rank the QB's where does CP/GREEN fit in | FinHeaven - Miami Dolphins Forums

rank the QB's where does CP/GREEN fit in

Heres how I ranked them:

1)Peyton Manning
2)Tom Brady
3)Drew Brees
4)Donavan McNabb
5)Carson Palmer
6)Marc Bulger
7)Matt Hastlebeck
8)Jake Delhome
9)Rex Grossman
10)Brett Favre
11)Chad Pennington
12)Steve McNair
13)Big Ben
14)Tony Romo
15)Jeff Garcia
16)Trent Green
17)Philip Rivers
18)Michael Vick
19)Byron Leftwhich
20)Eli Manning
21)Mark Brunell
22)Daunte Culpepper
23)Vince Young
24)Jon Kitna
25)Matt Leinart
26)Alex Smith
27)Matt Schaub
28)JP Losman
29)Jay Cutler
30)Travaris Jackson
31)Jamarcus Russell
32)Charlie Frye
 
feelthepain said:
Heres how I ranked them:

1)Peyton Manning
2)Tom Brady
3)Drew Brees
4)McNabb
5)Carson Palmer
6)Marc Bulger
7)Matt Hastlebeck
8)Jake Delhome
9)Rex Grossman
10)Brett Favre
11)Chad Pennington
12)Steve McNair
13)Big Ben
14)Tony Romo
15)Jeff Garcia
16)Trent Green
17)Philip Rivers
18)Michael Vick
19)Byron Leftwhich
20)Eli Manning
21)Mark Brunell
22)Daunte Culpepper
23)Vince Young
24)Jon Kitna
25)Matt Leinart
26)Alex Smith
27)Matt Schaub
28)JP Losman
29)Jay Cutler
30)Travaris Jackson
31)Jamarcus Russell
32)Charlie Frye
Click to expand...
Aren't you the one that has been saying we should stick with Culpepper and that Green is a waste of time? How come you rank Green ahead of Culpepper if that is true? :confused:
 
Crypt Keeper said:
Aren't you the one that has been saying we should stick with Culpepper and that Green is a waste of time? How come you rank Green ahead of Culpepper if that is true? :confused:
Click to expand...

Because we don't know if Culpepper will return and because Culpepper has missed more time then Green the last two seasons. Just because I want Daunte to be given a chance doesn't mean it's fair to grade hm higher at this point in time. The ranking is based on today, not the future.
 
Crypt Keeper said:
Aren't you the one that has been saying we should stick with Culpepper and that Green is a waste of time? How come you rank Green ahead of Culpepper if that is true? :confused:
Click to expand...

And maybe because Green only has maybe one or two more years MAX. If culpepper gets back to form he could have a lot more years a head of him. And before you bring up beck. I have all the hope and confidence in beck but you cant put all your eggs into that basket. and with green that is what we are doing.
 
No way Trent Green should be ahead of Philip Rivers as far as overall career, yes. But this season? Heck no. I'd put Vince Young over him too
 
ac_lanham said:
No way Trent Green should be ahead of Philip Rivers as far as overall career, yes. But this season? Heck no. I'd put Vince Young over him too
Click to expand...

I gave the nod to Green because of his experience. If Green and Rivers were to be in the playoffs at this moment, I'd take Green over Rivers.
 
dude these rankings suck sorry but rex grossman in the top 10 for the sake of humanity if green is healthy he is top 10 but DC could be top 5 if healthy to but thats the thing he isnt.
 
also the stats prove green is a great starter he was hurt for what 9 games last year or more and he would of thrown for almost 3,500+ yards if healthy
 
I ranked them:

1)Peyton Manning IND
1a/2)Tom Brady NE
3)Carson Palmer CIN
4)Drew Brees NO
5)Donavan McNabb PHI
6)Matt Hasselbeck SEA
7)Marc Bulger STL
8)Brett Farve GB
9)Jake Delhome CAR
10)Steve McNair BAL
11)Chad Pennington NYJ
12)Trent Green KC
13)Michael Vick ATL
14)Tony Romo DAL
15)Philip Rivers SD
16)Vince Young TEN
17)Big Ben PIT
18)Matt Leinhart ARI
19)Jeff Garcia TB
20)Eli Manning NYG
21)RexGrossman CHI
22)Dante Culpepper MIA (If healthy probably top 11)
23)Alex Smith SF
24)Jon Kitna DET
25)Byron Leftwich JAC
26)Jay Cutler DEN
27)JP Losman BUF
28)Matt Schaub HOU
29)Charlie Frye CLE (Probably will start season)
30)Jason Campbell WAS
31)Travaris Jackson MINN
32)Josh McCown OAK (Probabaly will start season)
 
feelthepain said:
Because we don't know if Culpepper will return and because Culpepper has missed more time then Green the last two seasons. Just because I want Daunte to be given a chance doesn't mean it's fair to grade hm higher at this point in time. The ranking is based on today, not the future.
Click to expand...

This is by far my favorite post of the entire weekend!

We are on the same side my friend. Good to see you now understand!
 
zach8111 said:
I ranked them:

1)Peyton Manning IND
1a/2)Tom Brady NE
3)Carson Palmer CIN
4)Drew Brees NO
5)Donavan McNabb PHI
6)Matt Hasselbeck SEA
7)Marc Bulger STL
8)Brett Farve GB- down to about 20-past doesnt count
9)Jake Delhome CAR
10)Steve McNair BAL
11)Chad Pennington NYJ
12)Trent Green KC
13)Michael Vick ATL
14)Tony Romo DAL
15)Philip Rivers - up to about 10
16)Vince Young TEN- about 12
17)Big Ben PIT
18)Matt Leinhart ARI-will be top 10 by years end
19)Jeff Garcia TB
20)Eli Manning NYG
21)RexGrossman CHI
22)Dante Culpepper MIA (If healthy probably top 11)
23)Alex Smith SF- more like #15
24)Jon Kitna DET
25)Byron Leftwich JAC
26)Jay Cutler DEN -also will be in and near #10 by seasons end
27)JP Losman BUF
28)Matt Schaub HOU- more like 20
29)Charlie Frye CLE (Probably will start season)-bottom 4 are perfect:sidelol:
30)Jason Campbell WAS
31)Travaris Jackson MINN
32)Josh McCown OAK (Probabaly will start season)
Click to expand...

eli and rex grossman i see falling :shakeno:
 
you guys are ranking him high considering croyle or huard are gonna start if he's no a fin.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top Bottom