Run underneath routes? You mean the same underneath stuff that got us man handled against Balt.? I for one think a elite qb can and should be able to make ALL the throws necessary on the field to maximize their offenses chance of scoring. Shoot, not even elite, but average. The problem is, is people like you think Penny is average or elite. I don't.
When you can't open up the offense and run on first down or second down, then have to pass dink and dunk for third down, eventually a top tier defense is gonna shut you down. Again watch both Balt. games and the last NE game.
Whenever Penny was asked to throw, 30-40 times in a game. How many of those did MIA win? 1?
Fact is again, there are many gaps, holes on this roster. And to say Ginn is the biggest one or the main problem misses the point. Right now MIA is using stop gap players to build for tomorrow. And one of those stop gaps happens to be Penny. I am not one to say Henne is the answer. I will say, the FO does.
When MIA can run the ball consistently on 1st and 2nd down, and is able to throw down field w/o our receivers having to come back for the ball. Then you can tear apart a WR game.
I don't see Moss coming back for under thrown balls, nor did I see the young rook from BALT, make alot of overthrown or underthrown mistakes. I seen 2 top tier teams take away the running game early, and sit on the short crossing stuff. And I seen average players like Leonhard, have a career day off the arm of Penny.