Ranking the top 10 teams of the Super Bowl era: '78 Steelers, '72 Dolphins battle for top spot | FinHeaven - Miami Dolphins Forums

Ranking the top 10 teams of the Super Bowl era: '78 Steelers, '72 Dolphins battle for top spot

Dolph N.Fan

Active Roster
Joined
Sep 11, 2010
Messages
35,174
Reaction score
38,921
Location
Columbus, OH

2. 1972 Miami Dolphins

  • 17-0 overall record (including playoffs)
  • Featured the league's top-ranked offense and defense
  • Shut out Washington's offense in Super Bowl VII
Nearly 50 years later, the '72 Dolphins remain the NFL's only perfect team. They featured a dominant "No Name" defense (led by Nick Buoniconti, Manny Fernandez and Super Bowl MVP Jake Scott) that allowed 17 points or less 14 times. Miami's offense boasted the first pair of teammates to each run for over 1,000 yards in a season in Larry Csonka and Mercury Morris. When the Dolphins did throw, Miami fans were treated to the balletic play of Hall of Fame receiver Paul Warfield.

Hungry to avenge their 24-3 loss to the Cowboys in Super Bowl VI, Don Shula's team did not lose a single game en route to defeating the Browns and Steelers (on the road, no less) in the playoffs before out-playing Washington in Super Bowl VII. Miami would have recorded the only shutout in Super Bowl history if not for one of the most iconic blunders in NFL history. The Dolphins can continue to take pride in being the NFL's only unblemished team, but the fact that they faced just one team (an 8-6 Chiefs team) that finished with a winning record during the regular-season left them one spot off the top of this list.

I'm surprised that Miami team is ranked so high mainly because the haters always point to how "soft' miami's schedule was that year. But then again this is CBS and not ESPN.
 
Let’s be honest, an average NFL team now would crush the best NFL teams back in the day. Players are bigger, stronger, smarter, and faster. There’s no comparison. In context you gotta give the undefeated team all the credit in the world, but todays Chiefs or Bucs would destroy them.
 


I'm surprised that Miami team is ranked so high mainly because the haters always point to how "soft' miami's schedule was that year. But then again this is CBS and not ESPN.
I counter those soft schedule arguments with the fact that we had to navigate a good portion of the schedule without our All Pro Quarterback, along with the bizarre fact an undefeated team had to go on the road to win the AFC Championship. I would also argue that in spite of a pair of losses, 1973 was a more dominant team…they were awesome. They should be in the discussion…
 
I counter those soft schedule arguments with the fact that we had to navigate a good portion of the schedule without our All Pro Quarterback, along with the bizarre fact an undefeated team had to go on the road to win the AFC Championship. I would also argue that in spite of a pair of losses, 1973 was a more dominant team…they were awesome. They should be in the discussion…
I don’t think a lot of people realizes this
 
Let’s be honest, an average NFL team now would crush the best NFL teams back in the day. Players are bigger, stronger, smarter, and faster. There’s no comparison. In context you gotta give the undefeated team all the credit in the world, but todays Chiefs or Bucs would destroy them.
I agree with your premise of superior athletes, training, equipment etc. would create mismatches now versus then, but the 1972 Dolphins were undefeated versus their peers of the same era….no team has replicated that….so they deserve to be in the discussion of greatest all time teams. Lastly, incredible talent supersedes athletic superiority…Joe DiMaggio, Jim Brown, Jack Nicklaus, Nolan Ryan and even Michael Jordan. They performed at an incredibly high level in spite of inferior equipment, lack of advanced training techniques, etc.
 
I'm a little surprised Miami got recognition. Usually the media seems to overlook the 72'-73' teams in spite of their dominance.
The media gets a subtle reminder and begrudgingly must acknowledge another NFL season comes and goes without another undefeated team in the Super Bowl era….I smile every time it occurs… : )
 
The media gets a subtle reminder and begrudgingly must acknowledge another NFL season comes and goes without another undefeated team in the Super Bowl era….I smile every time it occurs… : )
I know a lot of people hate that players like Mercury Morris always celebrate the last team to lose a game every season lol loved on Primetime how they always “popped the champagne” after the last undefeated team lost
 
Let’s be honest, an average NFL team now would crush the best NFL teams back in the day. Players are bigger, stronger, smarter, and faster. There’s no comparison. In context you gotta give the undefeated team all the credit in the world, but todays Chiefs or Bucs would destroy them.
I still believe the 70's team...... any team of the 70's is tougher than what we have today. The played with injuries that none of the player would step on the field for. Don't know if it was because they needed the money, enjoyed the game more or were just too stupid to sit down, but I think alot of those guys could lay out our players of today. That being said, I love the offenses of today, but love the defenses of 70's.
 
I still believe the 70's team...... any team of the 70's is tougher than what we have today. The played with injuries that none of the player would step on the field for. Don't know if it was because they needed the money, enjoyed the game more or were just too stupid to sit down, but I think alot of those guys could lay out our players of today. That being said, I love the offenses of today, but love the defenses of 70's.
No. Just no. It would absolutely be no contest. Tyreke Hill could run backwards against those teams. Chase Young would be unstoppable. They would look at Pat Mahomes like he was an alien. No contest whatsoever.
 
Give me the 72 Dolphins over any pansy *** team today.
Players today are 50-100 pounds heavier, twice as fast, way stronger, and way smarter. The ‘72 Dolphins probably couldn’t beat the worst team in the nfl right now.it’s not even appropriate to compare teams from 50 years ago to now. YA Tittle couldn’t hold Marino’s jockstrap.
 
Last edited:
Players today are 50-100 pounds heavier, twice as fast, way stronger, and way smarter. The ‘72 Dolphins probably couldn’t beat the worst team in the nfl right now.it’s not even appropriate to compare teams from 50 years ago to now. YA Tittle couldn’t hold Marino’s jockstrap.
Larry Csonka's mustache alone would dominate a defense today.

Today's athlete = LeBron James.

Defense rests.
 
Larry Csonka's mustache alone would dominate a defense today.

Today's athlete = LeBron James.

Defense rests.
I can’t stand Lebron, but he would absolutely dominate the NBA 50 years ago.
 
Back
Top Bottom