Reid/Fisher and their fan base | FinHeaven - Miami Dolphins Forums

Reid/Fisher and their fan base

FinsBR

FinsBR

Dolfan from São Paulo - Brazil
Joined
Aug 3, 2011
Messages
541
Reaction score
1
Location
São Paulo - Brazil
We already heard here about Reid and Fisher from people who live in Philly and Houston, Can you guys please elaborate more?

How about people from the Dallas and NY area about Ryan and young Schotty?

What we hear in syndicated radios and their analysis is different from the feeling of their fan base...
 
I live in Eagles land here in southern nj.......everyone HATES HATES HATESSSSS Andy Reid & think he is a terrible coach. They have been calling for his head for at least the last 5 years.
 
I bet the Jets would love for us to take Schottenhiemer, lol. They've wanted him gone for a while now.
 
Living in Delaware I will second that everyone hates Reid around here. Also seeing so many Eagles game I will say that Reid is the worst coach ever with clock management. I do think he will leave this year if things don't turn around.
 
They complain about Shotty every day up here in New York. I wouldn't mind old Shotty though. He should still be coaching the Chargers.
 
NewCoachPlease said:
Living in Delaware I will second that everyone hates Reid around here. Also seeing so many Eagles game I will say that Reid is the worst coach ever with clock management. I do think he will leave this year if things don't turn around.
Click to expand...

Couldn't have said it better myself.
 
What possess anyone to think young Schottenhiemer is even remotely someone you would want running the show at that fins is beyond me.
 
Reid is an unbelievably great QB coach and a terrible everything else.
 
Rob Ryan is already starting to grate on the Dallas fans here.

That guy can not say a simple sentence without injecting very colorful words, none of which you would want your kids to hear.

He is abrasive, loud, extremely vulgar and even more conceited than his smaller brother.

On top of that, other than his apparent DC knowledge, he really isnt a very smart guy
 
The Confessor said:
I'd say he is top 5 talent evaluation. Easily top 5. Maybe top 4 behind the FO's of Pits, GB and NE.
Click to expand...

He gave Michael Vick 100 million dollars. What do we know about Michael Vick:

- Admitted he hates watching film.
- Was always a lazy / no effort guy.
- Has never stayed healthy an entire season and gets hit a lot.
- Had a 4-5 game hot streak but then cooled off considerably at the end of the year.


There's a reason the wheels are coming off in Philadelphia despite having a roster stacked with talented FAs.
 
The Confessor said:
I'd say he is top 5 talent evaluation. Easily top 5. Maybe top 4 behind the FO's of Pits, GB and NE.
Click to expand...

No, not really...he has some hits but some epic fails as well, examples Freddie Mitchell (1st Round), Jerome McDougal (1st Round), he loves to trade back an accumulate draft picks. The Eagles are well run from a cap stand point but that has little to do with Reid. Honestly you want to look at how to build via the draft look at the Lions the last few years with Millen gone.
 
The Confessor said:
Rob Ryan is already starting to grate on the Dallas fans here.

That guy can not say a simple sentence without injecting very colorful words, none of which you would want your kids to hear.

He is abrasive, loud, extremely vulgar and even more conceited than his smaller brother.

On top of that, other than his apparent DC knowledge, he really isnt a very smart guy
Click to expand...

Yeah I don't want Rob Ryan coaching in Miami.
 
registeredguy said:
He gave Michael Vick 100 million dollars. What do we know about Michael Vick:

- Admitted he hates watching film.
- Was always a lazy / no effort guy.
- Has never stayed healthy an entire season and gets hit a lot.
- Had a 4-5 game hot streak but then cooled off considerably at the end of the year.


There's a reason the wheels are coming off in Philadelphia despite having a roster stacked with talented FAs.
Click to expand...

This time last year, Vick, after his obvious absence, was the top rated QB in the league.
He worked his *** off last year to get back to where he was
Watches TONS of film.

How many people in here were talking about how we should trade whichever pick to get him?
I don't like Vick either, but to completely discount what Reid did is assinine, and he absolutely RAPED Arizona in the Kolb trade. He got a pro-bowl calibur CB AND a 2nd round pick (Looks like it will be a very high 2nd) for a QB that looked good cause he was surrounded by the incredible talent that Reid had surrounded him with....which, of course, is also alot of what made Vick look so good so quickly last year.
 
Amish Pirate said:
No, not really...he has some hits but some epic fails as well, examples Freddie Mitchell (1st Round), Jerome McDougal (1st Round), he loves to trade back an accumulate draft picks. The Eagles are well run from a cap stand point but that has little to do with Reid. Honestly you want to look at how to build via the draft look at the Lions the last few years with Millen gone.
Click to expand...


Uhmmmmm. The Lions?
If you pick within the top 5 for two decades, top pick overall for 1/2 of those, you are eventually going to turn up some diamonds. I would NEVER want to endure what Lion fans have had to endure. NOT a good model for how to draft...at all.


Sure you can cherry pick a few failures. Guess what, Every team, every single one, blows some picks, some very high profile picks. Pissburgh has, NE has, Green Bay has etc etc etc.

The fact that Reid has kept his team competitive each and every year as long has he has is a true testament of his talent evaluation. I will crunch some numbers and see what his win% is since he has been there. I am willing to bet it is top 5 during his tenure. Anybody wanna wager on that?

As a dramatic comparison, Ronnie Brown is not playing very much for that offense. He is 2nd RB on the Roster, but barely. Word is that Dion Lewis is seeing more time with the 2nd unit than Ronnie. How does that contrast to the Dolphins and our talent pool??????
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top Bottom