Quinn or Beck?

[Duriel]

I suppose we will never know the truth, but if Quinn had still been there at 40, would we have taken him or Beck?

Maybe they feel Beck is better, and not just a better value, because they were able to take him in the second.

 

[dlockz]

I suppose we will never know the truth, but if Quinn had still been there at 40, would we have taken him or Beck?

Maybe they feel Beck is better, and not just a better value, because they were able to take him in the second.

The only question to them was Quinn or Guinn, they would have taken Quinn no matter how they spin it.

 

[tay0365]

Here is a comparison of both as I see it....

Leadership: Tie (Both proved to be very good)

Size: Brady (Obviously he is taller and bigger)

Arm Strength: Brady (Not much better, but better)

Release: Beck (Only Edwards is better then Beck from this class)

Mobility: Beck (Beck knows how to move around)

Age: Brady (Beck will be 26)

Accuracy: Beck (He is the most accurate of this class)


As far as I see it after 7 category of what I think are the most important, they both will bring something special to a team. Only Difference is, Beck will not be as expensive to sign, while Brady may last longer in the NFL (maybe 4 years later).