Shaw or Vickerson? | Page 3 | FinHeaven - Miami Dolphins Forums

Shaw or Vickerson?

I don't want to choose and you can't make me :tongue:

Seriously, Shaw looks great now, but Vickerson would be my choice. This is because I feel that cutting the future for the sake of winning now isn't a good choice at this position. We have great young talent on the front 7 of the D.
 
It is possible that Chester will go to the PUP list, if he doesn't get ready before the season starts, and that would give us even more room to keep both
 
Sirspud said:
I'm starting to think that Chester isn't a lock. I don't know what his situation is, but Saban might want a guy with more playmaking/pass rush ability. Traylor and Zgonina have played well, and we have lots of talent on the line.
Click to expand...


I'm beginning to think that myself. Injuries have ruined him. Maybe now he can go on to his second career and compete in the World's Strongest Man competitions. :lol:
 
Not only has shaw looked better but he went to Michigan State 98-01......hmmmmm can you guys remind me who there coach was?
 
You guys speak of Shaw as though he isn't young like Vickerman...

Shaw is a work in progress as well; he is only 25 years old guys.

Lee2000
 
I have not noticed much from Shaw, but Vickerson is in the backfield on every play.
 
I would keep Vickerson, Shaw, and Wright. The Dolphins need to look toward the future and get younger. I think Chester is the odd man out.
 
Lee2000 said:
Shaw is a work in progress as well; he is only 25 years old guys.

Lee2000
Click to expand...

I thought he was closer to 30. Either way if I HAD to choose, I'd still go w/ Vickerson. I think his potential is greater than that of Shaw's. But, I still think we'll keep both.
 
I prefer to keep Shaw, Vickerson, and Wright and just waive Zgonina. I like Z, but he is aging and we need to develop young guys now, which only makes sense because we are a developing team right now.
 
T.R.U. FIN3 said:
I prefer to keep Shaw, Vickerson, and Wright and just waive Zgonina. I like Z, but he is aging and we need to develop young guys now, which only makes sense because we are a developing team right now.
Click to expand...
I totally agree. Zgonia, because he is 35, and Chester , because he is sooooo out of shape, are expendable.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top Bottom