Pro Football Weekly: Dolphins Have Best Draft | FinHeaven - Miami Dolphins Forums

Pro Football Weekly: Dolphins Have Best Draft

infiltrateib

TV Doctor
Joined
Oct 14, 2002
Messages
2,095
Reaction score
1
Age
44
Location
Bay Area, CA
By: Jeff Reynolds
http://www.profootballweekly.com/PFW/NFLDraft/Draft+Extras/2005/reynolds042505.htm

Two days before the first pick was made, Dolphins triggerman Nick Saban finally facilitated a trade to unload CB Patrick Surtain and his $8 million salary to Kansas City. Saban had been hunting to reclaim a second-round pick since the Dolphins dealt theirs in February 2004 to the Eagles for raw-as-oysters QB A.J. Feeley. That trade was integral in making Miami’s draft a smashing success. We can agree to disagree that Ronnie Brown of Auburn wasn’t the best back in the draft  Cedric Benson is all beast, and proven as a 300-carry workhorse  but there might not be a player drafted among the top 15 picks with more potential. Brown hasn’t had the chance to show what he might be able to do as a featured back, but he did torch Saban’s LSU Tigers on multiple occasions. Now Saban can run him down the throats of the defensively loaded AFC East. The “Surtain selection†became Iowa DE Matt Roth, a powder keg of a defensive end who shone at the Senior Bowl and carries many of the same traits that made Georgia DE David Pollack the 17th overall pick to Cincinnati  only Roth came off 29 picks later. LB Channing Crowder of Florida had knee and legal issues  not a great combination  in college and fell all the way to the 70th pick. Sharing a locker room and meeting room with LBs Junior Seau and Zach Thomas could turn Crowder into one of the real Draft Day steals. LSU CB Travis Daniels must have been worth the Dolphins’ fourth-round pick  Saban was his coach in Baton Rouge and would have avoided pulling the trigger otherwise. And store away the name of Anthony Alabi (Texas Christian). A fifth-round pick, the offensive tackle could blossom for million-dollar OL coach Hudson Houck. Last year, Houck turned seventh-round pick Shane Olivea into a good starter for the Chargers.

Give some credit to Dallas, my runner-up, which added four players who had top-50 grades during the regular season  DE-OLB Demarcus Ware, DL Marcus Spears, OLB Kevin Burnett and DE-OLB Chris Canty. They also drafted RB Marion Barber, a solid return man and backup to Julius Jones.

Philadelphia gets the bronze, which is no surprise considering the Eagles have a tendency to hit more than they miss.
 
That's what I keep saying about Daniels. There should be no one questioning that pick. There wasn't one single player taken by any team in the entire NFL that was more completely scouted by the headcoach, than Travis Daniels.
 
His salary was $5.85 million not $8 million

No way Miami had the best draft :shakeno:

I would say the Ravens did better
 
yeah... it's a nice write-up.

I think that the majority of write-up that I have read have been decent but they are not really raving about our draft, which I think is suprising. On paper: Brown, Roth and Crowder are as good as any team with 3 first day picks.
 
inFINSible said:
That's what I keep saying about Daniels. There should be no one questioning that pick. There wasn't one single player taken by any team in the entire NFL that was more completely scouted by the headcoach, than Travis Daniels.

I agree, that should be a safe assumption. Even though by his own admission Saban went into the second day looking for a corner, I wouldn't think he would reach for one of his own boys when there was still considerable talent left on the board unless this guy was worth it.

The fact that he didn't draft Wilkerson late or any of his other LSU players should back that up.
 
Clumpy said:
His salary was $5.85 million not $8 million

No way Miami had the best draft :shakeno:

I would say the Ravens did better


I think it is silly to grade the draft at this juncture. No one has any idea which of the players will be busts or superstars. Neither PFW, nor even the Clump
 
The Best(IMO)

Arizona
Dallas
Cleveland
Minnesota

Honorable mention
Miami
San Diego
San Francisco
Philadelphia
 
Clumpy said:
His salary was $5.85 million not $8 million

No way Miami had the best draft :shakeno:

I would say the Ravens did better

Its always debatable Clump, but we can safely say Buffalo didn't.

I don't think any team with the one traditional 1st, 2nd and 3rd round picks did better.

We have three guys that IMO will greatly impact this team for the next 5 to 10 years.
 
vmarcilfan75 said:
The Best(IMO)

Arizona
Dallas
Cleveland
Minnesota

Honorable mention
Miami
San Diego
San Francisco
Philadelphia
I'd switch San Diego for Cleveland. I think now we're seeing where the brains in Buffalo were - they've moved to California, and Buffalo's personnel moves have been horrible ever since.
 
Clumpy said:
His salary was $5.85 million not $8 million

No way Miami had the best draft :shakeno:

I would say the Ravens did better

Well, draft grades are all over the place...but everyone that I've seen has kinda bashed Buffalo's so far. :tongue: Still, no one that I"ve seen has graded Miami below a "B". So whichever way you look at it, the Phins did well.
 
Dallas had a very good draft. It's all ridiculous to really rate them at this point. However, given what we had going into the draft early last week (5 picks), yet coming up with three excellent selections in rounds 1-3 and a couple of very good prospects in the latter rounds, I think we did fine. I'd put our draft in the top 3-5 at this point.

If the top three stay healthy, they will all be full-time starters and very significant contributors by year two. Three effective, quality starters would make this head-and-shoulders the best draft since 1997 - when we went Madison, Taylor and Rodgers. That was the last draft we got as many as three QUALITY starters.
 
Back
Top Bottom