Tempest in an Aquarium | FinHeaven - Miami Dolphins Forums

Tempest in an Aquarium

NaboCane

I'm on my comma
Joined
May 27, 2004
Messages
24,216
Reaction score
18
Location
Seattle, WA
A lot has been said lately on the subject of local sports reporters, particularly in light of the ongoing feud involving the local writers and Saban. There have been valid points made, as well as some hasty conclusions.

All in all, it's a sad time if you're a Dolphins' fan because the press is our conduit for information about our favorite team, its activities and its players. Anytime you have information taken from its normal course and forced through a funnel to the end users, (us) it skews the result. Try as anyone might to minimize the importance of an unfettered press, the reality is that we wouldn't know **** without them except what the team deigns to tell us. And any skewing of the news gives us a product unlike the one we would have received otherwise. That's just a simple fact.

There are those who stand statue-like on one side of the issue; they only defend "the party line," substituting knee-jerk reaction for independent, analytic thought, thinking that this reflects loyalty to the team. They fail to see that with the exception of a few - very few - instances, life is not comprised of absolute right and absolute wrong; the truth usually lies somewhere in the middle of the combatants' subjective truth.

True loyalty to the team would dictate an abiding desire to have every bit of news about the team that can possibly be available, except where it functions to the detriment of the team.

And I find it ironic that most of the folks willing to give Saban 100% absolution in this matter are the same ones that wailed loudly at the discovery of all the behind-the-scenes malfeasance during the Wannstedt regime, and lamented that we didn't know sooner.

I will remain a motivated observer; I will keep my own counsel as to who I think is to blame for each episode in this unfortunate situation, using logical analysis and my own personal set of ethics. What I will not do is succumb to any form of dogma, and support or vilify based on having chosen a side before all the facts are in.

In other words, I'll watch, learn, listen, and decide for myself what I believe. In other words, I will approach this with an open mind.

And most importantly, I will keep in mind that each of these incidents is part of a big picture; one that is only just beginning to unfold, and one that will play out over the time of Saban's tenure here. A long and successful tenure, as I'm sure we all hope.

So, instead of rooting for only one side and hoping for a loser on the other, I will root for mutual understanding so that we all win.


I'm posting this in main as well, just for sh!ts and giggles. I will only respond to posts here, though. :evil:
<!-- / message --><!-- sig -->
 
Shut up and get me another beer.

:roflmao:

Oh ... sorry about that. I had to.

Anyway, you raise a good point, but I don't think Saban's locking things off just to be an ***. Nor do I think this is a permanent situation.
 
DrAstroZoom said:
Shut up and get me another beer.

:roflmao:

Oh ... sorry about that. I had to.

Anyway, you raise a good point, but I don't think Saban's locking things off just to be an ***. Nor do I think this is a permanent situation.


You're just lealous that I wrote this! :roflmao:
 
I'm open to any new ways of doin things if it helps the team win. If i dont get a ton of finfo but the fins are improveing and headed in the right direction then im willing to make that sacrifice.
 
Its not a big deal to me. Nothing really going on right now anyway.
I don't need to know so or so stubbed his toe in practice.
 
what really irks me is hearing those that are responsible for sabans extreme actions, cry like little babies because they no longer have absolute access and are expected to be held accountable for what they write. it's unfortunate that all of us and the truely capable reporters have to endure because those that aspire to loftier goals are so careless about their craft. they hold mis-guided beliefs that because they are "reporters", they have every right to what ever info they can get and can write what ever they please.

too bad ESPu doesn't just permanently call these.....reporters.....to the bigs and let us get on with our team. maybe we could get some more empassioned reporters who don't let their personal alliances get in the way of their jobs.
 
I like your insight. I believe the same thing. I am in the process of talking to the reportrs to get a reafl feal and solid explanation form them in order to let people hear there point of view instead of just assuming everything.
 
i know that saban would have shut things down regardless of the media situation, but because things were so bad the last few seasons, it was necessary to shut things down completely. it's always a good idea to get ahold of any issue when you first take over. it was/is painfully clear that the media needed to be slowed down and brought back in line. we, on these boards, have been saying that for some time.

for those of us old enough, this is similar to what reagan did when he first took office. carter let the press corp run free during his term and the first thing ronnie did was shut them down and made order of the press conferences. he took control. i remember a similar buzz coming from the media then about "it wasn't right" and "how could he".... now there is order and no one is complaining. everyone gets their story.

so, i think with patience we will get the info we are all starved for.
 
Back
Top Bottom