Scouting Report from ESPN on Roth & Pic. One BAD Dude. | FinHeaven - Miami Dolphins Forums

Scouting Report from ESPN on Roth & Pic. One BAD Dude.

Da 'Fins

FinHeaven VIP
Club Member
Joined
Apr 29, 2003
Messages
3,282
Reaction score
686
Strengths: Better athlete than most think. Has good closing burst to the quarterback and ball carrier. Is a powerful tackler that will wrap up in space. Has excellent instincts and run/pass recognition. Does a very good job of reading his keys and finding the ball. Is disciplined and will keep his run-leverage. Has adequate size. Does a solid job of getting underneath OL pads and shows excellent power at the POA. Is a feisty run defender that will never give up on a play. Will find the ball quickly, shows great pursuit skills, and is a powerful tackler. Hands are outstanding. Has outstanding anticipation skills and good initial quickness. Comes out of his stance quickly and with good leverage. He is a quicker than fast pass rusher with a relentless motor. Is at his best using power moves as a pass rusher. Has good COD skills and shows the ability to use double moves to get back inside.

Weaknesses: He lacks ideal size and base. Can be very effective when on the move but bigger OT's in the NFL will be able to engulf him if they can get their hands on him. Lack of ideal top end speed is a concern. Might have a much more difficult time bending the corner in the NFL. Only time he has trouble in terms of his run/pass recognition is when he becomes over-aggressive and plays out of control. Temper has gotten him into some trouble during his career.

Overall: Roth began his career at linebacker but moved to defensive end as a sophomore in 2002 and was a fulltime starter from that point on. Roth developed into one of the top playmaking defensive linemen in the country as a junior in 2003, when he finished with 51 total tackles, 16 for loss and 12 sacks. He had another 49 tackles, 15 TFL and eight sacks as a senior in 2004. Despite facing constant double teams as a senior in 2004, Roth's production did not dip. Roth is a tenacious player with adequate size, good strength and an outstanding motor. He is tough and active versus the run, and he has excellent instincts and closing quickness as a pass rusher. Roth's lack of top-end speed and his occasional loss of temper could cause him to slip more than some think on draft day. However, Roth still grades out as one of the top-five DE's in the 2005 class and should wind up coming off the board late in the first round.
clear.gif
 
In another thread, it was mentioned that we don't need anymore DEs. While this is true - for this year - is it possible that Saban drafted Roth with the intention of possibly moving him back to LB?
 
Kiper just praised him so high on the draft show. It only took them 30 minutes to do their analysis thing but it was good.

He said defensively he was the best player at the Senior Bowl. Kiper said he is just as good as David Pollack and he had him labled as a late first round pick.

Also he said this guy can play up or down. Great for the 3-4/4-3 hybrid I would think.
 
could be a good pass rushing linebacker in the 3-4
 
Strengths

Matt has good size, speed and athletic talent for his position. He has a good burst off the line of scrimmage and uses good technique to free himself for sacks against his opponent. He makes offensive coaches account for him on every play in their game plans. Matt plays every play and every down with the same passion that you and I have for the game. It is a passion born from competition and wanting to be the best. Needs to Improve

Matt needs to learn how to be stronger at the point of attack. I have no doubt that he will. Bottom LineMatt is just going to be a core player and a fan favorite for the team that drafts him. He can be used in a 4-3 scheme or a 3-4 scheme. He can rush the passer or fall off the line of scrimmage to allow others to rush. Matt has some linebacker skills to go along with his DE skills. I think some teams that should be drooling to get Matt should be the Patriots, the Steelers and the Dolphins, among many others. Matt is relentless and seems like he plays a little out of control, but the scouts that say that are playing games with you. I call him Matt ‘Psycho’ Roth because everybody says this kid is a little nuts. I think he is just smart enough to let you think that about him.
 
Temper has gotten him into some trouble during his career.

Thats my favorite part his bio, and yet it was in the negatives. :lol:
 
I read somwhere that he lets his emotions get the best of him. I kinda like that. We need some intesity and little reckless abandonment.
 
I agree on his intensity. I watched him in the bowl game and the all-star game. He was pretty awesome.

He's going to be a great player for us.
 
There are a couple other guys on our D that lack "ideal size." Meh. Another Zach Thomas I'll take.
 
you say that now til it costs Miami a penalty on a 3rd and 15.
 
I think Roth will be a linebacker regardless of whatever system we run. The guy is pretty good. Saban knows what he is doing and what he is looking for. I can't wait until our next pick. So far so good, I think?
 
I like everythng I've read about him. The guy sounds like a nutcase. I love those kind of guys. Him and Bua might kill each other.
 
Matt Roth seems like he is going after the quarterback and then after he slams him into the ground he is going after the quarterbacks family to finish the job.
 
I am ready to order a ROTH jersey...looks like a big Zach. :wink:
 
Back
Top Bottom