Ronnie vs. Ricky

[SoFloDolFan]

Which running back do you think is better as of now despite Ronnie missing most of training camp?

 

[nick1]

Brown, he has more talent

 

[elandre]

i have no idea

lets see ronnie play a couple games and ill get back to u on that one.

For now i would have to stick with my boy ricky i mean come on this guy is just plane gifted .

 

[FuturePhin]

Ricky. He's got power and moves.

 

[nando03]

Brown, he has more talent

You honestly think Brown has more talent then a guy who put up 3200+ yards in his last 2 seasons? I'm not by any means saying that Brown is bad. I'm still not sold on Ricky, but you can't argue the numbers in this situation. What has Brown proven to you so far? He hasn't proven anything to me yet. Sorry. But if I had pick one based on talent alone it would have to be Ricky hands down. Keep in mind the question was talent not total package.

 

[nick1]

Ricky. He's got power and moves.

how do you know? from last week we sure saw that he had moves by juking some defenders on the same play but you don't know about the power, he hasn't shown power lately and he's still down 10 pounds from last year so how do we know he has power?

 

[Scrap]

Ricky, until Ronnie proves otherwise.

 

[nick1]

You honestly think Brown has more talent then a guy who put up 3200+ yards in his last 2 seasons? I'm not by any means saying that Brown is bad. I'm still not sold on Ricky, but you can't argue the numbers in this situation. What has Brown proven to you so far? He hasn't proven anything to me yet. Sorry. But if I had pick one based on talent alone it would have to be Ricky hands down. Keep in mind the question was talent not total package.

yes I do just compare all aspects of the game

Brown has the speed edge
Williams has the agility/moves edge
Williams has the power edge
Brown has the receiver/catching edge
Brown has the blocking edge

thats Brown 3-2

anything else?

 

[RoninFin4]

yes I do just compare all aspects of the game

Brown has the speed edge
Williams has the agility/moves edge
Williams has the power edge
Brown has the receiver/catching edge
Brown has the blocking edge

thats Brown 3-2

anything else?

Do you factor in the experience advantage that Williams has?

 

[Olbruck]

yes I do just compare all aspects of the game

Brown has the speed edge
Williams has the agility/moves edge
Williams has the power edge
Brown has the receiver/catching edge
Brown has the blocking edge

thats Brown 3-2

anything else?

Brown hasnt competed at the NFL level yet....So you dont know nothing yet...for all we know, he could be the next Kijana Carter.

 

[nando03]

yes I do just compare all aspects of the game

Brown has the speed edge
Williams has the agility/moves edge
Williams has the power edge
Brown has the receiver/catching edge
Brown has the blocking edge

thats Brown 3-2

anything else?

What about vision and experience? I would give both of those aspects to Ricky considering Brown has never been a starter. Lets be real here. Brown hasn't proven anything. Ricky as a talent is top 3 in the NFL. The only person I think is better is Tomlinson in SD. As a talent. Brown doesn't rank anything in the NFL. Your argument is weak.

 

[alx]

I say Ricky only because Ronnie hasn't played in NFL Speed

 

[ASCII]

does anyone really care? the both are dolphins so why not compare the dolphins backfield to say the chiefs?

 

[Doktor Ivel]

Brown, because of ricks 4 game suspension

 

[nando03]

I'm glad I'm not the only one that thinks we need to see Brown play before we start comparing his talent to any proven back's talent in the NFL.