*** The Official Dolphins vs Rams Game Thread *** | Page 52 | FinHeaven - Miami Dolphins Forums

*** The Official Dolphins vs Rams Game Thread ***

do you think we can keep 6 safties a 4 coners since some can play coner
 
mcteems said:
I think Vick makes the team. Gibson may have to go back to the practice squad for another season.
Click to expand...

I think Gibson makes it as the number 5.
 
Csonka39 said:
vick just made the team
Click to expand...

Who does he beat out, Gibson or Campbell?

I certainly hope not and I don't see it.
Vick to the PS hopefully.

Gibson has shown signs of being a solid WR.
He's polished and has shown signs he can contribute right now unlike Vick.
Campbell has already shown what he can do in the NFL and he's a burner albeit inconsistent.

It would be a bad decision to cut either of these 2 for Vick who is a project that may never pan out.


It always amazes me how fans take what they see in preseason scrub time as signs of a player being ready to contribute right away. The list of preseason superstars is long and undistinguished.
 
WelcomeBack said:
That's what I'm thinking. If Saban was still evaluating him, or getting rid of him, he would've allowed Vick to throw the ball.
Click to expand...

Was that an actual draw play or did he choose to run?
 
shanem8481 said:
do you think we can keep 6 safties a 4 coners since some can play coner
Click to expand...

I think we keep 5 safeties, and 4 corners. Valient effort by Hunt, but he shouldn't make this team.
 
Vick is more versatile then Gibson and Campbell....we'll see what Nick does.
 
Trekbiz said:
Who does he beat out, Gibson or Campbell?

I certainly hope not and I don't see it.
Vick to the PS hopefully.

Gibson has shown signs of being a solid WR.
He's polished and contribute right now unlike Vick.
Campbell has already shown what he can do in the NFL and he's a burner albeit inconsistent.

It would be a bad decision to cut either of these 2 for Vick who is a project that may never pan out.


It always amazes me how fans take what they see in preseason scrub time as signs of a player being ready to contribute right away. The list of preseason superstars is long and undistinguished.
Click to expand...

Gibson hasnt looked any better than Vick latley.... plus Vick hasnt dropped any easy catches either.
 
Lets trade one of our extra WR's for a RB to back up Ronnie. :tongue:
 
mcteems said:
I think Vick makes the team. Gibson may have to go back to the practice squad for another season.
Click to expand...

Gibson has played well and against more than just TC fodder as Vick has in this last game.
I just don't get your rationale.
So be it.
 
Who does he beat out, Gibson or Campbell?
Click to expand...

Probably Soup. IMO our WR situation looks like this

1)Chambers
2)Booker
3)Welker
4)Hagan
5)Gibson
6)Vick

Devin A will land on the PS.
 
wow we look good man lemon what a game does saban know talent or what nice to get some momentum for the pitt game get ready pitt cause miami is coming to town get your popcorn ready miami is going to put on a show...:dolphins:
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top Bottom