I'm going to go ahead and say that Joe Horn and Donte Stallworth or as good if not a little better than Chambers and Booker. Booker is just a a few years out of having had three 1000 yard seasons and a 100 reception year and Chambers had a phenomenal year last year, but Joe Horn at his best is a top flight receiver and Stallworth definitely has great ability. I'd definitely call it a push. Here's my problem with both sets. Chambers still drops too many passes, when he's on he's a game changer and I think he'll be one of the best in the league, but he's not consistent enough. On the other side, the Saints had inflated numbers last year and actually usually both years. They're a bad team, they play from behind a lot. When you play from behind you throw the ball more. Of course Stallworth had good stats. It's a push.
Hakim vs. Welker/Campbell (I don't know what his status is, I thought we had a deal with him but I've heard nothing since) is also pretty close. They're both return guys who can play some wideout. Hakim drops a lot of balls and I think Welker and Campbell are better receivers. I'd say there's a slight edge to Miami.
Deuce vs. Ricky/Ronny- If Ricky comes back this isn't even close. Hands down Ricky Williams is a better back than Deuce. When both are at their best Ricky is probably top three in the league and Deuce, while top tier, isn't close. If Ricky does indeed miss the year then it gets interesting. Remember Deuce tore up his knee last year, so he's not going to be full strength. I don't know what Ronnie can do but I do know thath he's healthy. It usually takes a back two years to come back from an injury like Deuce had, edge Miami.
Lines- Miami. No question.
Coaches- Miami.
Location- Miami.
