Question That I Was Asked This Morning

[EasyRider]

Someone brought up the dumb trade that Mike Ditka made years ago when he traded his whole draft for Ricky Williams

I was a flat out NO

But it is interesting in that if Tua is done, let’s say he walks away, and I wouldn’t blame the kid, but let’s say he does, would you trade all our picks in the next draft to move up and grab a QB in the top 3 picks

First, you college nuts, who is entering the draft next year that you like. Would love to hear about the prospects coming.

Anyway, the reason I bring this question up is because we have Five picks and no 1s this year. Being we are limited is it worth giving them up to grab the new hot commodity?

I say no because I would love a real smart GM (don’t know if we have one) who could do his homework and score with someone in the third round, like Wilson and a few others were found and still have a few picks to work with.

Or do you trade the five picks and gamble the hot prospect turns into a franchise QB

???

 

[Danny]

Nobody’s going to give us a top 5 picks for what we have.....in order to move up to 5 you always have to give up at least a late first plus a lot more so that's not happening

 

[BigSmoke]

No

 

[Maybe Memories]

He chose tua and he traded for bradley chubb.

If we had a different GM i would say lets do it.

What i will say…. Anyone thinking of taking a chance on Anthony Richardson? From FU? He is a raw talent but he is something i would like to see as a mid-late round pick.

 

[fishbanger]

See what eagles did. Find a jalen hurts

 

[utahphinsfan]

The stupidest thing Grier could do is channel his inner Ditka for Stroud or Young.

That said, I am intrigued by Sam Hartman (Wake Forest) who just entered the transfer portal. He is currently projected as a day 3 pick. SH is hoping another yr improves his stock

Being a bit of a homer, I also like Cam Rising in the 4th or 5th this yr

 

[AdamD13]

Three QBs will go in the top 10, Young (Bama), Stroud (OSU), and Levis (Kentucky).

Texans aren’t trading out of taking one.

Broncos, Bears, and Cardinals are the only teams that might.

The cost for Miami to move into the top 10 will probably deplete the next three drafts to do so.

Can’t put it past Grier because he has been handing out top draft picks like Santa Clause since trading down with SF, and his job might be on the line.

5 minutes after the SF trade he sent two 1st round picks to move up 6 spots.

Spent the majority of this year’s draft on Tyreek and added a record breaking contract to boot.

Spent next year’s 1st on Chub added another lucrative contract.

And of course upper management recklessness took away another 1st.

Bottom line. Miami doesn’t have the ammo to get a blue chip prospect at QB and even if they did the teams depth is going to be so depleted from salary cap restrictions and lack of quality draft picks, the Dolphins are better off not to.

Maybe McD will play along where Flores wouldn’t and engage in “Worst for Williams” next year, Caleb that is.

 

[DolfanSince93]

Depends on the GM. I don’t trust the incumbent moron to draft the right guy, so, until he’s gone, they need to rely on proven vets via free agency/trade.

 

[ForksPhin]

No….no….and no again for emphasis.

Not enough ammo, regardless. And the quality isn’t there at the top of the draft to make any move up for a QB.

 

[Fred Bear]

No good qaurterbacks in 2023

 

[AdamD13]

No good qaurterbacks in 2023

Bryce Young is definitely legit. Checks every box with one question mark.

Can he stay healthy since he is undersized?

Stroud maybe. Rarely was pressured and like most QBs wasn’t as effective when he was.

Levis played with minimal talent surrounding him so has the tools, but questions remain.

Of course might be another Purdy out there. No way of knowing.

 

[eMCee85]

Someone brought up the dumb trade that Mike Ditka made years ago when he traded his whole draft for Ricky Williams

I was a flat out NO

But it is interesting in that if Tua is done, let’s say he walks away, and I wouldn’t blame the kid, but let’s say he does, would you trade all our picks in the next draft to move up and grab a QB in the top 3 picks

First, you college nuts, who is entering the draft next year that you like. Would love to hear about the prospects coming.

Anyway, the reason I bring this question up is because we have Five picks and no 1s this year. Being we are limited is it worth giving them up to grab the new hot commodity?

I say no because I would love a real smart GM (don’t know if we have one) who could do his homework and score with someone in the third round, like Wilson and a few others were found and still have a few picks to work with.

Or do you trade the five picks and gamble the hot prospect turns into a franchise QB

???

Absolutely not. We need linebackers badly. And I don't wanna see just one freaking linebacker come in and the staff say we are good. We need like two or three upgrades. Then CBs and o linemen. We need a TE too but with this offense I think we can get away with an average above average FA for now.

 

[Mach2]

No good qaurterbacks in 2023

So you have done, or even read, an in-depth analysis of 100 collegiate QBs?

Surely you realize that statement reeks of emotional bias?

 

[SF Dolphin Fan]

Miami doesn't have the ammo to trade into the top 10, unless you start including future picks.

But let's say Tua retires. I think the Dolphins could bring in a stopgap guy like Jimmy Garappalo and draft a quarterback in 2024.

Another option might be a quarterback like Trey Lance. With the way Brock Purdy is playing, I could see the 49ers moving Lance.

I don't know if Lance is good enough, but McDaniel should have a pretty good idea.

 

[phinfann13]

See what eagles did. Find a jalen hurts

Sounds simple enough. Find an MVP at QB in the 2nd round. Let’s just do that!