Muck,
IMHO, Mods need to make sure this place runs smoothly, which means among other things:
1) No trolling, insulting, etc
2) No repetitive posts (merging, etc)
3) No board cluttering (users cant find relevent information because some threads are off topic)
IMO, the first two points have been dealt with in a professional, responsible manner. However, the Mods need to review their stance on the third point. Now that we are in the offseason, discussions about the draft/free agency are COMPLETELY relevant to the Dolphins, regardless of the actual wording of the TOS. Still, these posts continue to get moved. Go take a look at the college draft forum, or the Free Agency forum, or the Salary Cap forum. You will find plenty of threads that contain interesting, RELEVANT football discussion (which is either directly or indirectly related to the Phins) that have been moved. Its a shame, really.
As for the Pay content, I hear you but disagree how little (or how much) info can/should be posted. In CK's case, he cited 4-5 player bios from Scouts INC (out of more than 360 available bios). Even Amazon.com allows surfers to view 10-12 pages of a book without purchasing it.
And the ironic thing is that board veterans like CK honor the TOS anyway.
Again, not trying to dog you guys (and definitely not you personally). Maybe youre right, the TOS need to be revised - or at the very least, the way that they are interpreted by Mods (and posters) needs to be reconsidered.
I consider myself a honest guy that abides by and respects the rules. I'll play by whatever rules the Mods set up. I just feel you should think twice about which rules need to be enforced with an iron fist, and which rules call for a more liberal interpretation of the rules, in order to honor the intent of the TOS.