Please No More David Carr Threads--He Sucks!!

[tmny99]

Please spare us any more David Carr threads. The guy is horrible. He stares down his receivers (ala AJ Feely), has no pocket presence (ala Brian Griese during his stint in Miami). I know the guy's line is horrible, but he only got sacked once tonight, and he still played like garbage (19/36 182yds and a pick 6 [another Feelyesque move]).

 

[Rocky Raccoon]

Please spare us any more David Carr threads. The guy is horrible. He stares down his receivers (ala AJ Feely), has no pocket presence (ala Brian Griese during his stint in Miami). I know the guy's line is horrible, but he only got sacked once tonight, and he still played like garbage (19/36 182yds and a pick 6 [another Feelyesque move]).

you have succesfully bashed a player on one game, good job.

 

[infiltrateib]

you have succesfully bashed a player on one game, good job.

I wouldn't say he's terrible, but a career rating of 73 isn't going to cut it.

 

[RAS25]

Please spare us any more David Carr threads. The guy is horrible. He stares down his receivers (ala AJ Feely), has no pocket presence (ala Brian Griese during his stint in Miami). I know the guy's line is horrible, but he only got sacked once tonight, and he still played like garbage (19/36 182yds and a pick 6 [another Feelyesque move]).

eli played horrible vs minny and didnt he trow a pick6 that dude is a bust

 

[RAS25]

I wouldn't say he's terrible, but a career rating of 73 isn't going to cut it.

neither is the team management or coaching

 

[T BONE]

eli played horrible vs minny and didnt he trow a pick6 that dude is a bust

This might be a dumb question, but whats a pick 6?

 

[Rocky Raccoon]

This might be a dumb question, but whats a pick 6?

INT returned for a TD... six points

 

[tmny99]

you have succesfully bashed a player on one game, good job.

Look at his career stats. Not just one game bro.

 

[tmny99]

eli played horrible vs minny and didnt he trow a pick6 that dude is a bust

Eli has made the progression to gradually get better. Carr has regressed.

 

[T BONE]

INT returned for a TD... six points

Thanks, never heard of that.

 

[Rocky Raccoon]

Look at his career stats. Not just one game bro.

ehh I guess your right, I still think he's better than his stats show. I wouldn't mind him playing for us.

 

[PressCoverage]

I wouldn't say he's terrible, but a career rating of 73 isn't going to cut it.

i'm sorry... but what was Terry Bradshaw's rating before 1974? just curious... anyone know? perhaps just his % and TD/INT ratio?

 

[Maynard the Hammer]

i actually didnt think carr played that poorly. i didnt watch the whole game, though.

i'll just say that i wasnt encouraged, but the guy has a great arm thats accurate. he just hasnt put together the rest of it yet

 

[RAS25]

Eli has made the progression to gradually get better. Carr has regressed.

o rly? carrs completion % has gotten better every year and mistakes decreased and playcalling has gotten worse.....the coaching staff deserves some blame for his progression

 

[RAS25]

Look at his career stats. Not just one game bro.

look at his stats then look at his team they have 1legit starter on that team and he has been hurt all this year....look at his stats last year not horrible at all