The #s Game! | FinHeaven - Miami Dolphins Forums

The #s Game!

CCMiamiDolphins

CCMiamiDolphins

Parcells hater
Joined
Jun 9, 2003
Messages
1,633
Reaction score
1
Age
36
Location
Deptford, New Jersey
Alright I did a thread a couple of months ago asking which #86 was better? Orande Gadsden or Marty Booker. Well now its which player wearing that # would you want on your team when they were with the Dolphins. Im at work so im just going to do a couple if you got any good ones let me know and ill add it. Now some of them are in my opinion obvious but idk people sure do amaze me when it comes to this forum


#1 Reggie Roby or Matt Turk
#9 Jay Fiedler or John Beck
#10 Olindo Mare or Pete Stoyanovich
#11 Jim Jensen or Gus Frerotte
#13 Dan Marino or Jake Scott
#17 Cleo Lemon or Brandon London
#18 Sage Rosenfel or Ernest Wilford
#23 Patrick Surtain or Ronnie Brown
#24 Sammy Knight or Renaldo Hill
#26 Lamar Smith or Tavares Tillman
#52 Marlon Greenwood or Channing Crowder
#55 Junior Seau or Joey Porter
#56 Derrick Pope or Charlie Anderson
#59 Derrick Rodgers or Donnie Spragan
#66 Jamie Nails or Donald Thomas
#81 OJ Mcduffie or Randy Mcmichael
#82 Brian Gilmore or Derek Hagan
#83 Wes Welker or Greg Camarillo
#86 Orande Gadsden or Marty Booker
#88 Cris Carter or David Martin
#93 Trace Armstrong or Wally Ogunleye
#94 Keith Traylor or Randy Starks
 
CCMiamiDolphins said:
Alright I did a thread a couple of months ago asking which #86 was better? Orande Gadsden or Marty Booker. Well now its which player wearing that # would you want on your team when they were with the Dolphins. Im at work so im just going to do a couple if you got any good ones let me know and ill add it. Now some of them are in my opinion obvious but idk people sure do amaze me when it comes to this forum


#9 Jay Fiedler or John Beck
#10 Olindo Mare or Chad Pennington
#17 Cleo Lemon or Brandon London
#18 Sage Rosenfel or Ernest Wilford
#23 Patrick Surtain or Ronnie Brown
#24 Sammy Knight or Renaldo Hill
#26 Lamar Smith or Tavares Tillman
#52 Marlon Greenwood or Channing Crowder
#86 Orande Gadsden or Marty Booker
#88 Cris Carter or David Martin
#93 Trace Armstrong or Wally Ogunleye
Click to expand...

Red indicate who I think was better as a phin.
 
the ROnnie Brown Pat Surtain is the hardest one to pick but i would go with ronnie just because he is my 2nd fav dolphin of all time
 
CCMiamiDolphins said:
Alright I did a thread a couple of months ago asking which #86 was better? Orande Gadsden or Marty Booker. Well now its which player wearing that # would you want on your team when they were with the Dolphins. Im at work so im just going to do a couple if you got any good ones let me know and ill add it. Now some of them are in my opinion obvious but idk people sure do amaze me when it comes to this forum


#1 Reggie Roby or Matt Turk
#9 Jay Fiedler or John Beck
#10 Olindo Mare or Pete Stoyanovich
#11 Jim Jensen or Gus Frerotte
#17 Cleo Lemon or Brandon London
#18 Sage Rosenfel or Ernest Wilford
#23 Patrick Surtain or Ronnie Brown
#24 Sammy Knight or Renaldo Hill
#26 Lamar Smith or Tavares Tillman
#52 Marlon Greenwood or Channing Crowder
#55 Junior Seau or Joey Porter
#56 Derrick Pope or Charlie Anderson
#66 Jamie Nails or Donald Thomas
#81 OJ Mcduffie or Randy Mcmichael
#83 Wes Welker or Greg Camarillo
#86 Orande Gadsden or Marty Booker
#88 Cris Carter or David Martin
#93 Trace Armstrong or Wally Ogunleye
#94 Keith Traylor or Randy Starks
Click to expand...
My answers are in orange.
 
CCMiamiDolphins said:
Alright I did a thread a couple of months ago asking which #86 was better? Orande Gadsden or Marty Booker. Well now its which player wearing that # would you want on your team when they were with the Dolphins. Im at work so im just going to do a couple if you got any good ones let me know and ill add it. Now some of them are in my opinion obvious but idk people sure do amaze me when it comes to this forum


#1 Reggie Roby or Matt Turk
#9 Jay Fiedler or John Beck
#10 Olindo Mare or Pete Stoyanovich
#11 Jim Jensen or Gus Frerotte
#17 Cleo Lemon or Brandon London
#18 Sage Rosenfel or Ernest Wilford
#23 Patrick Surtain or Ronnie Brown
#24 Sammy Knight or Renaldo Hill
#26 Lamar Smith or Tavares Tillman
#52 Marlon Greenwood or Channing Crowder
#55 Junior Seau or Joey Porter
#56 Derrick Pope or Charlie Anderson
#66 Jamie Nails or Donald Thomas
#81 OJ Mcduffie or Randy Mcmichael
#83 Wes Welker or Greg Camarillo
#86 Orande Gadsden or Marty Booker
#88 Cris Carter or David Martin
#93 Trace Armstrong or Wally Ogunleye
#94 Keith Traylor or Randy Starks
Click to expand...

some of these were tough, some easy, anyone have an opinion on:
#13 Dan Marino or Jake Scott?
 
Some of those comparisions are bizzarely far off in terms of positions and functions on the team.

Jim Jensen/Gus Ferrotte? Really?
 
Last edited by a moderator:
#1 Reggie Roby or Matt Turk
#9 Jay Fiedler or John Beck
#10 Olindo Mare or Pete Stoyanovich
#11 Jim Jensen or Gus Frerotte
#17 Cleo Lemon or Brandon London
#18 Sage Rosenfel or Ernest Wilford
#23 Patrick Surtain or Ronnie Brown
#24 Sammy Knight or Renaldo Hill
#26 Lamar Smith or Tavares Tillman
#52 Marlon Greenwood or Channing Crowder
#55 Junior Seau or Joey Porter
#56 Derrick Pope or Charlie Anderson
#66 Jamie Nails or Donald Thomas
#81 OJ Mcduffie or Randy Mcmichael
#83 Wes Welker or Greg Camarillo
#86 Orande Gadsden or Marty Booker
#88 Cris Carter or David Martin
#93 Trace Armstrong or Wally Ogunleye
#94 Keith Traylor or Randy Starks
 
#1 Reggie Roby or Matt Turk
#9 Jay Fiedler or John Beck
#10 Olindo Mare or Pete Stoyanovich
#11 Jim Jensen or Gus Frerotte
#17 Cleo Lemon or Brandon London
#18 Sage Rosenfel or Ernest Wilford
#23 Patrick Surtain or Ronnie Brown
#24 Sammy Knight or Renaldo Hill
#26 Lamar Smith or Tavares Tillman
#52 Marlon Greenwood or Channing Crowder
#55 Junior Seau or Joey Porter
#56 Derrick Pope or Charlie Anderson
#66 Jamie Nails or Donald Thomas
#81 OJ Mcduffie or Randy Mcmichael
#83 Wes Welker or Greg Camarillo
#86 Orande Gadsden or Marty Booker
#88 Cris Carter or David Martin
#93 Trace Armstrong or Wally Ogunleye
#94 Keith Traylor or Randy Starks

Some of these guys were before my time so I may have gone with the more familiar player in some cases. One that I would likely highlight is the Wally over Trace selection. I don't really know Trace Armstrong therefore I have to go with Wally because he was good with us.
 
I like the one guys idea, Red = Better

CCMiamiDolphins said:
#1 Reggie Roby or Matt Turk
#9 Jay Fiedler or John Beck
#10 Olindo Mare or Pete Stoyanovich
#11 Jim Jensen or Gus Frerotte
#13 Dan Marino or Jake Scott
#17 Cleo Lemon or Brandon London
#18 Sage Rosenfel or Ernest Wilford
#23 Patrick Surtain or Ronnie Brown
#24 Sammy Knight or Renaldo Hill
#26 Lamar Smith or Tavares Tillman
#52 Marlon Greenwood or Channing Crowder
#55 Junior Seau or Joey Porter
#56 Derrick Pope or Charlie Anderson
#59 Derrick Rodgers or Donnie Spragan
#66 Jamie Nails or Donald Thomas
#81 OJ Mcduffie or Randy Mcmichael
#82 Brian Gilmore or Derek Hagan
#83 Wes Welker or Greg Camarillo
#86 Orande Gadsden or Marty Booker
#88 Cris Carter or David Martin
#93 Trace Armstrong or Wally Ogunleye
#94 Keith Traylor or Randy Starks
Click to expand...
I purposely chose not to answer between Gilmore and Hagan.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top Bottom