Remember the Ronnie vs. Cadillac Argument

[FinHopeful]

Do you remember all the posters on this board that moaned about taking Ronnie over Cacillac? Given those posts, I think the following stats are humorous.

Rushing
RNK NAME ATT YDS AVG YPG LNG TD FUM LST
12 Ronnie Brown RB, MIA 176 710 4.0 78.9 27 5 3 2
28 C. Williams RB, TAM 139 497 3.6 55.2 38 1 1 1

Receiving
REC YDS AVG LNG TD
Ronnie Brown RB, MIA 28 246 8.8 24 0
C. Williams RB, TAM 21 115 5.5 14 0

 

[23brown]

very nice

 

[bigmiamifan]

But no, screw your solid facts and concrete stats, Ronnie is a bust and Caddy should have been our pick! (speaking for the irrational)

 

[ckparrothead]

Doesn't it kind of remind you of when Anthony Thomas beat LaDainian Tomlinson for Rookie of the Year?

LOL.

I really, really, REALLY hope Cadillac's career goes better than Anthony Thomas' career does. That would suck for him and he's a player I really like.

 

[Rixon]

thats why NFL coaches and Talent scouts get paid for this and we dont

 

[Roman529]

I think Chuckie Gruden overused him his first year and the Caddie got beat up and turned into a Olds 88.

Ronnie is the real deal and will only get better. I love that he can catch the ball out of the backfield...now he just has to work on those left handed throws into the end zone. :wink:

 

[SHEDDAWG DOLFAN]

thats why NFL coaches and Talent scouts get paid for this and we dont

Amen

 

[Gardenhead]

I am one of the biggest Ronnie Brown homers on Finheaven.

That being said, Cadillac's offensive line sucks worse than Ronnie's. Do I think Ronnie is better? Of course. But Caddy is a stud as well.

 

[Silverphin]

But no, screw your solid facts and concrete stats, Ronnie is a bust and Caddy should have been our pick! (speaking for the irrational)

:sidelol:

 

[Majpain]

But no, screw your solid facts and concrete stats, Ronnie is a bust and Caddy should have been our pick! (speaking for the irrational)

I hope that was a joke.

 

[PerfectFinz72]

thats why NFL coaches and Talent scouts get paid for this and we dont

I dont think it could have been put any better than the way you put it. Its cool for fans to have opinions, but sometimes I swear it gets out of hand. Let the coaches coach, and we'll do what fans do....cheer.

 

[FEARDAFINS]

Do you remember all the posters on this board that moaned about taking Ronnie over Cacillac?

NO.

 

[Mike13]

Ronnie is the man. Caddy will be a stud too.

 

[Dolfan984]

NO.

That draft was in April 2005. You joined in August 2005, of course you wouldn't remember.

 

[Ronnie Brown 23]

I'm glad this debate is put the rest. Cadillac is having a horrible year