Seriously consider this! | FinHeaven - Miami Dolphins Forums

Seriously consider this!

normaniii

Active Roster
Joined
Jul 30, 2008
Messages
2,372
Reaction score
47
Location
wales and will die a prou
With no rookies or Free Agent signings our depth chart after losing Sparano and going into 2012 season looked liked this :-

QB - Matt Moore
RB - Reggie Bush
FB - Charles Clay
WR - Brandon Marshall, Brian Hartline, Devone Bess
TE - Anthony Fasano
OL - Jake Long, Richie Incognito, Mike Pouncey, John Jerry, Nate Garner

DL - Starks, Soliai, Odrick, McDaniel
OLB - Cameron Wake, Koa Misi
MLB - Karlos Dansby, Kevin Burnett
CB - Sean Smith, Vernon Davis, Nolan Carroll, Jimmy Wilson
S - Chris Clemons, Reshad Jones

When you consider again this depth chart is without any offseason additions. We had a power running offensive line and a press 3-4 D in place. Rumour has it there was a disagreement between owner Stephen Ross who wanted Joe Philbin to become HC and GM Jeff Ireland who wanted Mike McCoy.

This is where I feel we made a massive error which has put us back years.

Mike McCoy worked wonders in Denver, creating a run heavy attack even with Tim Tebow at QB. After becoming HC in San Diego, they have one of the heaviest O'lines in NFL and Ryan Matthews has rushed for the most yards in his career. They drafted a WR in Keenan Allen who is more comparable to Brandon Marshall than Mike Wallace.

He has a 3-4 DC in John Pagano, who has similar traits to his brother Chuck where Vontae Davis has finally started to flourish.

We hired Joe Philbin, who wanted a WCO, with a ZBS and hired Kevin Coyle a 4-3 DC who prefers zone, off man coverage. This created square pegs in round holes and an inevitable roster turnover.

Just consider if we had hired Mike McCoy. Again the above roster is without any and I repeat not one FA signing or draft pick. When you consider that San Diego chargers recently drafted DJ Fluker, Manti Teo & Keenan Allen, all players who would have fitted with what we had.

I was surprised how loaded this roster was. I was one of those wanting Jeff Ireland out, but if rumour has it and he had hired his own man, we would IMO have been far more successful than we currently are.
 
I see where you are coming from on this. But...Mike McCoy hasn't won anymore Super Bowls than Joe Philbin. The Roster was not "Loaded". We had one Pro Bowl starter in that group (Long) and two back-ups (Marshall and Solia). Problem with this team is not coaching, it's talent. The roster has not improved since then, or many years before that. We just have not had enough talent on this team to contend.
 
Water under a bridge. Who cares at this point? We have we have and must build on it from here
 
I see where you are coming from on this. But...Mike McCoy hasn't won anymore Super Bowls than Joe Philbin. The Roster was not "Loaded". We had one Pro Bowl starter in that group (Long) and two back-ups (Marshall and Solia). Problem with this team is not coaching, it's talent. The roster has not improved since then, or many years before that. We just have not had enough talent on this team to contend.

I see where your coming from, but I do in parts disagree. IMO Sparano and his coaching staff had a lot to do with many players not hitting Pro Bowl form. I believe that Long, Marshall, Soliai, Wake, Starks, Odrick, Reggie Bush, Ritchie Incognito, Karlos Dansby, Vernon Davis and even Reshad Jones, at times have all shown Pro Bowl potential.
 
But, we must always look at what could've been! :boohoo:

I wish people would stop looking at the past and look to the future.
 
Jesus that is depressing.

That team + Ryan Tannehill > This team with Ryan Tannehill
 
If I had only picked different #s for the mega million just think. I hate these stupid post. What ifs are for losers.
 
I just wanted to point one small thing out real quick...When did we have Vernon Davis at CB? That may have been a serious problem...having a TE play CB for us Lol
 
If I had only picked different #s for the mega million just think. I hate these stupid post. What ifs are for losers.

When you haven't won a playoff game in over a decade all you have left are what ifs.
 
Back
Top Bottom