position analysis of upcoming draft | FinHeaven - Miami Dolphins Forums

position analysis of upcoming draft

adamprez2003

FinHeaven VIP
Joined
Sep 7, 2004
Messages
12,035
Reaction score
784
Location
New York
http://www.profootballweekly.com/PFW/The+Way+We+Hear+It/WWHI/2006/wwhi2129.htm
At wide receiver, PFW projected only one senior, LSU’s Dwayne Bowe, as a first-round-caliber talent before juniors Calvin Johnson (Georgia Tech), Ted Ginn Jr. (Ohio State), Dwayne Jarrett (USC) and Robert Meachem (Tennessee) entered the mix. The crop of pass catchers has now become deep enough to make it possible to find some talented receivers even on the second day of the draft.
Juniors have also made their presence felt at the RB position, but that’s solely due to the draft declarations of Adrian Peterson, an Oklahoma Sooner who PFW is predicting will be selected as soon as the third pick overall in the first round and California product Marshawn Lynch, who figures to be a top-15 pick in Round One. Aside from those two, this year’s stable of backs appears extremely weak.
On the other side of the ball, the DE crop was definitely fortified by three solid juniors from the Southeastern Conference — Jarvis Moss (Florida), Jamaal Anderson (Arkansas) and Charles Johnson (Georgia). A case could be made for defensive end as this year’s strongest position, at least at the top of the litter, with seniors Gaines Adams (Clemson), Quentin Moses (Georgia), Anthony Spencer (Purdue) and Adam Carriker (Nebraska) expected to attract a lot of attention.
Arguably the strongest position this year will be safety, with three seniors — LaRon Landry (LSU), Michael Griffin (Texas) and Brandon Meriweather (Miami, Fla.) — all potentially fitting into the first round, as well as Florida junior Reggie Nelson.


What follows is a quick assessment of the talent levels at the other positions not previously mentioned:
Quarterbacks — Good but not great, headlined by Notre Dame’s Brady Quinn and enigmatic, boom-or-bust LSU junior JaMarcus Russell. Stanford’s Trent Edwards has a lot of uspide, but it will be difficult to find more than backups in the rest of the class.
Fullbacks — As bad a class as there’s been in recent years with only a handful who may get drafted.
Tight ends One of the weakest positions in the draft. Miami’s (Fla.) Greg Olsen will work out well and may intrigue some late in first round.
Centers — Class is typically weak and doesn’t feature a first-rounder.
Guards — Class is heavy on converted offensive tackles and former defensive tackles and is solid at the top, with several players potentially fitting into the first round, but the group is thin overall.
Offensive tackles — Class features some premier top talent but, like guard, is not deep. Wisconsin’s Joe Thomas is a top-line left tackle, but Penn State’s Levi Brown, once his technique improves, may have more upside. Both of them are top prospects.
Defensive tackles — Michigan junior Alan Branch is the prize of the group. Otherwise, the position is marked by a lot of overrated prospects and is among the weakest in the draft.
Inside linebackers — A typically weak group. Mississippi’s Patrick Willis is the standout of the class. Florida junior Brandon Siler is high-maintenance but talented.
Outside linebackers — Two juniors — Miami’s (Fla.) Jon Beason and Florida State’s Lawrence Timmons — head the class, along with rock-solid Penn State senior Paul Posluszny. Not nearly as strong as last year’s class, but it was improved by early-entry juniors.
Cornerbacks — Not a good year for corners, with no true elite prospect rising to the forefront. Michigan’s Leon Hall had the best senior year. A number of juniors could factor into the first day, but they all could have benefited from another year in school.
Specialists — Nothing special. Colorado PK Mason Crosby is the best of the bunch.
 
I think that maybe Drew Stanton and Troy Smith have starter-like qualities, although it it will take them a couple years as backups, but otherwise I agree with the QB assessment
 
Brandon Siler is "high-maintenance"??? :hmmm:

Whats that supposed to mean for a football player???

I've heard of girls being high-maintenance but not football players. :lol:
 
I dont know anything about the guy's personality. That's their take on him. Take it for what its worth

Yeah I know, I wasn't directing that comment at you by any means.

I've watched every game this guy has played the last 2 years and read countless articles on him during that time and you'd be hard pressed to find a more responsible, hardworking guy than Brandon Siler. Very standup guy.
 
Yeah I know, I wasn't directing that comment at you by any means.

I've watched every game this guy has played the last 2 years and read countless articles on him during that time and you'd be hard pressed to find a more responsible, hardworking guy than Brandon Siler. Very standup guy.

Yeah its kinda weird. Read his official bio and I think he was on the Leadership council or something like that. Seemed pretty standup. Did he have any problems with the law?
 
Yeah its kinda weird. Read his official bio and I think he was on the Leadership council or something like that. Seemed pretty standup. Did he have any problems with the law?

Not at all that I can remember.
 
Overall, seems like another so-so draft, typical when we are in position to get a good player.
 
Brandon Siler is "high-maintenance"??? :hmmm:

Whats that supposed to mean for a football player???

I've heard of girls being high-maintenance but not football players. :lol:

It usually means a player needs lots of coaching but I don't understand how they come to that conclusion based on his weigh in.
 
It usually means a player needs lots of coaching but I don't understand how they come to that conclusion based on his weigh in.

This isn't based on Senior Bowl weigh-ins, Siler is a Junior.

Even by that defention its a ridiculous statement.
 
http://www.profootballweekly.com/PFW/The+Way+We+Hear+It/WWHI/2006/wwhi2129.htm
At wide receiver, PFW projected only one senior, LSU’s Dwayne Bowe, as a first-round-caliber talent before juniors Calvin Johnson (Georgia Tech), Ted Ginn Jr. (Ohio State), Dwayne Jarrett (USC) and Robert Meachem (Tennessee) entered the mix. The crop of pass catchers has now become deep enough to make it possible to find some talented receivers even on the second day of the draft.
Juniors have also made their presence felt at the RB position, but that’s solely due to the draft declarations of Adrian Peterson, an Oklahoma Sooner who PFW is predicting will be selected as soon as the third pick overall in the first round and California product Marshawn Lynch, who figures to be a top-15 pick in Round One. Aside from those two, this year’s stable of backs appears extremely weak.
On the other side of the ball, the DE crop was definitely fortified by three solid juniors from the Southeastern Conference  Jarvis Moss (Florida), Jamaal Anderson (Arkansas) and Charles Johnson (Georgia). A case could be made for defensive end as this year’s strongest position, at least at the top of the litter, with seniors Gaines Adams (Clemson), Quentin Moses (Georgia), Anthony Spencer (Purdue) and Adam Carriker (Nebraska) expected to attract a lot of attention.
Arguably the strongest position this year will be safety, with three seniors  LaRon Landry (LSU), Michael Griffin (Texas) and Brandon Meriweather (Miami, Fla.)  all potentially fitting into the first round, as well as Florida junior Reggie Nelson.


What follows is a quick assessment of the talent levels at the other positions not previously mentioned:
Quarterbacks  Good but not great, headlined by Notre Dame’s Brady Quinn and enigmatic, boom-or-bust LSU junior JaMarcus Russell. Stanford’s Trent Edwards has a lot of uspide, but it will be difficult to find more than backups in the rest of the class.
Fullbacks  As bad a class as there’s been in recent years with only a handful who may get drafted.
Tight ends  One of the weakest positions in the draft. Miami’s (Fla.) Greg Olsen will work out well and may intrigue some late in first round.
Centers  Class is typically weak and doesn’t feature a first-rounder.
Guards  Class is heavy on converted offensive tackles and former defensive tackles and is solid at the top, with several players potentially fitting into the first round, but the group is thin overall.
Offensive tackles  Class features some premier top talent but, like guard, is not deep. Wisconsin’s Joe Thomas is a top-line left tackle, but Penn State’s Levi Brown, once his technique improves, may have more upside. Both of them are top prospects.
Defensive tackles  Michigan junior Alan Branch is the prize of the group. Otherwise, the position is marked by a lot of overrated prospects and is among the weakest in the draft.
Inside linebackers  A typically weak group. Mississippi’s Patrick Willis is the standout of the class. Florida junior Brandon Siler is high-maintenance but talented.
Outside linebackers  Two juniors  Miami’s (Fla.) Jon Beason and Florida State’s Lawrence Timmons  head the class, along with rock-solid Penn State senior Paul Posluszny. Not nearly as strong as last year’s class, but it was improved by early-entry juniors.
Cornerbacks  Not a good year for corners, with no true elite prospect rising to the forefront. Michigan’s Leon Hall had the best senior year. A number of juniors could factor into the first day, ut they all could have benefited from another year in school.
Specialists  Nothing special. Colorado PK Mason Crosby is the best of the bunch.

I dunno about fullbacks. Brian Leonard will be a beast in this league.
 
Trent Edwards QB from Stanford is a sleeper I say we steal him in the 3rd or 4th round
 
Back
Top Bottom