Poll : Our WORST starting QB since Marino

[insomnia411]

Let's have some fun with this.

Pat White doesn't count because he never started a game.
I understand that I left some guys off the list list like Sage Rosenfels and Cleo Lemon, but I only had so many poll spaces for names, and I created an OTHER option if you think that Tyler Thigpen was the worst of the worst for example.

For me, I gotta go with John Beck and I think he just edges out AJ Feeley for the worst Dolphins QB I've ever seen.
Feeley was really bad, but he had a pretty good arm and was out there trying to make big throws, he just had absolutely no help and he was a moron. John Beck (also not much help) was just an absolute wuss that played scared, fumled snaps, had a noodle arm and just had no ability to play the position.

 

[greasyObnoxious]

looking at that list, i need a drink now...

 

[andyahs]

All of them.

 

[Buddy]

Ray Lucas was a dumpster fire on another level from these other guys!

 

[SQuinn17]

Lucas was by far the worst. Followed by Beck. I have Osweiler and Cleo Lemon on the same level of awfulness too, but did we really expect them to be good?

 

[Vaark]

Lucas concur!

 

[RastaMan407]

Wow ok?? Lets set a starting minimum of 8 games and decide from there. Most of those QBs on the list didn’t even play 5 games. Based off that criteria here are my choices.

1. Cleo Lemon
2. Joey Harrington

 

[AdamD13]

Like trying to pick out the worst in punch bowl full of turds.

I am going with Culpepper because I remember some experts trying to convince me he was playing well in a Dolphin uniform when he was playing.

 

[Mr. Day]

A.J Feeley was one of the worst quarterbacks that I have seen in my life. I cursed him out every time I saw him on my television screen.

 

[dolphinkev]

I will take Beck at least Feeley had a Great Moment in 2004 Monday Night Game against the Pats.

 

[traptses]

Wow, what a god awful list of QBs. A lot of different acceptable answers. From an expectation sense, either through the draft or trade, Culpepper, Feeley, Rosen, Beck, and Henne all cost us a 2nd round pick. Terrible value on those picks, but I don’t think any of them were our worst QB performance wise.

I think I would have to go with Lucas. Lemon gets honorable mention, but his game winning pass to save an 0-16 season saves him.

 

[circumstances]

 

[DPhinz_DPhinz]

I would say Ray Lucas...by a long shot, but Osweiller tapped me on the shoulder and said, "You forgot about me."

The silver lining in us signing Lucas is that he would be 1st team All-Pro the 2 times the Jets played us, and 1st team Awww No! against everyone else. We destroyed his career to the point that we wouldn't have to worry about him anymore.

 

[Retnuhrace]

But Cleo Lemon gave us that magical Greg Camarillo moment!

 

[MrChadRico]

I had to go Culpepper. Because not only did he stick up the joint he also cost us the All Time NFL Passing Leader!