Rookie of the year | FinHeaven - Miami Dolphins Forums

Rookie of the year

P

phins3454

☠️ Banned ☠️
Joined
Nov 15, 2006
Messages
377
Reaction score
0
a lot of good offence rookies this year...who deserves rookie of the year?

I would say Marquies Colston WR for the Saints should get it

but then you have Jones Drew for the Jags

Vince Young has really helped the Titans since hes been the starter

DeAngelo Williams has been productive when given the chance

Joseph Addi has been productive

Laurence Maroney has been productive

Devin hester is the best return man in the NFL

Reggie Bush has really stepped it up


all of them are great rookies
 
This was a strong draft class indeed.

Manny Lawson looked great at the beggining of the season, recording 5 sacks in his first 3-4 games. But he kind of slipped. If he continued the pace, he would have been in these talks as well.
 
Oh I just remembered Leon Washington RB for the jets isnt too shaby either for a rookie
 
culpepper2chambers said:
you forgot the real rookie of the year

marcus mcneal

he wont win it though
Click to expand...

dude is freakin amazing!
 
young will get it because he is a QB, and the reason they have been winning games lately.

i say it stacks up like this:

1) Young
2) Bush
3) Colston
4) Jones-Drew
5) Addi
6) Hester
7) Maroney
8) whats all this about an o-lineman?? just wont happen.
 
I agree young is in the driver's seat and is an automatic win if the Titans go 9-7 and somehow sneak into the Playoffs. But behind him I have Colston and Jones-Drew really tightly together. I think Bush is in the middle of the pack, he's been playing well even if his stats don't show as much as the hype would let you to believe.
 
I think it should go(at least this is how I would vote)

1) Colston
2) Young
3) Demeco Ryans
4) Marcus McNeill
5) Jones-Drew
6) Reggie Bush
7) Devin Hester
8) Addai
9) Alex Brown
10) Mangold
 
yeah I think Colston should get it, hes putting up better numbers than our best WR...better than a lot of good veteran WR's
 
Stitches said:
I think it should go(at least this is how I would vote)

1) Colston
2) Young
3) Demeco Ryans
4) Marcus McNeill
5) Jones-Drew
6) Reggie Bush
7) Devin Hester
8) Addai
9) Alex Brown
10) Mangold
Click to expand...

I speak with rose colored glasses off....but there is NO ONE on that list that I would rather have than Marcus McNeill well besides him at 4 of course:)

He is ridiculously good....I just pray the back holds up
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top Bottom