Originally posted by rickeyrunsover
Ok in simple terms you are one of those peopl that see things in black and white only and cannot see the grey or you refuse to consider any scenario or fact or versions that dont support your argument. In other words you have the "I have to be right at all costs because i have labeled myself genious because my thoughts seems so logical to me everybody has to agree with me" syndrome.
Simply put writers and fans in Philli will tell you Feeley is listed as teh #3 qb because Koy was the holder for Akers. Now Nfl rules say the 3 rd qb or emergency qb cannot be on the field or teh #1 and 2 cannot return, so if Koy would have been listed as the #3 he would not been able to hold for akers. Therefore, in order to facilitate Koy holding and since they could start Feeley the following week if McNabb was hurt, they list Koy as #2 so he can hold.
Now before you go say "gee i didnt need you to tell me that" You either did or you dont want to acknowledge this as this was the crux of my last post but you do not want to address this because then at a very minimum, puts a crack in your argument.
Herein lies the diff, with all that, you may be right that we gave up too much, I admit that I do not know whether this will work out or not. He may turn out great and then a #2 is fine. You can and some have they dont believe the above statement, which is fine, your opinion. But to ignore the above completely and just state the black and white is a deceptive trick to make your argument seem infoulable, which it is not. Nor is mine nor anyone elses, they are all opinions weighted equally.
