Show me the talent evaluator that hasn't been in love with a player that didn't end up playing well, and I'll show you a liar.
I remember two calls of yours that I thought were particularly good. The first was QB Levi Brown, who I looked up after you mentioned him. You can only see so much from a guy playing at Troy, but in terms of size, arm, feet in the pocket I thought that Brown just might have that elusive "it" factor. I only remember so much, but I do remember watching some clips of him and thinking that he reminded me a bit of Marino in terms of his quick release, ball velocity and accuracy. And the feet, too- nice quick feet in the pocket. If he's available I'd like to see us give him a shot.
Another was a WRa few years ago from some small college in the South, I'm thinking Louisiana. I Don't remember his name, but that guy has size, speed, quicks and hands. IIRC he made his own video and sent it to NFL teams. To this day I'm surprised that he hasn't done more, not sure if and where he's playing football these days.
Everyone hits and misses- people can say what they want, but as I said in a different post I really liked John Beck as a prospect- he hasn't done much, but I still stand by the pick and the thought process as per liking him. And I also liked Blaine Gabbert way more than Cam Newton, who I thought might be in for a rude awakening in the NFL. He's certaintly proven that theory to be invalid so far, and my guy Gabbert is pretty much sucking eggs so far. That's how it goes.