Suh or Knighton+Odrick?

[Carne Asada]

Idk if this has been asked but looking at the numbers, for what we pay Suh we could have gotten Odrick back and brought Knighton and still have like $3M left (if you average their salaries). I'm not advocating either, nor calling any contract out or anything, I just want to know what you guys think. Personally, I'm a big fan of rotating D-linemen and would have probably preferred being deeper at the position.

 

[Hayden Fox]

Suh

 

[nick1]

Suh. Odrick is overrated around here i like the guy but he needs to be in a rotation. Suh is on the field all day

 

[CamWakeForest]

Suh easily

 

[phinfan33]

Give me Suh. Odrick and Pot Roast aren't game changers that opposing OCs have to account for like Suh is. Yeah I had Odrick as my av, but he never affected games like Suh does. Knighton doesn't affect games like Suh does. Suh is a generational game changing DT coming into the prime of his career. When u have a chance to get a guy like that, you do it. Suh all day for me.

 

[Finex]

Suh, makes everybody on defense better I think

We have had very goods before, not a possibly future Hall of famer.

 

[Fintastic2124]

Absolutely Suh....odrick was a part of the defense that was porous against the run the last part of last year. it was horrible

 

[Carne Asada]

Yea, well, I'm not questioning how good Suh is, he's definitely better than Odrick. I'm questioning value and depth. In one option you also have your depth taken care of with Mitchell as a rotation guy, while with Suh, Mitchell starts and depth beyond him is poor. I like Anthony Johnson as our 4th option better than our 3rd.

 

[phinfan33]

Value wise Suh is better than Odrick and Knighton.

 

[NBP81]

This is a legit question. You could make an argument either way I guess but im snap calling Suh...

 

[miamiron]

Suh is going to be in the Football Hall Of Fame someday
the others will need a ticket to get in

 

[Hc90]

Id take suh . He's an absolute nightmare on an individual matchup . And that's what makes him different .

 

[3rdandinches]

One of the potentially best ever or a couple decent players?????

Suh forces olines to change their blocking schemes, Wake, Vernon and our LB's will benefit for this; let alone the secondary which will see the ball come out faster too. Knighton and Odrick are good defensive players, I like them both but they make no one around them better. I'll give the money to the difference maker every time.

 

[Carne Asada]

Well then we better draft another DT early. I just don't feel comfortable with our depth. Either a two-gapper in the first three rounds to take Mitchell's spot and let Mitchell be the back up or a balanced DT to take the rotational spot.

Two-gappers:

Shelton at 14.
Brown/Goldman if we trade down to late teens/early twenties.
Phillips borderline 1st/2nd.
Davis at #47.

Balanced DTs:

Gabe Wright if we get a 3rd.
Tyeler Davison, Derrick Lott, David Parry, Letterious Walton are all late rd picks we should look at.

 

[Danny]

Idk if this has been asked but looking at the numbers, for what we pay Suh we could have gotten Odrick back and brought Knighton and still have like $3M left (if you average their salaries). I'm not advocating either, nor calling any contract out or anything, I just want to know what you guys think. Personally, I'm a big fan of rotating D-linemen and would have probably preferred being deeper at the position.

Well, with the money we're paying Suh we could get a whole bunch of nobodys too. I rather have an elite player than 2 average players anytime

Ozzy rules!!