Tannehill Or Winston?

[gregorygrant83]

With Jameis Winston's three game suspension and people, like ESPN, saying he needs to win in 2018 to have a future with the Bucs, would you prefer Tannehill or Winston as the Dolphins qb? I would prefer Tannehill, but consideration for Winston would include his Florida ties and his younger age. The truth is Winston's not a bad qb, but might always lose and be over shadowed in a division with Matt Ryan, Drew Brees and Cam Newton.

 

[Fin Fan in Cali]

Ryan all day long. I don't like Jameis past track record in how he conducts himself. If Jameis doesn't win, I can see him looking for another team.

 

[Finman1022]

THill without question. Winston has issues that in my opinion unfortunately will cost him his career.

 

[Csonked Out]

not even a question....Winston is a damn fool.

 

[nick1]

Not this again .Tannehill versus ______

 

[dolphintodd]

Hey if your going to lose anyway, might as well have people's respect... Tannehill.

 

[Danny]

Tannehill

 

[gregorygrant83]

As I said at the top, I like Tannehill a great deal but I would have to consider the fact that Winston is 24 with 3 seasons of NFL experience while Tannehill was 24 when he started his first game as a rookie. I'll tell you this, there's not a scheduled 2019 NFL free agent qb or qb in the 2019 draft that I would take over Winston.

 

[Dolph N.Fan]

“Or”

 

[fins1]

With Jameis Winston's three game suspension and people, like ESPN, saying he needs to win in 2018 to have a future with the Bucs, would you prefer Tannehill or Winston as the Dolphins qb? I would prefer Tannehill, but consideration for Winston would include his Florida ties and his younger age. The truth is Winston's not a bad qb, but might always lose and be over shadowed in a division with Matt Ryan, Drew Brees and Cam Newton.

He might always lose but will always be a loser.

 

[phintim]

I believe Winston has more football moxie or presence that has not happened for RT yet. Winston also has some backwoods immaturity issues that I am not sure are full blown bad or he just has not grown up yet. Winston and Manziel both got that Hiesman trophy way to early in their college career and I think it went to their heads. No reason to give that trophy to a kid until he is a junior at least in college and has proven he has true leadership qualities and not just a strong arm. I am sticking with RT cause he is tough hard working guy that l respect and he is a phin. Both coming out of college in the same draft probably would have chosen Winston.

 

[WCUPUNK]

Jameis Winston was a borderline starter before this suspension. A better argument would be Winston or Bortles at this point.

 

[Adam Strange]

So after he’s been caught yet again acting the fool— to put it mildly— and has been sanctioned by the league for it, you still think it’s a good idea to bet on him showing better judgment in the future? Because I’m pretty sure he’s got some more idiotic behavior in him.

 

[Fin Fan in Cali]

I hope for Jameis the person he gets help and gets his life together.

 

[superphin]

I pick Tannehill because he's not a rapist and I like that.

Although during Tannehill's 8 game stretch in 2016, Winston during that exact time frame put up an equally impressive run.

Tannehill 13 TD 5 INT 69% comp% 100.1 QBR
Winston 14 TD 4 INT 64% comp% 100.7 QBR