I think Reggie is a phenominal athlete but very over-rated as a college back who doesnt get the full-load of carries. Reggie's size is very disturbing. He weighs 200lbs soak'n wet and just does not have the prototypical frame for a runningback(which isnt always a bad thing). Reggie will suffer injuries in the NFL like every back, and while he hasnt bitten the injury bug in college, the NFL is a complete different story. The speed of the game is night and day different compared to the NCAA, not to even mention the size and strength difference.
For OUR TEAM, I would take Ronnie Brown. I feel Ronnie offers us more of a complete package by a large margin and fits our team better. Just my 2 cents.