Quinn drops out of top 10! | FinHeaven - Miami Dolphins Forums

Quinn drops out of top 10!

P

phinfreak

☠️ Banned ☠️
Joined
Oct 14, 2005
Messages
963
Reaction score
22
Miami will NOT take Quinn if available at #9 for the following reasons.

1- Not the BPA
2- Mediocre NFL arm (no deep ball)
3- No threat running the ball
4- Cameron / Shea in love with Trent Green
5- Quinn not a starter in year 1 - no immediate impact on this team
6- Too many other players that can start or be in rotation game 1 i.e. Omobi
7- Left Tackle is #1 priority IN THE DRAFT
8- Other free agent QB's available later
9- C-Pep just might get healthy if no Trent Green
10- Miami has other QB rated higher in Draft
 
so let me get this straight you LT is biggst priority and what you think Brown is better at his position than Quinn??? cmon guy your opinion is vague and a bad one at that
 
phinfreak said:
Miami will NOT take Quinn if available at #9 for the following reasons.

1- Not the BPA
2- Mediocre NFL arm (no deep ball)
3- No threat running the ball
4- Cameron / Shea in love with Trent Green
5- Quinn not a starter in year 1 - no immediate impact on this team
6- Too many other players that can start or be in rotation game 1 i.e. Omobi
7- Left Tackle is #1 priority IN THE DRAFT
8- Other free agent QB's available later
9- C-Pep just might get healthy if no Trent Green
10- Miami has other QB rated higher in Draft
Click to expand...

I disagree with all 10, try again
 
no threat running the balll...and we're in love with green??? wow how could i forget how good green was at running the ball in his career...and lets not forget the speedy brees and godfast rivers in san diego....cameron loves those guys and there ability to take it to the house....great point
 
:lol:

Have you been following the draft at all or know anything about the Cam Cameron style of offense?

Well here are a few things to fill you in before I rate this thread one star for lack of research and everything else.

1) You don't need a huge arm to run the Cam Cameron style of offense. Do Phillip Rivers and Drew Brees have huge arms? No they don't. Besides Quinn can get the ball down the field just fine, it just isnt a rocket.

2) You don't need to be a running threat in this offense. Were Drew Brees and Phillip Rivers running QB's? No.

3) Trent Green is not on our roster, and the reason we wanted Green was to groom a young QB. Besides Green is not a fit either by your standards as he isnt a running threat and doesnt have the best deep ball.

4) I'll trade an immediate starter for a guy who will start for ten years after that first season and be a franchise guy.

5) Omobi isn't even a fit on our team so I have no clue what you are talking about there.

6) Left Tackle is a priority but if you have ever heard Houck talk about Alabi you would know he is very confident he can play LT. He has also said if Alabi can't he could always move Shelton or Carey back.

7) You can predict free agents? Wow your good.

8) Culpepper might get healthy? I love C-pep and yes he might but if he does thats even better after having drafted Quinn. I'd rather have two QB than none.

9) Who does Miami have rated higher? Thats a complete made up thing.
 
trate121hb said:
no threat running the balll...and we're in love with green??? wow how could i forget how good green was at running the ball in his career...and lets not forget the speedy brees and godfast rivers in san diego....cameron loves those guys and there ability to take it to the house....great point
Click to expand...

:sidelol:
 
in love with trent green.. hes 37.. not a permanate fix. do like thr res and just let it all happen..
 
phinfreak said:
Miami will NOT take Quinn if available at #9 for the following reasons.

1- Not the BPA
2- Mediocre NFL arm (no deep ball)
3- No threat running the ball
4- Cameron / Shea in love with Trent Green
5- Quinn not a starter in year 1 - no immediate impact on this team
6- Too many other players that can start or be in rotation game 1 i.e. Omobi
7- Left Tackle is #1 priority IN THE DRAFT
8- Other free agent QB's available later
9- C-Pep just might get healthy if no Trent Green
10- Miami has other QB rated higher in Draft
Click to expand...

1) Maybe he won't be or maybe he will be the BPA.
2) yeah right
3) Big deal. Neither was Philip Rivers last year in San Diego with Cam as the OC. Quinn is effective when he does run.
4) They are also in love with Quinn as they have met with him more than any other potential draft pick this year.
5) That where the love for Trent Green comes in. He can be the starter for a year or two while Quinn sits and learns.
6) This is true
7) Left tackle may be a priority but so is QB
8) Like who?
9) C-Pep may never be the same again Especially after he rushed back last year. Who knows what kind of damage he did to himself by doing that.
10) The only QB who may be rated higher is Russell.
 
phinfreak said:
Miami will NOT take Quinn if available at #9 for the following reasons.

1- Not the BPA
2- Mediocre NFL arm (no deep ball)
3- No threat running the ball
4- Cameron / Shea in love with Trent Green
5- Quinn not a starter in year 1 - no immediate impact on this team
6- Too many other players that can start or be in rotation game 1 i.e. Omobi
7- Left Tackle is #1 priority IN THE DRAFT
8- Other free agent QB's available later
9- C-Pep just might get healthy if no Trent Green
10- Miami has other QB rated higher in Draft
Click to expand...

1- you have no idea who will be there when the 9th pick comes up on draft day. Other than that, BPA is a relative term, and you have no clue what Mueller and Cam's big board looks like.

2- he doesn't have a cannon like Russell, but he can make every NFL throw. He is a good fit for the kind of offense Cam runs. Last time I checked, neither Brees or Rivers had huge arms and they both excelled in this offense.

3- He isn't Mike Vick, and he doesn't have to be. He can throw on the run very well, even though he isn't going to win any races. We don't need a QB who can be like an extra RB. We need a competent passer.

4-Cameron/Shea being in love with Green, if anything, points to Quinn being even more of a necessity. Green is old and doesn't have more than a year, two max, of being a starter. He would be excellent to help Quinn get ready to play.

5-You have a point here, but the draft isn't just about this year. It is about the future of the franchise. What is more important? Having a guy who can start day one for a team that likely won't contend anyway, or having a guy who can possibly be the answer for 10 years or more at a position where we have had nothing but jokes since 2000?

6- See 5
7-Left Tackle is priority #1- to you. It is a definite need, but if Mueller/Cam aren't sold on Levi Brown and don't want to take Joe Staley so high (something I highly agree with, if that is how they think), then there is no point in reaching for one just to do it.

8-The other FA QB's who may come available are not likely to be anything of note. It would be more of this franchise spinning their wheels at the position. I have seen enough of that the last 7 years. No more.

9- Culepper may be healthy again at some point. Until then, there is no need to basically put the most important position on the team on the back burner in some holding pattern. It's time to move forward.

10- Again, you have no idea what their big board looks like. Take what you hear in the media with a ginormous grain of salt.

Edit: Damn you all who posted responses while I was typing! lol
 
You guys cant read. Here it is again.

Quinn does not deliver day one impact on game day - period, for any team - there is universal agreement on this.

Miami needs game 1 impact player. In other words, someone who will either start or play in the rotation at his position.

I was not comparing Trent Green running ability to Quinn...read my post again.

Russel can hurt you throwin and runnin, neither of which Quinn can do thus he is not a top ten pick as a QB.
 
A QB has to be able to run to be a top 10 pick now? OOOkay.
 
scrambling qbs are the single most overrated ability in the world. If you don't believe me look up Marino, Manning, Brady, Montana, Brees, Aikman, Moon's career stats. I will take brains over legs any day. And that seems to be Quinn's strong suit.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top Bottom