Pierre Garcon or Reggie Wayne

[Robs88]

Im not jumping the gun on Manning just yet, Lets assume he does sign with the dolphins which one of these receivers will go guys choose as
both have stated interest in playing for Miami if Peyton does sign here.

 

[Valbon8]

Neither are really necessary. Hartline will do just fine with a QB like Manning. We need to spend that money elsewhere (OL, S, Pass Rusher).

 

[JCane]

No sense in having Pierre Garcon at all. We already have a slot receiver.

Reggie Wayne all day. Better talent, better receiver. Reggie Wayne forces teams to play single-coverage on Brandon Marshall. This opens up the field for a slot receiver like Davone Bess.

 

[CalDolFan10x14]

No sense in having Pierre Garcon at all. We already have a slot receiver.

Reggie Wayne all day. Better talent, better receiver. Reggie Wayne forces teams to play single-coverage on Brandon Marshall. This opens up the field for a slot receiver like Davone Bess.

This.

 

[Vertical Limit]

Rather have the sure handed and most experience one in Wayne.

 

[Mr. Day]

Neither are really necessary. Hartline will do just fine with a QB like Manning. We need to spend that money elsewhere (OL, S, Pass Rusher).

Nobody can make Hartline look good.

 

[foozool13]

Wayne...we r in win now mode if we get manning...no brainer to me

 

[CMD]

Nobody can make Hartline look good.

Hartline looked just fine with Moore, if Hartline could stay on his feet after a long catch and break some damn tackles he would be a damn good receiver.

But I want Reggie Wayne over Garcon, to force A team to pick either Marshall or Wayne to double is better than anything Garcon would bring.

 

[Funky Fin]

Wayne. Bring the brother back to Miami!

Let's not forget that Wayne and Manning also won their Super Bowl right here in South Florida.

 

[Zounds]

Michael Floyd