PFF/Scouting Megathread | Page 10 | FinHeaven - Miami Dolphins Forums

PFF/Scouting Megathread

Latest draft buzz:

Where will the QBs land?

Fowler: The Titans have decided to stay in the No. 1 spot, and the entire league expects the pick to be Miami quarterback Cam Ward. They've done considerable homework on Ward, spent quality time with him and his family on multiple occasions and are comfortable with not only his football ability but also his makeup off the field. But what happens next in the QB class is anyone's guess. When I asked an NFL general manager how many QBs will go in the first round, he referenced the current Vegas line of 2.5 as "about right."

Finding a clear-cut home for Colorado's Shedeur Sanders is not easy. Many teams I've spoken to now expect Sanders to fall out of the top 10, though they also point to an outside chance that the Giants take him at No. 3. There isn't much momentum that the Saints will take him at No. 9. The Steelers have an appreciation for his game, but with big needs on defense and no second-round pick, they could eschew the position entirely at No. 21. However, multiple teams I've spoken to still have Pittsburgh loosely earmarked as an intriguing option for them.

Graziano: Yeah, the Steelers look like the spot to watch for Sanders if he's going to go in the first round. He made a strong positive impression on their coaching staff during the predraft process, and not having the second-round pick might actually mean the Steelers could stretch for a QB on Day 1.

But Pittsburgh has other needs -- most prominently defensive tackle and running back -- and could absolutely use its pick on one of the many well-regarded interior defensive linemen in this class. If the Steelers are going to go DT in the first round, my sense is they would prefer to trade down a bit and add another Day 2 selection if possible. They might need it if they're planning to address quarterback before the draft is over.

Fowler: The Steelers' QB plans are also complicated by a few factors -- even beyond the Aaron Rodgers uncertainty. I continue to hear Pittsburgh wants to take a swing on a quarterback in one of the next two drafts, and next year's class is considered stronger. I'm just not sure taking one in the first round in 2025 makes the most sense for them. Consider this: I asked an NFL offensive coordinator where Steelers quarterback Mason Rudolph would rank in this draft class, had he been coming out with the rest of the group. The coordinator placed him third.

Graziano: Pittsburgh's No. 21 pick is also one to watch for potential trade-ups by teams such as the Browns, Giants and Saints if Ward is still the only QB off the board at that point. Teams are keeping an eye on the Rams at No. 26 and might want to navigate in front of them. Los Angeles could quietly be in the market for one of the young QBs because Matthew Stafford, 37, is clearly on a year-to-year program at this point.

Fowler: One back-pocket thought I keep going back to: The Browns like Sanders' processing ability at the line of scrimmage. They also have 10 picks in the draft, including two third-rounders and four sixth-rounders. So packaging picks to trade into the middle-to-late first round seems feasible.

Graziano: Then there are the Giants. While I can't rule it out entirely, most of the people I talk to still don't expect the Giants to take a quarterback with the third pick. The more likely outcome is that they take Penn State edge rusher Abdul Carter or Colorado receiver/cornerback Travis Hunter -- whichever the Browns don't take at No. 2 -- and then try to use their second-round selection to solve their long-term QB problem. That could mean sitting tight and using the 34th pick on someone such as Ole Miss' Jaxson Dart or Alabama's Jalen Milroe, or even trading up into the first round to pick one Thursday night.

Much of the chatter I've heard in the past couple of days indicates a growing impression that Giants coach Brian Daboll prefers Dart over Sanders and the rest of the non-Ward passers on the board. I doubt they would take him at No. 3, but if they were to trade out of that spot, it's possible they could pick him later in the round. It's also worth noting that Giants GM Joe Schoen, not Daboll, is in charge of making the pick. Daboll's opinion is certainly significant in Schoen's final evaluation, but if the organization as a whole settles on Sanders or someone else, don't be surprised. As Daboll said in his news conference Monday, it's a collaborative process with a lot of people contributing opinions and evaluations.


Fowler: I got the same line from three different executives when I asked about Dart potentially going in the top 15: I don't expect it, but I also wouldn't be surprised. Teams are legitimately torn on Dart. While one will suggest his status as a potential first-round pick could be more of a media creation than reality, another believes he's tracking for the first round because of his arm talent, mobility and upside. The Saints, Steelers and Giants all seem like options here, and New Orleans, in particular, has done a lot of work on his evaluation.

Graziano: Dart is getting a lot of late buzz, and I don't think it would be a surprise at this point if he were the second quarterback taken. In addition to those three teams, I've also heard speculative connections to the Browns and Rams. It's possible that if he's the apple of someone's eye, there could be trade movement in the first round to secure him.

Fowler: Milroe, meanwhile, is still positioned to be an early Day 2 pick, though I've talked to a few executives in recent days who wonder if a team will trade into late-Round 1 for him. "I think someone will do it," an NFC executive said. The Raiders are on the radar, which would make sense; he could develop behind Geno Smith for a few years. The upside on Milroe is sizable. I spoke to long-established QB coach Jordan Palmer, who says Milroe checks the two most important boxes for a signal-caller: He's a competitive learner and a high achiever. Palmer and Milroe have worked over the past year on fluidity and connection to the ground as a passer, which should help his accuracy at the next level.

Three more QB-related notes:

Louisville's Tyler Shough has emerged late, with great arm strength and 6-foot-5 size. "He's my No. 2 quarterback," an AFC executive said. And one NFL general manager went as far as to say he would not be surprised if Shough went on Day 1. I've heard that some people with the Rams are very high on Shough (though they don't have a second-round pick), and the Giants have done a lot of work here, too.

While the Saints, Steelers and Giants have either worked out or met with Syracuse's Kyle McCord, other teams that've shown sneaky interest in him during the predraft process are the Jaguars and Rams. Some teams see him as more of a QB2, but you'd be surprised how many coaches have him rated highly in a class that's considered weaker and wide open. "He can read a defense, really smart, loves football, studies, can learn all the concepts, can make all of the throws," a veteran NFL assistant coach told me.

As far as midround options go, Pittsburgh has done a lot of work on Ohio State's Will Howard. The Colts, Jets and Raiders also have looked into Howard, whose play in the College Football Playoff helped his profile.


Fowler: Several industry sources believe the Patriots have an affection for LSU offensive tackle Will Campbell. Assuming Hunter and Carter are off the board, Campbell would represent a safe pick for New England at No. 4, and word is new coach Mike Vrabel is high on him. Campbell would provide New England the chance to reestablish its identity across the offensive line for quarterback Drake Maye.

Things get interesting at No. 5. Multiple teams picking in the top 10 are under the impression Jacksonville could go offense there. Boise State running back Ashton Jeanty is on the Jaguars' radar as the best offensive player available at that spot. He's on the proverbial short list. One of the GMs I spoke to thinks wide receiver isn't off the table for Jacksonville in the first round, as the team could pair Brian Thomas Jr. with someone such as Arizona's Tetairoa McMillan.

The Raiders have also been linked to Jeanty, but the Mason Graham connection could be one to watch at No. 6, too. The Michigan ties run deep with Graham, general manager John Spytek and minority owner Tom Brady. And Graham's lengthy video call with defensive line coach Rob Leonard featured a special cameo: Maxx Crosby. I talked to teams Sunday and Monday that still think offensive tackle (perhaps Texas' Kelvin Banks Jr. or Missouri's Armand Membou) will ultimately be considerations for Las Vegas, too.

Graziano: On the subject of Graham, my current belief is that the early part of Round 1 could be very heavy on defensive linemen. There are a ton of good edge rushers and pass-rushing defensive tackles this year. And in a draft where teams don't seem thrilled about the choices at quarterback, cornerback, offensive tackle and wide receiver, I wouldn't be surprised if a bunch of teams default to pass rusher on Day 1. It does sound like Jacksonville is thinking offensive playmaker (Jeanty, McMillan or even Penn State tight end Tyler Warren) at No. 5. But the Raiders (No. 6), Jets (No. 7), Panthers (No. 8) and Saints (No. 9) all look like teams that could select defensive lineman.

That means you could hear names such as Jalon Walker (Georgia), Mykel Williams (Georgia), Walter Nolen (Ole Miss), Kenneth Grant (Michigan), Derrick Harmon (Oregon), James Pearce Jr. (Tennessee), Mike Green (Marshall) and Shemar Stewart (Texas A&M) called early. That would make life interesting for the Falcons, who are sitting at No. 15 and desperate for defensive help in this draft. Could they try to trade up if the top defensive linemen start flying off the board?

Fowler: Walker as a top-10 pick seems viable. One executive whose team picks high in the draft said Walker's Thursday workout at UGA was "outstanding." Walker is firmly on the radar for Carolina at No. 8. And one industry source predicted that his floor is probably Atlanta's pick. Williams also is well positioned. While he might not go in the top 10, he's a legit option in the teens. Multiple teams told me Atlanta and Arizona (No. 16) are two to watch.

Offense could be the focus at the back of the top 10 and into the teens. The Bears (No. 10) have been linked to skill players such as Jeanty and Warren. If Jeanty is for some reason there at No. 10, the word is Chicago loves him. If not, multiple execs believe offensive tackle makes more sense. "Caleb Williams was sacked like 90 times last year," a veteran NFL personnel man said. (He was sacked 68 times, but point taken.)

Graziano: And many around the league believe the Cowboys are likely to take a wide receiver at No. 12. Dallas could have its pick of them -- outside of Hunter, of course. McMillan and Texas' Matthew Golden are the two names to watch if the Cowboys go that direction.

Here's another name to watch for Dallas, though, on the other side of the ball: Alabama linebacker Jihaad Campbell. He is extremely well regarded by teams and could go higher than expected if some team (Cowboys? 49ers? Colts?) loses out on its Plan A on Thursday night.

 
Fowler: Yeah, Campbell has a projected range of anywhere from late top 10 to the late teens. "He's a top-10 player in the draft, without question," an NFC executive said. "He's awesome. You just worry a little about the durability." Mounting injuries at Alabama, including a shoulder injury that prompted labrum surgery this offseason, are on teams' files as something to consider. One team believed to be very high on Campbell is the Buccaneers (No. 19). Perhaps Tampa Bay serves as a de facto floor for him. One scout from a team in the late first round admitted, "I hope he falls, for our sake."

A few more things I heard on Round 1, quick-hitter style:

Teams have some injury concerns with cornerback Will Johnson. He did not run a predraft 40-yard dash. While some franchises are wondering whether he'll be available in the back half of the first round, one AFC executive finds that hard to believe because of Johnson's strong body of work on the field.

The Dolphins (No. 13) have been linked to defensive backs in the first round, an obvious choice after losing safety Jevon Holland in free agency and amid trade speculation around cornerback Jalen Ramsey. Texas corner Jahdae Barron and Georgia safety Malaki Starks could be among the options there.

Multiple teams said they could see Michigan's Colston Loveland as the first tight end taken -- ahead of Warren. "Because of athleticism and upside," an AFC executive said. Both players have a chance to go pretty high, though.

Some execs have pegged Ohio State's Josh Simmons as the best pure OT in the class. "He probably had the best tape of any offensive tackle," a personnel director said. Teams I've checked with aren't overly concerned about his recovery from a torn patellar tendon.

Kentucky corner Maxwell Hairston is considered a riser as the draft approaches. "He's a first-round-graded player, easy," a veteran NFL defensive coach said. He has the speed (4.28-second 40 time) and instincts. And while his size (5-foot-11, 183 pounds) has been a slight concern for some evaluators, it shouldn't affect his stock much.

Several teams are anticipating a run on RBs at some point. North Carolina's Omarion Hampton could go earlier than expected. An executive said he believes Denver (No. 20) could be a pivot point for running backs. "I think [Hampton is] the best back, and I think that's who Denver is targeting," the exec said. Ohio State's TreVeyon Henderson could also go earlier than most think. Enough teams have him very high on their RB board, meaning late Round 1 isn't totally out of the question. Contenders such as the Texans, Chiefs and Commanders are looking to improve their ground games.

It's always fun to ask teams for their sleeper first-rounders -- names that would be a mild surprise to the common fan but not necessarily to those in the draft rooms. Here are a few I've heard: South Carolina defensive lineman T.J. Sanders, Minnesota offensive tackle Aireontae Ersery, Ohio State guard Donovan Jackson and East Carolina corner Shavon Revel Jr. (Kansas State corner Jacob Parrish and Texas A&M defensive lineman Shemar Turner are deeper sleepers mentioned for Day 2.)

The Giants' 2022 draft -- Schoen's first -- seems intrinsically tied to this year. If the Giants take Carter at No. 3, that puts 2022 first-rounder Kayvon Thibodeaux's future into focus. While the Giants appear undecided on whether to pick up Thibodeaux's fifth-year option, sources said New York is not expected to pick up offensive lineman Evan Neal's option. Declining Thibodeaux's option would represent a rough first draft for Schoen. But as one AFC executive sees it, the Giants could play Carter and Thibodeaux together, along with Brian Burns and Dexter Lawrence II, to try to recreate the glory days of the Giants under Tom Coughlin. They'd be trying to win with elite pass-rush depth.

Who are some names to watch on Day 2 and beyond?

Rittenberg: The draft projects to have Day 2 value at wide receiver, and among those who should hear their names called Friday is Washington State's Kyle Williams. He's smaller at 5-foot-11, 190 pounds but has explosive ability, averaging 17.1 yards per catch last fall. "He's a vertical charger, he's an over-the-top catcher," said Wake Forest coach Jake Dickert, who coached Williams at WSU. "But he really showed this last year how good he is with the ball in his hands. Everyone knew he could run and catch a vertical, but he took some screens, some hitches to the house, showed like, 'OK, this guy's pretty dynamic.'"

Staying with the pass catchers, LSU's Mason Taylor could be the third tight end selected after Warren and Loveland. He set team records for a tight end with 129 receptions for 1,308 yards and six TDs over three seasons. "Everybody thinks he's going to be kind of somewhere around [pick No.] 40 to 50, which is a pretty good deal," an LSU source said.

Graziano: This is a completely personal perspective, but the Day 3 marriage of team and player that I'm hoping to see is Florida defensive tackle Desmond Watson to the Eagles. Watson weighs 464 pounds -- 80-plus pounds more than the heaviest player in the NFL in 2024. He has said he's working on getting his weight down because he knows that will be his path to staying in the league. But he has incredible strength and agility for his size (36 bench press reps and a 25-inch vertical jump at his pro day). Couldn't you totally see Philadelphia finding a way to mold him into the kind of player who helps them win Super Bowls? And think about what Watson -- who actually had a carry and converted a first down on offense in Florida's bowl game last season -- would bring to the tush push play.

Rittenberg: Speaking of big players, Kentucky defensive tackle Deone Walker (6-foot-7 and 331 pounds) is a fringe top-100 prospect. Walker earned All-SEC honors in each of the past three seasons, and though his production declined a bit in 2024, he played the season with a fracture in his back. "If it got to Day 3, people I would assume would be clamoring to trade up for the first pick of [Round 4] to get him," a Kentucky source said. "You watch his freshman, sophomore film, there's a reason he was talked about as a preseason top-12 pick. So the ability and the talent is there."

One last note: Iowa prospects have a history of overperforming their draft positions, with Eagles defensive back Cooper DeJean (No. 40 in 2024) being the latest. Two Hawkeyes defenders who could follow the same route are safety Sebastian Castro and linebacker Jay Higgins, who are projected as Day 2 or Day 3 selections. Castro started three seasons and earned third-team All-America honors in 2023, while Higgins was a first-team All-America selection last fall and had 295 tackles over the past two seasons. "They'll get dinged for everything that's not football, but when you turn on the tape, that's what they're banking on," an Iowa staff member said.

Which teams could make trades?

Fowler: Multiple teams picking in the top 10 say the Browns are indeed getting calls about the No. 2 pick, as ESPN's Peter Schrager reported. But Cleveland is keeping completely quiet. Not taking Hunter would ultimately be a surprise to many, even some within the Browns' building. The Jets, meanwhile, could be open to trading back from No. 7, according to multiple teams.

The Texans (No. 25) are calling into the top half of the first round to potentially move up. While their target is unclear, one NFC executive predicts Houston is interested in Texas' Banks, trying to solve a clear need at offensive tackle. Teams behind Houston are also hearing from GM Nick Caserio, so it's possible the Texans are just doing their due diligence across the board. The Broncos (No. 20) are also looking to move up, as Adam Schefter noted. And while San Francisco (No. 11) has been linked to trade rumors, there isn't much buzz around the 49ers making a move as of now. If San Francisco targets defensive line, the 11th pick is a good spot to find someone.

Could Browns, Giants trade down for 'Godfather deal?'Peter Schrager says the Browns and Giants are listening to offers for the second and third picks in the NFL draft.
Graziano: I'm curious to see how the first round affects potential veteran trade talks. If the Bengals draft an edge rusher they love, does that make them more likely to honor Trey Hendrickson's trade request? Maybe get them to drop their demands and take a second-round pick for Hendrickson?

And if the Browns or Steelers whiff at quarterback, does that make them more likely to push Atlanta on a Kirk Cousins trade? Cousins has a no-trade clause and would prefer to wait until after the draft before approving any deal, so as to avoid a repeat of last year (when he signed with the Falcons before they drafted Michael Penix Jr. in the first round a month and a half later).

Also, if the Colts or some other tight end-needy team misses out on the top guys at that position, that could make them more likely to pursue an available veteran such as Baltimore's Mark Andrews or Philadelphia's Dallas Goedert.
 
Last edited:
Bob Mcginns top 100…he won the award last year getting 86/100 right.

OFFENSE (49)

Wide receivers (11) — Tetairoa McMillan, Arizona; Matthew Golden, Texas; Luther Burden, Missouri; Emeka Egbuka, Ohio State; Jayden Higgins, Iowa State; Jack Bech, Texas Christian; Jaylin Noel, Iowa State; Isaiah Bond, Texas; Jalen Royals, Utah State; Tony Horton, Colorado State; Savion Williams, Texas Christian.

Tight ends (6) — Tyler Warren, Penn State; Colston Loveland, Michigan; Elijah Arroyo, Miami; Mason Taylor, Louisiana State; Terrance Ferguson, Oregon; Harold Fannin, Bowling Green.

Tackles (10) — Will Campbell, Louisiana State; Armand Membou, Missouri; Kelvin Banks, Texas; Josh Conerly, Oregon; Aireontae Ersery, Minnesota; Josh Simmons, Ohio State; Ozzy Trapilo, Boston College; Charles Grant, William & Mary; Marcus Mbow, Purdue; Cameron Williams, Texas.

Guards (7) — Tyler Booker, Alabama; Jonah Savaiinaea, Arizona; Donovan Jackson, Ohio State; Tate Ratledge, Georgia; Dylan Fairchild, Georgia; Emery Jones, Louisiana State; Anthony Belton, North Carolina State.

Centers (2) — Grey Zabel, North Dakota State; Jared Wilson, Georgia.

Quarterbacks (5)— Cam Ward, Miami; Shedeur Sanders, Colorado; Jaxson Dart, Mississippi; Tyler Shough, Louisville; Jalen Milroe, Alabama.

Running backs (8) — Ashton Jeanty, Boise State; Omarion Hampton, North Carolina; TreVeyon Henderson, Ohio State; Quinshon Judkins, Ohio State; Trevor Etienne, Georgia; Kaleb Johnson, Iowa; Ollie Gordon, Oklahoma State; DJ Giddens, Kansas State.

DEFENSE (51)

Defensive line (14) — Mason Graham, Michigan; Walter Nolen, Mississippi; Kenneth Grant, Michigan; Tyleik Williams, Ohio State; Alfred Collins, Texas; Derrick Harmon, Oregon; Jordan Burch, Oregon; T.J. Sanders, South Carolina; Shemar Turner, Texas A&M; Joshua Farmer, Florida State; Ty Robinson, Nebraska; Ty Hamilton, Ohio State; Darius Alexander, Toledo; Sai’vion Jones, Louisiana State.

Edge rushers (15) — Abdul Carter, Penn State; Jalon Walker, Georgia; Shemar Stewart, Texas A&M; Mykel Williams, Georgia; James Pearce, Tennessee; Mike Green, Marshall; JT Tuimoloau, Ohio State; Landon Jackson, Arkansas; Nic Scourton, Texas A&M; Donovan Ezeiruaku, Boston College; Jack Sawyer, Ohio State; Femi Oladejo, UCLA; Ashton Gillotte, Louisville; Bradyn Swinson, Louisiana State; Princely Umanmielen, Mississippi.

Linebackers (5) — Jihaad Campbell, Alabama; Carson Schwesinger, UCLA; Smael Mondon, Georgia; Danny Stutsman, Oklahoma; Demetrius Knight, South Carolina.

Cornerbacks (11) — Travis Hunter, Colorado; Will Johnson, Michigan; Maxwell Hairston, Kentucky; Jahdae Barron, Texas; Benjamin Morrison, Notre Dame; Shavon Revel, East Carolina; Azareye’h Thomas, Florida State; Trey Amos, Mississippi; Darien Porter, Iowa State; Jacob Parrish, Kansas State; Jordan Han****, Ohio State.

Safeties (6) — Malaki Starks, Georgia; Nick Emmanwori, South Carolina; Kevin Winston, Penn State; Xavier Watts, Notre Dame; Billy Bowman, Oklahoma; Jonas Sanker, Virginia.
 
Here's another name to watch for Dallas, though, on the other side of the ball: Alabama linebacker Jihaad Campbell. He is extremely well regarded by teams and could go higher than expected if some team (Cowboys? 49ers? Colts?) loses out on its Plan A on Thursday night.


Insert crying emoji m, the dream is dead I think, I need to move on.

Hold me
 
Here's another name to watch for Dallas, though, on the other side of the ball: Alabama linebacker Jihaad Campbell. He is extremely well regarded by teams and could go higher than expected if some team (Cowboys? 49ers? Colts?) loses out on its Plan A on Thursday night.


Insert crying emoji m, the dream is dead I think, I need to move on.

Hold me
Jihad is gonna be 21 years old throughout this season

That’s how young he is

Can you believe that ?
 
Here's another name to watch for Dallas, though, on the other side of the ball: Alabama linebacker Jihaad Campbell. He is extremely well regarded by teams and could go higher than expected if some team (Cowboys? 49ers? Colts?) loses out on its Plan A on Thursday night.


Insert crying emoji m, the dream is dead I think, I need to move on.

Hold me
As long as you don't mind being the little spoon. ;)
 
Kipers thoughts on Day 1
_end_rule.png

Biggest winners and best picks from Round 1​



i

Green Bay Packers

The pick: Matthew Golden (No. 23)

The first receiver in Round 1 for the Packers since 2002! I love this pick. I remember watching Golden in 2023, when he was still at Houston. His consistency continued at Texas last season; he runs great routes and is a big-play threat with 4.29 speed. Receiver was a huge need for the Packers (and has been for a while). They have good pass catchers in Jayden Reed, Romeo Doubs and Christian Watson, but none of them are no-doubt WR1 options. Golden can be that.

And wait, it gets better. I ranked Golden 16th overall. He was my second-ranked receiver in the class behind Travis Hunter, yet we saw Tetairoa McMillan and Emeka Egbuka go before him. This is a really nice marriage of value, need and upside. What a night for the host city.

i

Indianapolis Colts

The pick: Tyler Warren (No. 14)

I heard teams were trying to trade ahead of the Colts to get one of the top two tight ends. I thought Warren might go to the Jets at No. 7, but they took Armand Membou. Then Colston Loveland -- the other top tight end -- went No. 10 to Chicago. But somehow, someway Warren ended up falling into the Colts' lap four picks later.

I actually have Warren ranked five spots higher than Loveland at No. 7 overall. He moves all over the offense, has the strong hands to make contested plays and is simply unstoppable after the catch. He will fill a major need for Indianapolis, which managed just 467 receiving yards from its tight end room in 2024. The team also lost Kylen Granson, its top guy at the position. In a huge year for Anthony Richardson's long-term evaluation, the Colts had to get their third-year quarterback some more reliable pass catchers. Warren will stretch the seams and catch some Richardson deep balls, but he will also eat up targets underneath and turn them into first downs. Great pick.


i

Jacksonville Jaguars

The pick: Travis Hunter (No. 2)

As soon as Cam Ward went to the Titans at No. 1 -- essentially a formality at this point -- the fireworks started. The Jaguars made an aggressive move up to get Hunter, sending Nos. 5, 36 and 126, plus a 2026 first-rounder, to Cleveland for Nos. 2, 104 and 200. Yes, it's a rich package. But Hunter is going to bring some much-needed juice to this team; he was the wire-to-wire No. 1 prospect on my board, dominating on both sides of the ball in college. His ball skills, feel for the game and quickness are outstanding. I could see Hunter making big plays on offense and defense for the Jags.

I expect Hunter to play primarily on offense in Jacksonville. New coach Liam Coen wants to give quarterback Trevor Lawrence help, and the combination of Hunter and Brian Thomas Jr. should do it. Hunter is a touchdown machine. But I also fully expect him to spend a lot of time on the field with the defense, especially late in games. Cornerback is an issue in Jacksonville, so look for Hunter to get reps opposite Tyson Campbell (Jourdan Lewis will be mainly in the slot). I'm betting defensive coordinator Anthony Campanile will push to get him out there when his unit is backed up against the red zone, too.

Hunter is a baller who is going to make this team better very, very quickly. Two for the price of one.

i

Cleveland Browns

The pick: Mason Graham (No. 5)

The flip side of that trade was the Browns moving back three spots. They added a Day 2 pick this weekend. They added a first-rounder in 2026. And then they took my No. 3 prospect in Graham. He doesn't have many "wow" traits, but he's an extremely good football player. I love his technique and power, and Graham will join Maliek Collins and Shelby Harris to form a reliable defensive interior in Cleveland. The Browns are trying to reset, and Graham will help boost the defense.

I would have loved Hunter here, too. Like Jacksonville, Cleveland needs players who will excite the fan base. But factoring in the trade return and the fact that they still got a top-three prospect, this is a good start to their draft. The Jaguars aren't a lock to make the playoffs next season, so that 2026 first-rounder could end up being in at least the teens. And remember that Cleveland has the No. 33 pick at the beginning of Round 2 on Friday; could it get a quarterback there?


i

Los Angeles Chargers

The pick: Omarion Hampton (No. 22)

I thought Hampton would be a Bronco. Denver's run game was missing a punch, and Hampton would have helped second-year QB Bo Nix by taking some pressure off him. Instead, Hampton goes two picks later to a division rival! Denver might have some regret in short order. Chargers coach Jim Harbaugh loves to run the football, and he now has a really good duo in Hampton and Najee Harris. Hampton runs through contact, has breakaway speed and can catch the ball out of the backfield.

I don't love first-round running backs, and this is a deep class at the position. But given Los Angeles' identity on offense, this just makes sense. Hampton is my 14th-ranked prospect, which means there actually is some value despite the position.

i

Kansas City Chiefs

The pick: Josh Simmons (No. 32)

The Chiefs added a fifth-rounder in a move back from No. 31 and addressed a big problem at left tackle with my No. 15 prospect. I can't say enough good things about this bookend to Day 1. Simmons was dinged during the predraft process because of his knee injury, which limited him to six games in 2024. But if healthy, he might have been the top tackle in the class. Seriously. He's consistent with terrific pass protection traits.

If you watched the Super Bowl, you know Patrick Mahomes' blindside was going to be an offseason focus. Kingsley Suamataia and Wanya Morris weren't the answers there, and Joe Thuney -- who moved outside from guard -- was traded. The Chiefs signed Jaylon Moore, but he was a backup in San Francisco, so he's not a sure thing. Simmons could be the long-term answer. He can help inside at guard, too, or potentially bump to right tackle, where Jawaan Taylorhas been inconsistent.


More picks I liked in Round 1​

  • There was speculation that the Giants might go quarterback at No. 3. But this team needs difference-makers, and Abdul Carter is one of the two elite prospects in this class. It makes sense. The Giants are going to get after the quarterback; they also have Brian Burns and Kayvon Thibodeaux off the edge. And remember that Carter also has the versatility to play off-ball if needed.
  • Everyone knew the Falcons had to draft a pass rusher early in this draft, likely in the first round. Names associated with them at No. 15 included Mike Green and Shemar Stewart -- guys a little further down the board. So getting Jalon Walker, who ranked 10th for me, is a steal. He slid down the board as teams picking earlier focused on offense. Pairing him with Leonard Floyd (and James Pearce Jr., but more on that in a moment) should improve this Atlanta unit. Walker had 6.5 sacks last season and plays with heavy hands. He popped in every game I watched. I actually had him graded as an off-ball linebacker -- he played both positions at Georgia -- but that versatility only raises his pro ceiling.
  • Grey Zabel to the Seahawks wasn't the sexiest pick. But they needed to fix the interior protection, and Zabel can play all along the offensive line. They tackled their biggest need, and they now have four picks on Day 2 to get a receiver and some help on defense.
 
Last edited:

Questionable picks and reaches from Round 1​

i

Dallas Cowboys

The pick: Tyler Booker (No. 12)

This was a reach for need. The Cowboys were 24th in pass block win rate last season, and Zack Martin retired. I get it. Dallas obviously wanted an immediate replacement at right guard, and Booker is a good player -- it's a heavyweight fight on every snap against him. Movement is not his game, but there's no doubt he's a mauler at the line of scrimmage. I thought he was outstanding in pass protection, too.

The value is just really iffy. He barely clipped my final top 25, and he plays a nonpremium position on the interior offensive line. Matthew Golden was on the board, and the Cowboys have a big hole at WR2 opposite CeeDee Lamb. Omarion Hampton was on the board, and the Cowboys had a dreadful run game last season. I would have gone another direction here.


i

New Orleans Saints

The pick: Kelvin Banks Jr. (No. 9)

This isn't really about Banks. He started 42 games in college and is a really good run blocker. All in all, he's decent value at No. 9 (No. 13 on my board) and checks a box for New Orleans. The Saints needed to improve their pass protection.

No, this is really about passing on the quarterback class -- and specifically Shedeur Sanders. He is my QB1 and ranked No. 5 overall on my final board. He's accurate and tough in the pocket, and he sees the field well. While he doesn't have a huge arm, he is strong enough to deliver the ball to every level of the field. And he was right there for the taking.
This match would have made all the sense in the world. The Saints play indoors at the Caesars Superdome, which alleviates any arm strength concerns. They have a new coach who has worked with a bunch of young passers in Kellen Moore. And they have a sudden need at the position, with starter Derek Carr uncertain for this season because of a shoulder injury. Even if Carr does play, he's 34 years old and isn't a lock to be on the roster beyond 2025. New Orleans has to start planning for the future at some point, and it again passed on the most important position in Round 1. The Saints haven't used a first-round pick on a QB since Archie Manning in 1971. They can't keep rolling the dice.

Now here's what can change everything for New Orleans, though: It picks at No. 40 on Friday. Could Sanders fall to the Saints? Could they trade up to get him? Stay tuned.

i

Miami Dolphins

The pick: Kenneth Grant (No. 13)

The Dolphins could have had Will Johnson (though he reportedly has a knee issue). They could have had Jahdae Barron. If they do trade Jalen Ramsey, their cornerback room would include Kader Kohou, Storm Duck, Cam Smith and Ethan Bonner. That's a problem, and Miami opted to skip the position to draft a nose tackle. Yes, Grant is explosive, and sources told me the league was hot on him heading into the draft. But he was 30th on my board.


i

Carolina Panthers

The pick: Tetairoa McMillan (No. 8)

McMillan is tremendous on contested-catch balls, and he always produces. He had 1,319 receiving yards last season, and he had 1,402 the year before. I've comped him to Drake London, who was also the eighth pick (2022), and he should be a big target for Bryce Young. The Panthers lacked a true No. 1 receiver, and they clearly see McMillan as that guy. They now have a nice young receiving core to build Young's offense around (Xavier Legette and Jalen Coker). I'm expecting some solid TD numbers from McMillan in the red zone.

But I wonder about the value. I have McMillan ranked 19th in the class, and I thought Matthew Golden might come off the board before him. The knock on McMillan is that he doesn't always get consistent separation. That could be a problem in the NFL against elite cornerbacks.

There's also the defense question. I had Jalon Walkerprojected to Carolina in all four of my mock drafts, and he was still on the board when it picked. This team allowed a league-worst 6.0 yards per play last season and gave up more the 30 points per game. I'm surprised the Panthers went offense here.


More picks I questioned in Round 1​

  • Who is going to play quarterback in Pittsburgh? If the Steelers sign Aaron Rodgers, this is less of an issue. He would at least give them a 2025 starter. But I had issue with the Saints passing on Shedeur Sanders, so I have to point out the Steelers doing the same 12 picks later. Plus, Pittsburgh doesn't have a second-round pick, meaning it will be a long wait until No. 83 on Friday night. Derrick Harmoncould bring some pressure inside for the Steelers, who have to think about the future with Cameron Heyward turning 36. But if they don't sign Rodgers, and they don't get lucky with the Day 2 quarterbacks, we're going to be examining this pick all season long.

  • I'll mention the Jaxson Dart pick for the Giants, too -- but only because he went before Sanders. I ranked Dart 28th, which means the value was right in line at No. 25. He has the arm to drive the ball in the New York weather, and he can make plays with his legs. So the pick itself is solid. But trading three Day 2 picks over the next two years to get back into the first round for him, and passing on Sanders -- who, again, is No. 5 overall on my board -- makes it less appealing.
  • James Pearce Jr. was 34th in my rankings. So while I mentioned the Falcons' sizable pass-rush issue earlier, I was shocked they traded a future first-rounder to move up to No. 26 to get him. It's a lot to give up, and talented edge rushers such as Donovan Ezeiruaku and Mike Green were still on the board. Atlanta got value with Jalon Walker, but this one was questionable.
  • I have mixed feelings on the Lions' pick. Tyleik Williams was the lowest-ranked first-round pick on my board at No. 44. But defensive tackles went fast Thursday, with my top four off the board by No. 21. When Detroit was on the clock at No. 28, Darius Alexander was the best remaining player at the position, but he was only a few spots higher than Williams on the Big Board at No. 39. So it's a slightreach, but there weren't many options if Detroit was set on adding to its interior. Williams is sudden and stuffs the run, but he isn't a dominant pass rusher, and I would have liked to see Detroit get an edge rusher here to take the load off Aidan Hutchinson.

_end_rule.png

Kiper's best available prospects for Round 2​


Here are the best players on my board still available for Day 2. I have their predraft top-150 ranking in parentheses.

1. Shedeur Sanders, QB, Colorado (No. 5)
2. Will Johnson, CB, Michigan (No. 11)
3. Nick Emmanwori, S, South Carolina (No. 17)
4. Mike Green, OLB, Marshall (No. 18)
5. Donovan Ezeiruaku, OLB, Boston College (No. 23)
6. Carson Schwesinger, LB, UCLA (No. 32)
7. Luther Burden III, WR, Missouri (No. 36)
8. Elijah Arroyo, TE, Miami (Fla.) (No. 37)
9. Darius Alexander, DT, Toledo (No. 39)
10. Mason Taylor, TE, LSU (No. 41)

I'm obviously watching where Sanders might go on Day 2 -- Cleveland could be a fit at No. 33 -- but I've talked about him enough here. Johnson could be an excellent value in Round 2, and Schwesinger has a lot of upside. Teams that need pass rushing could be jockeying for position Friday, with Green and Ezeiruaku still out there. There are a lot of good players still on the board.
 
More thoughts from Insider panel:

Who was the best pick of the night?​


Miller: Jalon Walker to the Falcons at No. 15 was the best pick of the night based on value. I had him at No. 5 in my rankings. He also checks off the team's biggest need with Atlanta having just 31 sacks last season and a desperate lack of speed defensively. Walker's ability to play off-ball linebacker, spy quarterbacks and just straight-up rush off the edge made him a weekly force for Georgia. Now he'll get to stay in state and keep doing it.

Reid: Tetairoa McMillan to the Panthers at No. 8 was my favorite pick because Bryce Young needed a true WR1. The top-ranked wideout in my rankings, McMillan adds an alpha to a room that included a lot of secondary options. Entering a crucial third year, finding Young a primary pass catcher was seen as essential. General manager Dan Morgan likely weighed the strengths of the receiver class to the defensive line group and saw the lack of high-end options, which is why he wasted little time in drafting McMillan.

Yates: Donovan Jackson to the Vikings at No. 24 was a fantastic pick, as he is an extremely versatile lineman. He was the 20th-ranked player on my board. Jackson was a star guard for Ohio State throughout his tenure until Josh Simmons suffered a torn patellar tendon in October, at which point he kicked out to left tackle. After having a difficult first test at tackle against Penn State, he did not surrender a sack and yielded just one pressure the rest of the season, playing outstanding ball in the playoffs. He's a welcome addition to a new-look Vikings line that added Will Fries and Ryan Kelly in free agency.



What was the most confusing pick of the night?​

Miller: The Browns trading back from No. 2 to select defensive tackle Mason Graham at No. 5. I like Graham, but if Cleveland wanted to boost its defensive line, why not remain at No. 2 and select Abdul Carterto play opposite Myles Garrett? Graham is a good player -- I had him ranked No. 4 overall -- but the Browns need blue-chip players. Graham projects as a solid starter but not to have an All-Pro-level impact like Hunter or Carter.

Reid: The Giants trading back into the first round for Jaxson Dart instead of Shedeur Sanders. Before Thursday, they were circled as a potential trade-up team for their QB of the future. I had Sanders as the higher-graded player and thought he was a better fit in Brian Daboll's offense.

Yates: The Dolphins taking defensive tackle Kenneth Grant with the No. 13 pick. I am a fan of Grant -- whose 331-pound frame will immediately boost their run defense -- but felt there were other available defensive tackles who offered more pass-rush upside. My board had both Walter Nolen (No. 16 to Arizona) and Derrick Harmon (No. 21 to Pittsburgh) ahead of Grant due to their superior pass-rush ability.



What was the biggest non-Travis Huntersurprise of the night?​

Miller: Miami selecting Grant at No. 13. Defensive tackle was one of the Dolphins' needs entering the draft, but they also had to fill holes at cornerback, safety and along the offensive line given Terron Armstead's retirement. Grant is a good player, but he's primarily a nose tackle and was ranked No. 30 on my board. This seemed like a luxury pick instead of a smart one.

Reid: The Buccaneers selecting Emeka Egbuka at No. 19. Considering they already have Mike Evans, Chris Godwin and Jalen McMillan (on whom they spent a third-round pick last year), I did not anticipate the Bucs using a first-round pick at receiver. Egbuka is a sure-handed and dependable route runner who might be an heir apparent to Evans or Godwin, but there were more pressing roster needs.

Yates: The Falcons sending a package of picks to the Rams that included a 2026 first-rounder to get back into the first round, where they drafted edge rusher James Pearce Jr. with the No. 26 pick. Pearce likely wouldn't have made it to Atlanta's second-round pick (No. 46), but I'm a fan of the Rams making a bet on the downside of the Falcons' season next year. The Falcons got a necessary boost to their pass rush in Pearce and Jalon Walker, but at what price?



What's the best Day 2 fit for Shedeur Sanders?​

Miller: Cleveland Browns. The Browns weren't convicted enough to spend a top-five pick on Sanders, but adding him at No. 33 is a much different conversation. With an offensive scheme under coach Kevin Stefanski that makes its living with a strong run game and heavy play-action, Sanders would be able to operate from the pocket and carve up defenses similar to how he played at Colorado. A team with an offensive-minded coach and little pressure to see the field early is the best scenario for Sanders.

Reid: New Orleans Saints. With pick No. 40, they are positioned to add him. Many viewed him as a possible option at No. 9 overall, but they selected offensive tackle Kelvin Banks Jr. instead, filling a hole along the line. The Saints have massive questions at quarterback, so they should make this move.

Yates: Pittsburgh Steelers. I believe the Steelers at least pondered picking Sanders at No. 21 overall. Though they do not own a second-round pick, a maneuver to get into position to select him -- however high that needs to be -- could still be possible, dipping into draft capital in 2026. Unless Aaron Rodgersagrees to a deal by the time Round 2 begins, the Steelers have a massive question mark under center.


What is your biggest regret from your mock draft after seeing Day 1 play out?​

Miller: I didn't want to place Shedeur Sanders to Pittsburgh at No. 21 after talking to teams, but I kept the pick given the Steelers' lack of an answer at quarterback. The Steelers weren't in love with Sanders, or at least not enough to pick him in Round 1. I ranked him as my No. 25 overall player and should have stuck closer to my ranking.

Reid: Not having guard Donovan Jackson higher. Because of his consistency, durability and versatility, it was not surprising to see him get picked in the top 25. Jackson slots perfectly at left guard for as the final member of a remodeled Vikings' offensive front, joining free agent signings Will Fries and Ryan Kelly.

Yates: Not heeding some of the caution that was sent my way about where Will Johnson was going to end up. Though I am a fan of Johnson's game, there was concern over a prior knee injury that had some teams skeptical he would go in Round 1. That proved to be the case, as Johnson was one of two players in the green room who wasn't selected (quarterback Jalen Milroe being the other).
 

Which team best addressed a glaring need (or needs) on Day 1?​

Miller: The Packers' first-round wide receiver drought is over, with Matthew Golden becoming the first receiver to go to Green Bay in Round 1 since 2002. It was a needed pick, too, given Christian Watson's inability to stay healthy. The Packers have plenty of WR2s and WR3s, but lacked a true No. 1 who could win down the field and consistently make big plays. Golden showed that ability at Texas last season, leading the FBS with 23 catches of 20 yards or more.

Reid: After using free agency to bolster their defense, the Patriots needed an upgrade from Vederian Lowe at left tackle. By drafting Will Campbell with the No. 4 pick, New England got a tough, durable blocker to protect quarterback Drake Maye's blind side. The Patriots weren't dissuaded by Campbell's arm length and now have an immediate starter who could eventually become their franchise left tackle.

Yates: The Colts stayed patient and landed Tyler Warren, a difference-maker tight end they have lacked. Amazingly, the Colts have not had a tight end reach 500 receiving yards in a season since Eric Ebron did it in 2018. The winner of the Colts' quarterback competition will dramatically benefit from the presence of Warren, who is among the best run-after-catch players in the class.



What was the best trade up, down or for a player during Round 1?​

Miller: Jacksonville trading up for Travis Hunter. The Jaguars clearly believe they can win the AFC South and help get quarterback Trevor Lawrence on track with Hunter's playmaking. Hunter will form a potentially elite receiver duo with 2024 first-rounder Brian Thomas Jr., while also helping the defense at corner. We'll see which position Hunter majors in, but I love the aggressive decision by first-time general manager James Gladstone to move up for one of the two elite players in this class.

Reid: The Rams trading back and gaining a second first-round pick in 2026 was excellent. Despite being in win-now mode, general manager Les Snead kept the future in mind, as the team could look for its QB of the future down the road. And the Rams still have a top-50 pick (No. 46), so they're in range to add a key player at a position of need.

Yates: The Browns trading down from the No. 2 pick. Let me be clear -- I love Hunter as a prospect. He was the No. 1 player on my board from start to finish and has a legitimate chance to be a Pro Bowler at both receiver and cornerback. This take represents my fundamental belief in the value of draft capital. The Browns are now well-positioned to stockpile talent in this year's draft and are armed with two first-round picks next year, when there will be a deeper group of quarterbacks.



Which contender helped itself the most?​

Miller: The defending Super Bowl champion Eagles have made a living off waiting for great players to fall. They did it again by selecting linebacker Jihaad Campbell at pick No. 31. Campbell, who was flagged by teams for his shoulder issues, has elite potential as both a linebacker and a pass rusher. Teams are torn on his NFL position, but they love his versatility. My No. 15 overall player, Campbell can have an impact on the Eagles playing a role like Zack Baun did last season.

Reid: The Ravens stayed true to their historic ways, taking one of the best players on the board in safety Malaki Starks. Pairing him with Kyle Hamiltonprovides them with even more versatility in the secondary. Starks can play in the slot, but he projects best as a free safety. Regardless, he is an upgrade from Marcus Williams, who was released this offseason.

Yates: The Chiefs were incredibly patient, trading down from No. 31 to No. 32 and landing offensive tackle Josh Simmons along with a fifth-round pick. His immense physical tools stack up with any left tackle in the class. However, a torn patellar tendon in October left him on the board until the final pick, meaning the team taking him needed a short-term solution at tackle. The Chiefs have that in new signee Jaylon Moore, so this move made a lot of sense for the extended future.



Who are you most shocked to see available on Day 2?​

Miller: Will Johnson. His medical situation definitely foreshadowed a slide. He missed all but six games this past season with a turf toe injury, sat out of the combine and pro day with a hamstring injury and then had a knee issue flagged by NFL teams. But Johnson was my No. 7 overall player based on his tape and an elite cover corner. He'll start Day 2 as my top available player.

Reid: Donovan Ezeiruaku. Because of the production, good testing and a standout performance at the Senior Bowl, the edge rusher was viewed as a mid-to-late first-round pick. Ezeiruaku will likely be picked quickly in the second round, as he's viewed as one of the top options still on the board.

Yates: I'm going with Johnson, too. This is a clear situation where the medicals are concerning enough for teams to stay patient. That being said, the team that lands Johnson in Round 2 is getting incredible value, provided his knee checks out. His size and ball skills are too impressive to ignore.


What's the biggest non-QB story to watch Friday?​

Miller: When does the running back run start? We've talked for months about how great this running back class is and only two are off the board so far. When will TreVeyon Henderson and Quinshon Judkins go? How about Kaleb Johnson? I have four running backs with Round 2 grades, so I'll be watching how early teams jump at starting-level backs.

Reid: Which cornerback comes off of the board next? Will Johnson surprisingly fell all the way out of the first round. Shavon Revel Jr, Trey Amos and Azareye'h Thomas are all still available, too, but I think they will fly off of the board during Day 2.

Yates: Do we see trades at the top of Round 2? Friday often leads to trade calls by teams that have a target who unexpectedly made it to the second round. Given that the Browns own two of the first four picks in the second round, they will be busy one way or another -- from making picks or fielding calls to secure more capital.


Which first-round offensive playmaker will have the best rookie season?​

Miller: I hate to be too obvious, but it's Ashton Jeanty. Chip Kelly will feed him early and often as a downhill runner; they'll throw him the ball, too. Jeanty has realistic Offensive Rookie of the Year ability since head coach Pete Carroll will look to mirror the strong run game that worked for him in Seattle. Jeanty is his new Marshawn Lynch.

Reid: Tyler Warren steps into a role where he can immediately be one of the Colts' best pass catchers. Indianapolis had the least productive group of tight ends in the NFL a season ago. Warren changes that right away, as he can be a versatile option in the passing game but can also contribute as a serviceable blocker in the run game.

Yates: I agree with Matt. Jeanty is my clear pick when factoring in the skill set he brings to the table, the system and organizational fit, plus the position he plays. Running backs frequently make immediate contributions as rookies, and Jeanty's combination of contact balance and explosiveness is elite. The Raiders will surely want to run the heck out of the ball with Pete Carroll.


What's the one word you'd use to describe Atlanta trading back into Round 1 for James Pearce Jr.?​

Miller: Expensive. I love that Atlanta doubled down on defense and added a ton of speed, but trading a 2026 first-rounder -- along with picks No. 46 and 242 -- to the Rams for the No. 26 and 101 picks seems pricey considering that they drafted Jalon Walker earlier in the round. Again, I really like giving Raheem Morris this much speed for his defense, but now the Falcons are sitting out of the first round of a deep 2026 draft.

Reid: Surprising. The Falcons moved up 20 spots for Pearce, but I thought there were better players available and that a gigantic move like this wasn't necessary. It's clear that Atlanta had a very high grade on Pearce, and the Falcons were in desperate need of a presence off the edge. Pearce satisfies that, but giving up a first-rounder next year is steep.

Yates: Perplexing. Given the cost, Atlanta needs this move to pay off in a hurry after sending its 2026 first-round pick to the Rams in this deal. Though I believe Pearce was likely to be gone when Atlanta picked next at 46, I would have been comfortable also playing the board on Day 2 with the other available edge options. This trade increased the pressure on Atlanta in 2025.

Make one prediction for Day 2​


Miller: Quarterbacks will come off the board fast. We should see Sanders, Tyler Shough and Jalen Milroe be selected early Friday -- all three might be gone in the first 10 picks of Round 2. With QB-needy teams such as Cleveland and New Orleans going elsewhere in Round 1, it stands to reason that they'll address the position early on Day 2.

Reid: We'll start to see a run on running backs very quickly in the middle of Round 2. TreVeyon Henderson is my top-ranked available running back and should hear his name called quickly on Day 2. Quinshon Judkins is another name that I expected to be selected during the latter parts of Round 2 or early in Round 3.

Yates: This is a bold call that could be proven incorrect right away Friday, but I'll predict that Cleveland does not take a quarterback with either of its second-round picks. Instead, it will gear its efforts toward next year's QB class. The Browns have plenty of draft capital to be aggressive in what profiles as a much deeper 2026 class.
 
Also 2 nuggets from Todd McShay hours before the draft that shows he’s pretty plugged in

Game of Chicken Between the Giants and Saints for Jaxson Dart

If Sanders is the pick at 21, the focus of the end of the first round will turn to Jaxson Dart, and which team will outmaneuver everyone else for his services.
I’ve been told Dart is high on the Saints’ list. In fact, based on calls I had yesterday, they like him more than I realized. Maybe not enough to take him with the ninth pick, but don’t be surprised if Saints GM Mickey Loomis tries trading back into the first round using a package of the 40th and 71st picks to move into the mid-20s.
Expect there to be competition, though. The Giants also like Dart, and on paper—New York has day-two picks at 34, 65, and 99, compared to New Orleans’s picks 40, 71, and 93—are better positioned to make a deal.
But Loomis is a renegade. If my intel is correct and Dart is who they want, people in the league know he’ll do what it takes to get that done. The Giants are acutely aware of that as well.
I don’t expect either of these teams to consider Dart in the top 10. The Giants shouldn’t pass on the opportunity to draft Penn State pass rusher Abdul Carter, and as I wrote in Mock 4.0, I think New Orleans would be wise to draft the top edge defender on their board to act as Cameron Jordan’s spiritual successor along the Saints’ defensive front seven.




McShayYardBreakers_20.png




Third_Down.png



Could the Jaguars Be Trying to Trade Up?
I mentioned in my final mock draft that if Jacksonville sticks and picks at 5, Boise State running back Ashton Jeanty will likely be the pick. I still believe that’s true. There’s also been some speculation among league sources that they would entertain moving back as long as it isn’t past 11, with the potential plan being to pick Arizona wide receiver Tetairoa McMillan before the Cowboys are on the clock at 12.
But what if there’s a third option? In the past 24 hours, multiple league sources have reached out to me wondering whether new GM James Gladstone is actually trying to move up, not down. I don’t have much info outside of that, but I find it interesting that I’ve been approached with that question by two different people. NFL Network’s Ian Rapoport reported that the Jags have been eyeing a move up to 2, and I think he may be on to something.
Let’s play out the football logic. If Jacksonville is after an offensive skill guy to help get Trevor Lawrence back on track under first-year head coach Liam Coen, the only player who fits the bill in a move-up scenario is Colorado’s Travis Hunter. I haven’t gotten the sense that the Browns are looking to move out of no. 2, but I’d be curious how much it would take to wrestle that pick away.
There’s a lot of gossip in the draft weekend game of telephone, though, and that’s all this could be. But Jacksonville is a team to monitor. They are the biggest wild card in the top five, followed by Chicago in the top 10 and Denver in the top 20.
While a Jags move-up seems like it’d be for Hunter, a Bears or Broncos move would likely be for Jeanty. If Sean Payton can’t make that big of a jump, though, look for him to explore a shorter trip up the board for Penn State’s Tyler Warren or Michigan’s Colston Loveland—the two premier tight end prospects in this class.
 
Bob McGinns thoughts on NFC North Day 1 picks, really good read

GREEN BAY PACKERS (11-6)

1/23. MATTHEW GOLDEN, WR, Texas (5-11, 192, 4.32)

The assumption has to be that cornerback Will Johnson of Michigan received a troubling medical report (knee, turf toe). Based on talent, he’s a legitimate Top 20 pick even with all the missed time during a three-year career.

Johnson’s name is mentioned here because he would be a perfect fit for Jeff Hafley’s zone coverage scheme. Johnson never ran a 40 and, based on scout evaluations, questions arose about his catch-up speed. Still, in zone or in off man coverage, his instincts to read and react to the football (three pick 6’s) were exquisite.

As it stands now, the Packers figure to start Keisean Nixon and Nate Hobbs outside with Javon Bullard in the slot. Carrington Valentine is the main backup. It’s probable the Packers no longer want Jaire Alexander around. Clearly, there was room for Johnson (6-1 ½, 194).

Hafley’s premium at defensive tackle is on athleticism and penetration, but every system needs one shock absorber. T.J. Slaton played that role fairly well a year ago but now he’s in Cincinnati.

Kenny Clark, their best defensive lineman for almost a decade, has played a ton of snaps. At this point, he’s the Packers’ lone holdup player. Devonte Wyatt, Colby Wooden and Karl Brooks are 3-techniques, not run stuffers.

It’s likely that Tyleik Williams was very much under consideration.

Edge rusher made a lot of sense, too, because Rashan Gary is coming off a down year, Lukas Van Ness hasn’t done much and Kingsley Enagbare is more try-hard than talented. The best rush threat might turn out to be inside backer Edgerrin Cooper on cross blitzes with an occasional foray as a 9-technique on third downs.

Boston College’s Donovan Ezeiruaku made sense here because he had 30 sacks and once played for Hafley. James Pearce and Mike Green were regarded as character risks by some teams.

The Packers will wait until Friday to address the defense with the selection of Golden. The need at wide receiver was high because oft-injured Christian Watson blew out his knee late in the season, Romeo Doubs suffered multiple concussions in 2024 and the wide receiving corps dropped far too many passes.

Golden, according to one scout, might have the finest ball skills of any wideout in the draft. His makeup also was regarded as much more palatable than Tetairoa McMillan and Luther Burden. Another possibility, Emeka Egbuka (6-1, 202, 4.48), went off the board at No. 19.

Based on his one 40 at the combine (4.32 hand held, 4.29 electronic), Golden might have the fastest time of any wideout in Green Bay. After a cursory check, another speedy draftee was David Clowney, a fifth-round pick in 2007 who ran 4.36 but never made it.

Several scouts, however, said it was noticeable that Golden didn’t play as fast as he timed. In other words, he wasn’t a blur.

One scout compared Golden to Tyler Lockett, the former Seahawk who was a third-round pick in 2015. Lockett was 5-10 and 181, and ran 4.35.

Is Golden a better player than Jayden Reed (5-10 ½, 189, 4.47), the Packers’ second-round choice in 2023?

“He’s got better ball skills than Reed,” one executive said. “More of an outside player than Reed. Reed’s more of a slot. Reed’s more of a twitchy route runner, more of a ball carrier. Different players. He’s as good as Reed, and potentially could be better.”
Golden is smaller than most of the team’s leading receivers in modern history. That group (all measurables pre-draft) would include Donald Driver (5-11 ½, 181, 4.48), Davante Adams (6-1, 214, 4.55), Sterling Sharpe (5-11 ½, 201, 4.52), Jordy Nelson (6-2 ½, 218, 4.54), Randall Cobb (5-10, 191, 4.47), James Lofton (6-3, 187, 4.40), Antonio Freeman (6-0, 195, 4.60), Greg Jennings (5-11, 198, 4.42), James Jones (6-0 ½, 207, 4.54), Robert Brooks (6-0, 175, 4.60) and Robert Ferguson (6-1, 202, 4.53).

The last time the Packers drafted a wide receiver in the first round was in 2002 when coach-GM Mike Sherman selected Javon Walker (6-2 ½, 210, 4.41) with the 20th pick.

One reason GM Ron Wolf emphasized size at all positions during his nine years (1992-2000) in charge was wintry, windy conditions and the old grass playing surface at Lambeau Field.

Despite Golden’s dimensions, scouts said he projected as an outside receiver in addition to the slot.



Getty Images

CHICAGO BEARS (5-12)

1/10. COLSTON LOVELAND, TE, Michigan (6-5 ½, 248, no 40)

The Bears need a running back either to become the workhorse or job-share with D’Andre Swift. When the brain trust of GM Ryan Poles and new coach Ben Johnson were unable to trade up for Ashton Jeanty at No. 6, they put aside reinforcing the position until Friday or possibly even Saturday given the extreme depth.

Was tight end a luxury pick for a last-place team the last three years considering that Cole Kmet, a second-round choice in 2020, is in the prime of his career?

No, because Loveland is more than a conventional tight end. He played the majority of his snaps at Michigan in the slot, wide or in motion. Loveland essentially will replace Keenan Allen, the venerable slot last year who won’t return. In the offseason, the Bears added a pair of experienced slots, ex-Jaguar Devin Duvernay and ex-Commander Olamide Zaccheaus, but they can’t begin to approximate the potential impact of Loveland.

As the Lions’ offensive coordinator in 2023, Johnson devised a good portion of his prolific attack around rookie Sam LaPorta (6-3, 246, 4.60), a second-round draft choice. The results were spectacular (86 catches, 889 yards, 10 touchdowns), and it’s certain Johnson will attempt to follow suit with his latest Big Ten tight end.

Loveland is a more dynamic route runner and catcher than Kmet, a workmanlike Y tight end with better than average blocking ability.

A year ago, Poles selected quarterback Caleb Williams No. 1 over Jayden Daniels, who went to Washington at No. 2 and had a vastly superior first season than did Williams. Now the decision to take Loveland over Tyler Warren will be scrutinized.

Warren (6-5 ½, 256, no 40) is bigger than Loveland and a more physical runner after the catch. His production far exceeded Loveland’s, leading to groupthink that the Penn State player clearly was the better prospect.

Michigan had a woeful passing game led by three quarterbacks and Loveland was doubled most of the time. One scout estimated Loveland’s speed at 4.6 and Warren’s at 4.7, and said their blocking and hands were comparable.



Getty Images

DETROIT LIONS (15-2)

1/28. TYLEIK WILLIAMS, DT, Ohio State (6-3, 329, no 40)

It could be argued that edge rusher was more of a need than defensive tackle. The margin, however, wasn’t much. In the end, GM Brad Holmes and coach Dan Campbell probably decided that Williams was a better player than edges Mike Green, Donovan Ezeiruaku and Nic Scourton.

The need inside arose when Alim McNeill, a 3-technique, suffered a torn ACL in December. Also, nose tackle DJ Reader will be 31 this summer and his 10th season figures to be his last in Detroit.

Let’s assume McNeill returns at about Game 11. As a Super Bowl contender facing a rugged schedule, the Lions can’t afford something like a 5-5 start because they couldn’t stop the run or rush the passer from the interior.

Williams was my fifth-rated defensive tackle, and he was the fifth to go. His body type suggests nose tackle but, not unlike McNeill, he has the athletic ability to get into gaps as a 3-technique.

McNeill (6-2, 317, 4.99) was drafted in the second round in 2021. By his second season he had bulked up to 335 mainly to blunt the run as a nose. Last year, he was down to about 310 and demonstrated pass rush as a 3-technique.

Williams’ arm length (32 inches) isn’t ideal; McNeill’s was 32 5/8.

Holmes missed in the third round two years ago on untested nose man Brodric Martin. Williams is far removed from Martin in terms of experience, desire, strength and consistency. The Lions don’t feel pressure for Martin to prove himself in his third season because they re-signed Levi Onwuzurike for one year/$4 million, added ex-Cardinal nose Roy Lopez for one year/$3.5 million and also return athletic Mekhi Wingo and hustling Pat O’Connor.

Edge? It’s Aidan Hutchinson and Marcus Davenport coming off major injuries, the pedestrian Josh Paschal and a bunch of guys. Finding another capable rusher or two is a Day 2 priority.



Getty Images

MINNESOTA VIKINGS (14-3)

1/24. DONOVAN JACKSON, G, Ohio State (6-3 ½, 315, no 40)

Sam Darnold’s Pro Bowl season has become all the more remarkable in light of the decisions made by GM Kwesi Adofo-Mensah and coach Kevin O’Connell on the offensive line.

Everyone could see that Darnold had pressure in his face. Center Garrett Bradbury and left guard Blake Brandel were susceptible to interior power rushers, and right guards Dalton Risner and Ed Ingram allowed too much leakage. Minnesota’s moves underscored how much the organization recognized it.

The decision-makers let Bradbury and Risner walk in free agency. They traded Ingram. Incoming were Ryan Kelly (two years, $9.25 million guaranteed) and Will Fries (five years, $34 million guaranteed).

Entering the draft, Brandel (6-7, 315) still was the left guard. He won’t be now after Donovan Jackson was the Vikings’ choice. Jackson displayed amazing adaptability in 2024, starting the first half of the season at left guard and the second half at left tackle.

Clearly, the Vikings want to do everything possible to smooth J.J. McCarthy’s entrance as the replacement for Darnold, now in Seattle. Not only will the brand-new interior better prevent rushers from collapsing McCarthy’s pocket a la Darnold’s but also pave the way for O’Connell to take greater interest in a rushing attack spearheaded by Aaron Jones and ex-49er Jordan Mason.

It goes without saying that it must have been a brutal decision for the Vikings to pass on Malaki Starks. Safety was every bit the need that guard was. Cam Bynum is now a high-paid Colt, and for now old pro Harrison Smith, 36, and Josh Metellus, whose specialty is working as a Buffalo nickel, are penciled in as the starters.

Starks, who went three slots later to Baltimore, had the versatility and intellect to fit perfectly in Brian Flores’ complex defense.

In the end, Adofo-Mensah and O’Connell might have thought the draft offered better depth at safety than guard.
 
Kipers thoughts on Day 2
_end_rule.png

Biggest winners and best picks from Rounds 2-3​


i

Seattle Seahawks

The picks: Nick Emmanwori (No. 35), Elijah Arroyo(No. 50), Jalen Milroe (No. 92)

Seattle came up 17 spots from No. 52 to take Emmanwori early in Round 2. The Seahawks handed a third-rounder to Houston, but they had four Day 2 picks entering the day. And Emmanwori, my No. 17 overall prospect, was still sitting there at No. 35. The Seahawks love toolsy players in their secondary, and Emmanwori has a lot of standout traits. He's explosive, physical and fast, as we saw at the combine. And he is a ball hawk on the back end, picking off four passes last season.

Down the board, the Seahawks got new quarterback Sam Darnold another pass catcher with Arroyo. He plays tight end, but he's essentially a big wide receiver. He'll bring speed and a wide catch radius, and offensive coordinator Klint Kubiak is going to move him around to find mismatches against the coverage. Arroyo was 37th on my board, so the value is right, too.

To cap it all off, the Seahawks went and got a quarterback to learn behind Darnold. This should have been Shedeur Sanders. But I do like the fit a lot, and the value is still really strong for Milroe. He can hit the deep ball with accuracy, and he's a true difference-maker as a runner on designed carries and scrambles. Defensive coordinators are going to be worried about offensive packages shaped around his run-game traits this season, and he has the chance to develop into a starter down the road.


i

Arizona Cardinals

The picks: Will Johnson (No. 47), Jordan Burch (No. 78)

On Thursday, Adam Schefter reported that Johnson has a knee issue that scared teams off in Round 1. But when healthy, he's the complete package. Johnson had nine career interceptions, thanks to his high-end instincts, quickness and diagnosing ability. He was No. 11 on my board, and two corners whom I had ranked below him -- Jahdae Barron and Maxwell Hairston -- went on Day 1. We're going to look back at this pick and wonder how Johnson slid all the way to the middle of Round 2. Arizona took care of a big need in a big way. Johnson will start outside right out of the gate and should improve a pass defense that allowed opponents to complete 68.6% of throws last season (29th in the league). The Cards also landed Burch to put pressure on NFC West quarterbacks.


i

Houston Texans

The picks: Jayden Higgins (No. 34), Aireontae Ersery(No. 48), Jaylin Noel (No. 79), Jaylin Smith (No. 97)

The Texans traded back on Thursday, which meant they had to check off needs on Friday. One was wide receiver. Stefon Diggs signed in New England after missing much of last season with a torn ACL. Tank Dell's return timeline from his own knee injury is uncertain. They traded for Christian Kirk, but the Texans had to do more to support C.J. Stroud in Year 3. Higgins is a big 6-foot-4 pass catcher who had 1,183 yards last season. I preferred Luther Burden III, and it's a slight reach for Higgins based on my board (No. 53), but it's a solid pick for an offense that needed a boost.

The better value came when Houston took Higgins' Iowa State teammate. Noel -- 56th in my rankings -- is speedy slot man with reliable hands, and he's going to make things happen after the catch for Stroud. Higgins and Noel will slide in alongside Nico Collins.

The other need to address was offensive line. Houston had another second-rounder and traded up to get Ersery, who brings 6-foot-6, 331-pound size and the power to drive defensive ends off the ball. Texans O-line coach Cole Popovich has a lot to work with in Ersery's skill set. Remember, the Texans completely turned over the offensive line after giving up 54 sacks last season, tied for the third most. Ersery could play early here.
i

Philadelphia Eagles

The pick: Andrew Mukuba (No. 64)

Every year I put out a list of my favorite prospects at every position heading into the draft. These are the Day 2 or Day 3 picks who have great tape and should outplay their draft slot. Mukuba was the first member of the 2025 list to get drafted this year. I love Mukuba's game. He's 5-foot-11 and 186 pounds, but he plays so much bigger and hits like a linebacker. Mukuba is a top-five safety on my board, and I could see him popping into the lineup in C.J. Gardner-Johnson's vacated spot.


i

New York Giants

The pick: Darius Alexander (No. 65)

Great pick. The Giants' roster still has a lot of holes. But their pass rush is a massive strength. They added Abdul Carter early in the third round Thursday, and they already had Brian Burns and Kayvon Thibodeaux. Now they go get Alexander, who plays with speed, physicality and bend. He simply wreaks havoc in the backfield (nine tackles for loss last season), and the Giants will be able to line him up anywhere. I thought he might go early in Round 2, as he was ranked No. 39 on my board. The Giants got him in Round 3. New York's defense is going to put some quarterbacks on the ground this season.


i

Chicago Bears

The picks: Luther Burden III (No. 39), Ozzy Trapilo(No. 56), Shemar Turner (No. 62)

If Caleb Williams doesn't break out this season, there are going to be a lot of questions. The Bears have cleaned up this offense in a hurry, starting with the offensive line moves in free agency and continuing into the first two days of the draft. They took seam-stretching Colston Loveland in the first round, and then landed Burden on Day 2. He's really, really good after the catch. His 2024 numbers were down a little bit (676 yards), but the quarterback play was shaky at Missouri. Burden can play. He's explosive, and he will be able to take crossers and slants from Williams for first downs -- and then some -- in Chicago.

Chicago also drafted Trapilo in Round 2; he could push Braxton Jones for work at left tackle. No more excuses for Caleb. Watch this offense take off in 2025. But the Bears weren't done: Turner will join Grady Jarrett and Gervon Dexter Sr. on the interior defensive line. Good Day 2 haul for an up-and-coming team.

i

New York Jets

The picks: Mason Taylor (No. 42), Azareye'h Thomas(No. 73)

The Jets passed on Tyler Warren and Loveland in Round 1. I would have probably taken a tight end at No. 7, but I do like the Armand Membou pick. I like it even more now that the Jets came back on Friday and got Taylor. He's consistent. He has great hands and runs superb routes. Justin Fields is going to love putting the ball up to the 6-foot-5 target downfield. Taylor isn't going to blow you away with his after-the-catch ability or his blocking, but he's going to make the offense better in New York. And there's this: His dad, Jason Taylor, played one season with the Jets.

Plus, getting Thomas in Round 3 was really good value. I had him No. 47 overall. His recovery speed is impressive, and his Senior Bowl performance showed what he can do against top-tier receivers. Thomas will get reps opposite Sauce Gardner.


i

Dallas Cowboys

The picks: Donovan Ezeiruaku (No. 44), Shavon Revel Jr. (No. 76)

OK, here's some good value. Ezeiruaku was No. 23 on my board. Dallas got him halfway through Round 2. Ezeiruaku led the FBS in pressures last season with 65, and he had 16.5 sacks. Simply put, he gets after the quarterback. The Cowboys now have Micah Parsons, Dante Fowler Jr. and Ezeiruaku coming off the edge, so they will once again put up some strong sack numbers. Ezeiruaku isn't going to help much against the run, but he's going to feast on NFC passers on third down when he can pin his ears back.

Dallas kept going on defense. Trevon Diggs and DaRon Bland are both capable cornerbacks with elite ball skills, but they have both dealt with injuries. Plus, the Cowboys lost reliable slot corner Jourdan Lewis in free agency. So, Revel should contribute. He tore his ACLin 2024, which caused his stock to fall a little. But he's long and fast, and like Diggs and Bland, he makes plays on the ball. He looked like a first-rounder early in the 2024 season before the injury, so this is nice value for my No. 55 prospect. I actually had him projected to Dallas in the three-round mock draft that Field Yates and I did two weeks ago -- one round earlier.

I was critical of the Cowboys' approach to Round 1, reaching for guard Tyler Booker at No. 12. But this was a good recovery

 
Back
Top Bottom