QB who would you rather have? | FinHeaven - Miami Dolphins Forums

QB who would you rather have?

PHAZINPHINZPHAN

PHAZINPHINZPHAN

Seasoned Veteran
Joined
Jul 20, 2005
Messages
762
Reaction score
37
Age
49
Location
Palmdale
Which QB would you want to lead your franchise next year
100% healthy Donovan McNabb
100% healthy Daunte Culpepper
100% healthy Drew Brees.

Also which WR would you like to see come compliment your new QB?
Healthy Randy Moss
Healthy Terrell Owens
Healthy Reggie Wayne

Answers with explanations would be nice.
keep in mind any of these combinations could happen this is the NFL.
Just something to think about
 
Actually Mcnabb can't happen. He is gonna be with the Eagles untill he retires more then likely. So with us not having a shot for him I will turn and choose another quarterback. I'd more than likely want Culpepper and Randy Moss here. They went hog wild up there in Minnesota and they could do the same thing for us. So either Culpepper/Moss or Brees/Moss.
 
I think he means hypothetically.

I would take McNabb and Moss. McNabb makes plays that just arent supposed to be able to be made. He is an athletic QB, but his greatest strength is probably his accuracy. His arm strength is also top notch. Moss is probably the most talented WR ever. His size/speed combo is unnatural. When he wants to he can dominate. With the right coaching and the right QB he could be the greatest of all time.
 
culpepper and moss... history speaks for itself on that one. Combine all that with a better, faster Defense than Minnesota had. The Fins and Colts would be the topic on ESPN everyday if that were the case. But like I've stated several times, if we can get ahold of Daunte in the offseason despite his injury, we better pull the trigger on him.
 
PHAZINPHINZPHAN said:
Which QB would you want to lead your franchise next year
100% healthy Donovan McNabb
100% healthy Daunte Culpepper
100% healthy Drew Brees.

Also which WR would you like to see come compliment your new QB?
Healthy Randy Moss
Healthy Terrell Owens
Healthy Reggie Wayne

Answers with explanations would be nice.
keep in mind any of these combinations could happen this is the NFL.
Just something to think about
Click to expand...

McNabb
Moss - Maybe the second best WR ever
 
A 23 year old Marino
 
Cullpeper and Moss without any hesitation whatsoever!!! This offense would be SICK with these two back together plus with the plethera of talent we already have in Chambers, Mcmike, Brown, Williams, Booker, Welker.........Whoa!!!!
 
Brees and Moss.
Brees is the most accurate and reads Ds the best. I have real concerns about Peppers ability in the matter and real questions about McNabb's accuracy.
Moss has the most talent and seems to have dropped his baggage.
 
Culpepper and Moss couldn't get things worked out in Minn, I don't think they will work anywhere else. I think Brees and Moss or Owens would be my choice. I don't like McNabb I think he plays well as long as his competition is below avg,but when he plays teams that are tough he has problems. I watch a lot of Eagles football living in Eagle country. The team is shoved down my throat. Andy Reid and McNabb are the two main reasons the Eagles lost the SB to the Pats.

I know some here think he's great and thats fine, but I see him and his playing every week, more then I see my own team. McNabb has this thing he does when losing. All of sudden the injuries he has are much more obvious when he's losing but when he's lighting things up you'd never know he has an injury. McNabb is supposed to have this injury to his groin and it's keeping him from running and making things happen, but when he scores a TD he's high kicking like Michael Jackson and jumping and giving high fives. He also can throw a football seventy yrds down field but he can't take a hit?? If your having the kind of injury McNabb has how can you wind up and throw a ball seventy yrds down field or do a stupid dance in the endzone when his team is winning but you can't do any of those things when your team losing??
 
Great responses from everyone. I myself would like to see TO and culpepper. I Think we could get TO cheap and culpepper at a bargain consideering his injury. And still have a little cash to beef up the O-line and the secondary
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top Bottom