Quarterback Wish | FinHeaven - Miami Dolphins Forums

Quarterback Wish

Pick one that you wish was on Miami

  • Tom Brady

    Votes: 43 27.9%

  • Matt Hasselbeck

    Votes: 12 7.8%

  • Peyton Manning

    Votes: 58 37.7%

  • Ben Roethlisberger

    Votes: 30 19.5%

  • Donovan McNabb

    Votes: 11 7.1%
  • Total voters
    154
Roethlisberger due mostly to his age.
 
Brady- Id be hoping he got hurt every game I hate him as a person

Hasslebeck- Good but not superstar

Big Ben- Good young QB but I think his team does carry him a little

Peyton- Cant seem to win a big game, although he is a great QB

Mcnabb- I like him good leader, football wise he is very smart, he is athletic and has a great arm

Id take Mcnabb I like QB's who are mobile
 
Alex22 said:
Brady- Id be hoping he got hurt every game I hate him as a person

Hasslebeck- Good but not superstar

Big Ben- Good young QB but I think his team does carry him a little

Peyton- Cant seem to win a big game, although he is a great QB

Mcnabb- I like him good leader, football wise he is very smart, he is athletic and has a great arm

Id take Mcnabb I like QB's who are mobile
Click to expand...


Are you kidding me. Like it or not if the Dolphins actually had to make this choice and they chose anyone but Brady or Manning, they would be the laughing stock of the NFL. Brady hands down, and I can't stand him either but after that first SB win I'd get over it pretty fast.
 
Brady-Class. An A-hole but pure class QB.(I'd say we'd get over his personality if he won a few SBs with us)

McNabb-a bluffer. I don't think he is a good leader and don't think he has the bottle to win a championship.

Manning-we'd need a far better OL than we do and still ?s at the final hurdle

Big Ben-has done nothing to get ahead of Brady except happen to be younger

Hasselbeck-did little wrong sunday or all season. Honestly can't say why I wouldn't pick him except that he's a bit, I dunno, boring or something. I've always imagined our next great QB to be a bit more exciting, more of a gunslinger.
 
Tom Brady in a landslide. Not only is he a great winner, but he is HOT as hell.
 
spanish jonny said:
Brady-Class. An A-hole but pure class QB.(I'd say we'd get over his personality if he won a few SBs with us)
quote]

What??? Brady, and A-hole?!?!? I doubt that. What are you basing your feeling on? What, that he did the coin toss, that he said his team was disrepected? Please - that is just pure jealous homerism.

I doubt if Brady was an A-hole, he would be as loved by his teammates, and even former teammates...let alone Jason Taylor, who considers him a good friend. ...or would SI have voted him Sportsman of the Year?!?!? Doubt it!

Brady happens to be one of the Good things in sports! You hate him because he is great and plays for the Pats. Nothing wrong with that, but he is not at all known for being a jerk or an A-hole - quite the opposite!

Sour Grapes - get over it. Brady is NOT going away nor is he going to wear a Dolphins uniform. Damned it!!!!!
Click to expand...
 
I answered this question with the impression that it was a QB we really could have gotten. I don't recall that we ever had a shot at getting any of those QB's except one, Hasselbeck. I read in the Herald that he was pretty much ours from GB except that Speilturd couldn't make a decision to save his life and GB have him to Seattle instead. So when asked who I wish we could have gotten I said Hasselbeck because we should have gotten him. Otherwise the choice I think is pretty clear that it would be Brady or Peyton, probably Brady. Although with that last staff it wouldn't matter who we got, the team would still suck.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top Bottom