the quarterback, and he can do it from the left and right sides. And he can play the run. He’s not a hit-and-shed guy. He’s an escape guy. He runs off blocks. He doesn’t defeat blocks but he’s so quick and athletic he doesn’t have to beat on ‘em. He can escape and pursue down the line. This is what everybody’s looking for.” His 10-8 broad jump tied for the longest at the position. “He’s sudden, explosive, plays his ass off,” a third scout said. “Michigan couldn’t block him; they couldn’t even get their hands on him. That’s exactly why they started running the ball every play.” Started 11 of 35 games, finishing with 60 tackles (20 for loss), 11 ½ sacks, three forced fumbles and three passes defensed. “This Chop Robinson is the most overrated player in the draft,” a fourth scout said. “The comp is Bryce Huff. He’s the perfect example of a guy running a (fast) 40-yard dash. The way he’s being talked about, I thought they were talking about Lawrence Taylor. It makes no sense to me. If you told me third or fourth round, I’d get it. But first round? He's not even very big. Michigan ran right at that kid and he had no answer.” Arms were 32 ½, hands were 9 1/8. “He’s like Myles Garrett,” said a fifth scout. “He has the most potential but he doesn’t finish. He just doesn’t make plays.” From Gaithersburg, Md. “He reminded me of Haason Reddick and that (Arnold) Ebiketie that came out of Penn State (second round, 2022) and has been doing well at Atlanta,” a sixth scout said.
As a GM, if I knew this scout was working for my team, I'd sh*t can his useless arse.
 
Article boy fetch me last years rankings from these guys for edge and tackle. This dudes rankings are pretty different compared to the general media, want to see his previous work and accuracy if possible.
Article boy? Fetch me? Good gawd that is pretty fuking disrespectful. He's not your fuking dog. He's putting in a lot of time and effort to consolidate all this info in one thread to make it easy for us. Show some appreciation.
If I were him, I'd tell you to shove it where the sun doesn't shine.
 
Here’s his Patrick Paul and Jaylen Wright writeups

11. PATRICK PAUL, Houston (6-7 ½, 332, 5.18, 2-3): Longest arms at the position (36 ¼). “He’s an interesting guy because of his length,” said one scout. “He’s a left tackle-right tackle. He’s got just a unique, interesting way of playing. His hand placement is not great but he gets the job done. There’s some upside there from a physical tools standpoint. Second-third round type.” Lightly recruited out of Houston, Paul stayed home for college. He won the LT job in his second season (2020) but an ankle injury cost him the final six games. Started 39 games at LT from 2021-’23. “When is the last time the University of Houston had an offensive tackle?” said a second scout. “You’ve got to go back to the New England guy, Sebastian Vollmer, and that’s a long time ago (2009-’16).” Hands were just 9 3/8. “Fool’s gold,” a third scout said. “I just don’t see it. I don’t see the combative spirit.

4. JAYLEN WRIGHT, Tennessee (5-10 ½, 210, 4.38, 3): Third-year junior led the Volunteers in rushing the past two seasons in an Air Raid offense. “He’s a slippery, darter-type runner that is highly efficient,” one scout said. “Has speed, quickness and vengeance. Will finish runs. He’s tough. Not into dodging when the picture becomes cloudy. Can elude in tight spaces. Can get to daylight. Not a punishing runner but very proficient with his style. Functional as a receiver but not as a blocker. His weakness would be the power to move piles and break tackles, pass pro and routes.” Fastest back in the draft. “More of a big-play, straight-line guy,” said a second scout. “Does have good hands. Of all the backs, this guy might be the most explosive. He’s not elusive.” Finished with 368 carries for 2,297 (6.2) and 18 TDs plus 30 receptions. His 7.4 average in 2023 led FBS. “He’s fast but I’m not going there,” a third scout said. Led the top 25 backs in the broad jump (11-2). From Durham, NC
As I recall, McGinn also included Mo Kamara among his Edge rushers. If you feel like pasting it here, too.
 
As I recall, McGinn also included Mo Kamara among his Edge rushers. If you feel like pasting it here, too.
Yea I put it one of the later posts…I had heard of Bob McGinn but a couple of your posts quoting him actually got me to subscribe and man is it worth every cent. Some of the best analysis I’ve seen on any site, thanks for putting me on appreciate it.
 
Went back even further, starts off at 2022 draft. Ezukamna didn’t make the cut at WR that year. Cam Smith was just a bad pick unless he makes a serious turn around this year, not sure why they are drafting divas when we have the biggest diva in the NFL in Reek already on the team. Seems like Smith was already getting a reputation as a crybaby to the point a few teams took him off their board.

Oh Grier you silly little man.

9. CHANNING TINDALL, Georgia (6-2, 228, 4.50, 3): Played 50 games in four seasons but never had a start. “They rotate their linebackers just like their defensive linemen,” said one scout. “You can feel his speed, not only see it. Going sideline to sideline. Explosive collision tackler. Strikes with force. Uncoils on blocks. Not a real big guy, but plays bigger than he is. He can run vertically with tight ends and backs. Has some special-team value because he played it (all four years). Second round is where he ends up. Mike and will flex.” His 42-inch vertical led the position. “He gets locked on a guy and it’s over,” said a second scout. “When he arrives he is not in a pleasant disposition. His issue is he’s not smart. You just worry about him mentally. Might end up being a one-spot guy.” Finished with 108 tackles (16 for loss) and 12 sacks. His best season was last season. “That dude’s going early because he can run,” a third scout said. “He’s going to be like Bobby Wagner or somebody. You hope and pray it clicks when he gets to the NFL.” Wonderlic was 20. “He worked out crazy like all those Georgia guys did,” said a fourth scout. “They use him to do one thing: run in a straight line. That’s all the guy does. They blitz him straight line. He runs over there in a straight line. They drop him to a spot. He plays hard and can run, but this guy doesn’t have instincts, he’s stiff and he’s small. All those Georgia guys play their ass off. He’d be a late (round) guy for me.” From Columbia,

7. CAM SMITH, South Carolina (6-0 ½, 183, 4.37, 1-2): Started 19 of 33 games over four seasons. Probably lined up as much in the slot as outside. “Thin-framed guy,” one scout said. “Smooth, twitchy athlete. Good speed, and I really like his instincts. He can match up with top receivers. Not the strongest guy. Not a real physical guy. Not great in the run game.” Finished with 91 tackles, six picks and 24 PBUs. “He can play,” a second scout said. “He’s just a little bit of a live wire. Emotional would be a safe word to (describe) him.” Scouts from five teams expressed reservations about his makeup. “Diva, high maintenance,” said one scout. “Just not good enough to deal with all his bullshit.” One team removed him from their draft board. “He’s got anger-management issues,” said a third scout. “Be hard to coach this guy.” Wonderlic of 20. “He’s a good athlete — just undisciplined,” a fourth scout said. “He is talented. Second round. Too many good corners ahead of him.” From Blythewood, S.C.

5. DEVON ACHANE, Texas A&M (5-8 ½, 189, 4.30, 2-3): Third-year junior. “Quick, tough, aggressive,” said one scout. “Has really good hands. He will step up and chip block and stick his nose in there, but he gets run over a lot. Has open-field elusiveness.” Posted 19 on the Wonderlic, the best score among the top 10 backs. “He’s a small back that runs like a big back,” a second scout said. “He is as fast as they come. Got contact balance. A lot of these small backs that are as fast as he is have a tendency to bounce everything outside. This guy, for a small back, puts his foot in the ground and gets it up inside the tackles. He’s not always trying to outrun the edge; he’s going forward. A rotational guy. He’s not too far behind the Alabama kid (Gibbs).” Finished with 369 carries for 2,376 (6.4) and 21 TDs plus 65 receptions and 5 TDs. “Pure gimmick speed guy,” said a third scout. “Can catch the ball out of the backfield. Everybody likes him because he ran so fast but he’s a gimmick guy. He’s not a real runner. He’s a midget. This is the National Football League.” From Missouri City, Texas.


And the player I think we all wanted over Tindall that year and went the next pick to the Chiefs

6. LEO CHENAL, Wisconsin (6-2 ½, 249, 4.62, 3): Two-year starter declared a year early. “If he’s in an old classic 3-4, thump-the-crap-out-of-them scheme, he’ll be fine,” one scout said. “I don’t know about the coverage and the range stuff. He needs to be playing downhill. He’s big and thick. All that muscle is manufactured. It does affect him when he’s going backwards. I think fourth round is his sweet spot.” Executed punishing, well-timed blitzes beautifully in 2021 when he notched eight of his 12 sacks. “Team MVP,” another scout said. “They said he played in the 260s during the season. Tested well. Very competitive. Plays with a high motor. Shows heavy hands to shock and slip blocks. Strong wrap (tackler) and can deliver a blow. Really effective as a blitzer either coming from depth at linebacker or when he’d mug up in an ’A’ gap. Has coverage concerns in zones. Sucked up on play-action. Lack of ball production in coverage (two passes defensed). More of a starting two-down, old-school Mike. He brings blitz ability, but I’d have to see more development in coverage to play on third down. Third or fourth round. I don’t want to say these guys are dinosaurs per se but …” Finished with 181 tackles (26 ½ for loss). “Struggles to change directions in coverage,” a third scout said. “Struggled flipping his hips. I wouldn’t want him in man. He’s right on the fringe of being a starter, but I do think he is.” Posted the highest Wonderlic (34) of the top 30 linebackers. “He could do some things on third down,” a fourth scout said. “But I don’t think he’ll be the guy calling the defense.” From Grantsburg, Wis.
I was all in on wanting Chenal that year. Just as strongly as I wanted TJ Watt over Charles Harris. I think these instances indicate one thing anyway. If you have two guys at the same position, fairly evenly matched, and one is from Wisconsin, you take the Wisconsin guy.
 
Yea I put it one of the later posts…I had heard of Bob McGinn but a couple of your posts quoting him actually got me to subscribe and man is it worth every cent. Some of the best analysis I’ve seen on any site, thanks for putting me on appreciate it.
You're welcome.
The best thing about it is that McGinn, with all his years as a reporter, has dozens of scout contacts. It takes a lot of effort to assemble all those various scouts' opinions on any given player into one write-up. The vast disparity we often see with most players between the scouts should give us some insight into why certain players go much earlier or much later than they were projected in the media.
 
Good job grier,cam smith lacks a physical presence when playing ball and has an attitude problem, sure why not Putz.

Tindall was an easy bust projection not sure how our guy that makes millions couldn’t see it
The thing with Tindall is it sounds like the scout who mentioned the mental part as being a concern got it right.
 
I agree there will be good value in the top 100.

Imagine if Grier didn't trade away pick 79 for Wright last year.

And if Wilkins had played one more game our second comp pick would be 99 instead of 135.


That would be 5 picks in the top 100 instead of 3.

If we don't like our options at 13 we should really trade down even if we don't get the best value as long as we acquire an extra day 2 draft pick.
Wright was a good value, which was why the trade was made. However, they never figured on Wilkins not playing enough snaps to secure a 3rd round comp pick. Had their crystal ball told them Wilkins would fall short of the snap count threshold, they may not have traded for Wright.
 
So reading some of his older stuff when he used to actually quote the scouts by name, heres one on Jack Campbell...so this guy has sources from direct scouts in our org

“He is the best guy I’ve seen in probably two or three years at stepping up and just crushing a guard or a fullback,” said Jeff Smith, the Central Plains scout for the Miami Dolphins. “He can buckle their knees and freeze them in a hole. His problem is, he’s still hung up on them when the back goes up.”
This Jeff Smith is no longer employed by the Dolphins. Dunno where he went. When they hire and fire scouts, it seldom ever makes the news. Here are their current scouts. Some have been with the team a long time, like Brockington.

Ron Brockington, Senior National Scout
Nathan Trott, National Scout
James Abrams, Senior Scout
Chase Leshin, Senior Scout
Matt Leitch, College Scout
Ricky Seale, College Scout
Grant Wallace, College Scout
Minh Luu, Player Personnel Coordinator
Beau Bell, Pro Scout
J.P. Correia, Pro Scout
Andy Howell, Pro Scout
Devon Smith, Player Personnel Scout
 
You're welcome.
The best thing about it is that McGinn, with all his years as a reporter, has dozens of scout contacts. It takes a lot of effort to assemble all those various scouts' opinions on any given player into one write-up. The vast disparity we often see with most players between the scouts should give us some insight into why certain players go much earlier or much later than they were projected in the media.
Yea that’s what I love, every player he gives perspectives from scouts that have differing opinions, so it’s great to see how varying the opinions can be. Also makes sense why we see teams passing up guys and it makes you scratch your head as it seems like a perfect fit, but there’s a lot of information we aren’t privy to that these front offices receive.
 
Last edited:
Jordan Reid’s strength and weaknesses for top 12 qbs… I didnt include the top 3 because there’s no way Grier is dumb enough to draft a QB in round 1 with all our holes right? Right??!?!

Has the Fins as the best landing spot for Dillon Gabriel


i

4. Jalen Milroe, Alabama

Height: 6-foot-2 | Weight: 217 pounds
Class: Junior | Projected range: Mid-to-late Day 2

Best team fit: Cleveland Browns

Where he excels: Milroe was the quarterback I was most impressed with from the pro day circuit. While he had a 65-pass throwing session, the highlight of his workout was his 40-yard dash. Scouts that I talked to had him running as fast as 4.41 seconds, and he will be one of the NFL's most dynamic quarterbacks from a mobility perspective. He also has a powerful arm which he has displayed during the predraft circuit.

Milroe found open targets in Alabama's system and could excel in an NFL offense that uses his running skills. He showed more patience from the pocket this past season, slowing down his internal clock and not scrambling as soon as pressure hits. He is a tremendously competitive runner who developed into one of the best dual-threat quarterbacks in the country. In 13 games, he threw for 2,844 yards, 16 touchdowns and 11 interceptions. He added 726 yards and another 20 scores on the ground, and his 78.4 Total QBR ranked eighth in the FBS.

I was in attendance for Milroe's performance against LSU, when he finished with 109 passing yards and 185 rushing yards with four touchdowns in a blowout victory. Multiple scouts that I talked to are intrigued by the former Alabama QB not only because of his unique traits, but also the potential of molding his game around them.

"He has so much potential, but it's going to take patience and true development over time to eventually see the end product," an NFC personnel director said. "There's no way he gets outside of the second round because of the traits, and someone with time on their side will love the challenge of developing him, especially in this QB class."

Where he needs work: Milroe's accuracy and feel in the short-to-intermediate areas of the field and throwing from all pre-snap platforms aren't quite developed, and he was inconsistent at the Senior Bowl and the combine. His rhythm and timing were thrown off by taking snaps under center, something he didn't often do at Alabama. He still needs a lot of refinement as a passer and the pre-snap mechanics of playing from different platforms will be an adjustment. Milroe also struggled with seeing defenders sinking into windows on shorter passes.

He also takes too long to get the ball out on throws in which he's asked to make pre-snap reads and execute. Milroe's 2.86-second time to throw ranked 92nd in the country, as Alabama's offense consisted primarily of deeper throws downfield. Another area in which he has struggled is throws against man coverage, with a 40.1 QBR that ranked 109th.


He's likely a couple of seasons away from being a full-time contributor. There have been flashes during the predraft process, but there's still a lot of inconsistency sprinkled in. The team that drafts Milroe will have to have patience and a clear plan that enables his development to play out long-term. He can likely be utilized in various packages as a periodic passer or on designed QB runs while he develops.


i

5. Kyle McCord, Syracuse

Height: 6-foot-3 | Weight: 218 pounds
Class: Senior | Projected range: Late Day 2 to Early Day 3

Best team fit: New York Jets

Where he excels: Many evaluators have been complimentary of McCord throughout the predraft process. "He was the best QB at the Shrine Game and it wasn't even close," an NFC North area scout said.

He carried that over to the combine with a steady throwing session. He shined with his ball placement, showing anticipation by throwing the ball to spots where his receivers could easily grab it. His physical traits aren't as gaudy as some of his counterparts, though his arm is stronger than I thought after watching him in person.

His performance on the predraft circuit is a continuation of the growth he showed at Syracuse. McCord had solid stats at Ohio State in 2023 (3,170 passing yards, 24 touchdowns and six interceptions) but didn't show high-upside, pro-ready attributes. But when I visited Syracuse practices during preseason camp, it was clear he looked more comfortable in first-year coach Fran Brown's scheme. The move paid off, as McCord had an FBS-leading 4,779 passing yards, 34 touchdowns and 12 interceptions last season.

McCord displayed quick decision-making, getting rid of the ball in 2.46 seconds on average, the seventh-fastest rate in the FBS. He understands his limitations and plays in structure, immediately taking what's available early in his progressions. But he also showed the ability to push the ball down the field, as his 36 completions on passes of 20 or more air yards led the FBS. I have a Round 4 grade on McCord, but he could hear his name called as early as the end of Day 2.

Where he needs work: While he showed drastic improvement at the combine, McCord still has room for growth in ball placement. He's effective at getting the ball to the correct spots on his reads, but locations within the strike zone tend to be unpredictable. His 11% off-target rate ranked 48th in the FBS.

"It's clear that he knows where to go with it, but receivers still have to work way too hard to catch it at times," an AFC national scout said during the season.

A nightmare five-interception performance against Pittsburgh in October highlighted many of McCord's flaws. Head-scratching decision-making when facing early pressure forced him into the worst game of his career. And his 12 interceptions were tied for fifth most in the FBS.


i

6. Tyler Shough, Louisville

Height: 6-foot-5 | Weight: 219 pounds
Class: Senior | Projected range: Late Day 2 to Early Day 3

Best team fit: Pittsburgh Steelers

Where he excels: Shough has traveled a long road, starting at Oregon in 2018, where he spent his first two seasons as a backup behind current Chargers quarterback Justin Herbert. He transferred to Texas Tech after the 2020 season, then again to Louisville before the 2024 season. Shough set career highs in passing yards (3,195) and touchdown passes (23) this past season along with six interceptions. He is a tall pocket passer and an accurate distributor.

He has clean footwork and drop timing and can execute multiple pre-snap mechanics. Shough can play from under center and out of the shotgun and isn't hesitant to test the deeper parts of the field, yet he shows a feathery downfield touch. His 21 completions on passes of 20 yards or more downfield ranked 23rd in FBS.

Shough's name is trending throughout the league, and many scouts have discussed him with me since the conclusion of the season. He has been praised for his perseverance and toughness as he battled back from multiple injuries in his career to emerge as one of the more intriguing options outside the early rounds.

Where he needs work: Even though he played seven seasons of college football, Shough hasn't mastered getting rid of the ball quickly. His 2.99 seconds to throw ranked 114th in the FBS. He must make quicker decisions and trust what he sees, especially in the intermediate areas of the field.

And speaking of experience, Shough turns 26 in September. Though he'll be one of the oldest prospects in the class, many teams I've spoken to see that experience as a positive. Don't be surprised to hear Shough's name called as early as Round 2 or 3.


i

7. Quinn Ewers, Texas

Height: 6-foot-2 | Weight: 214 pounds
Class: Senior | Projected range: Early-to-mid Day 3

Best team fit: San Francisco 49ers

Where he excels: Ewers threw for 2,665 yards, 31 touchdowns and 12 interceptions this past season, and his completion percentage of 65.8% ranked 26th in the nation. He played well against major opponents, with his best game of this past season coming in Week 2against Michigan, when he finished with 246 passing yards and three touchdowns. Another moment that scouts frequently bring up is his game-saving throw on fourth-and-13 in overtime of the College Football Playoff quarterfinal against Arizona State in the Peach Bowl. Multiple evaluators have applauded Ewers' tremendous poise in such a heightened moment.

Ewers sat out two games early in the season because of an abdominal strain before returning against Oklahoma in Week 7, throwing for 199 yards with a touchdown and an interception in a 34-3 win. He also had to deal with adversity beyond the injury. He was benched in the first half of Texas' Week 8 loss to Georgia for redshirt freshman Arch Manning, but returned after halftime to throw two touchdown passes.

"He's tough as nails mentally because all of the background noise is impossible to ignore," an AFC area scout said.

Ewers completed a 60-pass script at a heavily attended Texas pro day on March 25. As expected, his ball placement on underneath throws shined. But his most comfortable throws came off play-action, as Ewers excels when executing concepts that start with quick fakes out of the shotgun or play-action from under center. A scheme that incorporates those types of passes mixed with run-pass options will maximize his strengths.

Where he needs work: Texas' offense mostly shifted away from deep passes in 2024, going for more of a quick passing attack. Ewers threw a higher percentage of passes at or behind the line of scrimmage (34.2%) than all but seven of 129 qualified passers, and his 7.1 yards per attempt ranked 110th. Texas' downfield passing game was mostly nonexistent last season, depriving scouts of opportunities to see whether Ewers' downfield touch and accuracy had improved in games.

Ewers looked more comfortable at the combine with these types of passes, as he was able to connect frequently down the field. But he had some inconsistent moments during his pro day session pushing the ball down the field or moving off the original launch point.

Scouts have also flagged Ewers' tendency to panic when under duress. His 12.0 QBR when facing pressure ranked 83rd in the country, as he didn't show the awareness and suddenness to consistently escape a collapsing pocket. Durability is also another area NFL evaluators question; he sat out seven games because of injuries over the past three seasons.




This rather explains why Miami is also interested in Ewers.
 
Back
Top Bottom