The True Quarterback Competition | FinHeaven - Miami Dolphins Forums

The True Quarterback Competition

Spesh

#freespesh
Joined
Apr 26, 2007
Messages
15,619
Reaction score
1,272
If we are finishing the season with a record that secures us a top selection in the draft it doesn't particularly matter how well or poorly Ryan Tannehill played for the rest of the season. The results would speak for itself. Either he totally bottomed out, thus making it imperative to find a replacement or the rest of the team dissolved and it will be years until we become legitimate contenders. When your in that situation you don't pass on a potential franchise quarterback.

Heres our competition for finding said quarterback:

Cleveland

Surprising absolutely no one Cleveland is appalling. No matter how highly they think of Cody Kessler they cannot afford to (yet again) pass on a potential franchise quarterback. Working in our favor is the fact they have multiple first round picks from their trade with the Eagles. From my understanding there is friction between the front office and coaching staff. Despite that, Hue Jackson is likely to keep his job.

Their remaining schedule is:

@ Titans
@ Bengals
vs Jets
vs Cowboys
@ Ravens
vs Steelers
vs Giants
vs Bengals
@ Bills
vs Chargers
@ Steelers

San Francisco

Possibly a worse quarterback situation than Cleveland. Chip Kelly is likely to keep his job, though the same can't be said about Trent Baalke. Kelly was fairly aggressive when trying to fix his quarterback woes. Despite inheriting Michael Vick and Nick Foles, he drafted Matt Barkley and traded for Sam Bradford.

Schedule:

@ Bills
vs Bucs
vs Saints
@ Cardinals
vs Patriots
@ Dolphins
@ Bears
vs Jets
@ Falcons
@ Rams
vs Seahawks

Chicago

It was leaked today that the coaching staff has totally lost faith in Jay Cutler and considers Brian Hoyer the superior option (due to his ball security). They won't fall into the trap other franchises have and believe hes the long term answer. Ryan Pace is safe and its unlikely, though not impossible, John Fox is sent packing.

Schedule:

vs Jaguars
@ Packers
vs Vikings
@ Bucs
@ Giants
vs Titans
vs 49ers
@ Lions
vs Packers
vs Redskins
@ Vikings

New York

Christian Hackenberg's selection in the 2nd round shouldn't prevent them from drafting a potential franchise quarterback. Little chance Todd Bowles or Mike Maccagnan are fired.

Schedule:

@ Cardinals
vs Ravens
@ Browns
@ Dolphins
vs Rams
vs Patriots
vs Colts
@ 49ers
vs Dolphins
@ Patriots
vs Bills

New Orleans

Drew Brees will turn 38 in January. Its easy to imagine the Saints trading him to a contender or having him mentor a young player. Either way they will be planning for the future. Sean Payton signed a long term deal and theres no chance he or Mickey Loomis will be fired, especially considering the lawsuits Tom Benson is dealing with at the moment.

Schedule:

vs Panthers
@ Chiefs
vs Seahawks
@ 49ers
vs Broncos
@ Panthers
vs Rams
vs Lions
@ Bucs
@ Cardinals
vs Bucs
@ Falcons

Arizona

Carson Palmer turns 37 during the season and the Cardinals have seen what awaits them once he retires. It wasn't exactly encouraging. No chance Arians or Keim are fired.

Schedule:

vs Jets
vs Seahawks
@ Panthers
vs 49ers
@ Vikings
@ Falcons
vs Redskins
@ Dolphins
vs Saints
@ Seahawks
@ Rams

Washington

Kirk Cousins is showing hes nothing more than a stopgap and he'll be a free agent this offseason anyways. Dan Synder's volatility is well known, so one can never be too sure, but Scot McCloughan's job is likely safe and Gruden will probably be given another year.

Schedule:

vs Bengals
vs Vikings
vs Packers
@ Cowboys
@ Cardinals
@ Eagles
vs Panthers
@ Bears
vs Giants

Buffalo

Tyrod Taylor has been exposed and cost his offensive coordinator his job. And just for good measure, Rex Ryan was given told in no uncertain terms that if he doesn't make the playoffs he will be fired. They likely won't make the playoffs. Tyrod's contract allows the team to walk away provided they cut him by the 3rd day of the 2017 league year.

Schedule:

vs 49ers
@ Dolphins
vs Patriots
@ Seahawks
@ Bengals
vs Jaguars
@ Raiders
vs Steelers
vs Browns
vs Dolphins
@ Jets

Houston

Brock Osweiler is showing the Texans why the Broncos played hardball during their negotiations. While Bob McNair is extraordinarily loyal to his hires, Rick Smith has been GM since 2006 and repeatedly dropped the ball with the quarterback position. Given McNair's loyalty, and the fact he had to pay Penn State a massive buyout, Bill O'Brien will likely keep his job. Osweiler's deal is apparently fully guaranteed next year, for what its worth.

Schedule:

vs Houston
@ Broncos
vs Lions
@ Jaguars
vs Raiders
vs Chargers
@ Packers
@ Colts
vs Jaguars
vs Bengals
@ Titans

San Diego

Philip Rivers turns 35 this December and that roster isn't even remotely close to competing for a Superbowl. Mike McCoy could be fired in the next 3 minutes. Given both those factors, its plausible the Chargers will begin a youth movement no matter what they decide to do with Tom Telesco.

Schedule:

vs Broncos
@ Falcons
@ Broncos
vs Titans
vs Dolphins
@ Texans
vs Bucs
@ Panthers
vs Raiders
@ Browns
vs Chiefs

Kansas City

Although hes only 32, Smith has shown how limited he is as a player. Andy Reid, who is in no danger of being fired, was aggressive in trying to replace Donovan McNabb when he hit his 30's. Smith's contract allows them to cut him in either of the next 2 offseason with manageable cap hit.

Schedule:

@ Raiders
vs Saints
@ Colts
vs Jaguars
@ Panthers
vs Bucs
@ Broncos
@ Falcons
vs Raiders
vs Titans
vs Broncos
@ Chargers

Available quarterbacks:

Sam Bradford: Assuming the Vikings don't keep him, he's playing so well that its a guarantee some team will talk themselves into giving him a chance. Plus, the Vikings will want to recoup some of what they spent for him. He turns 29 this season.

Teddy Bridgewater: Assuming the Vikings do keep Bradford, teams will kick the tires on Bridgewater and the Vikings will be receptive to it in order to avoid quarterback drama and recoup draft picks. He turns 24 during the season.

Jimmy Garoppolo: Whiny little piss ant that is he, Brady hasn't even hidden the fact that he plans to hold that team hostage for years to come. Given Belicheats fondness for flipping players, the notorious hardass might be willing to appease his drama queen of a quarterback. Former Patriot exec Michael Lombardi is predicting they will sit back and wait for some desperate team to blow them away with an offer. Working in favor of that is his utterly affordable contract. He turns 25 this year.

Tony Romo: Basically because...
2016-8-23-DakandRomo-719x1024.png

Jay Cutler: This ****ing tool will always get yet another chance based on his talent alone. He'll never play up to that talent but someone will give him a roster spot regardless. Unless he quits. Which would be a Jay Cutler thing to do.

Kirk Cousins: See previous section.

Brock Osweiler: See previous section.

Philip Rivers: See previous section.

Drew Brees: See previous section.

Alex Smith: See previous section.


Random Notes:

- As badly as hes being eviscerated on this board, Tannehill is still talented enough that other teams will be interested in him. Especially when compared to the alternatives listed above, many of whom are too old, too unproven, or too limited.

- Jay Cutler was traded to the Bears for two 1st round picks, a 3rd round pick, and Kyle Orton. Sam Bradford was traded to the Eagles for a 2nd round pick, a 4th round pick, and Nick Foles. Bradford was traded to the Vikings for a 1st and 4th round pick. Given those precedents, its not impossible Tannehill could fetch a 2nd round pick for us.

- The Titans are a problem. Not only are they struggling to win but they have the Rams first round pick. They are well positioned to make another trade with a quarterback needy team. And we currently lack the draft picks to be the team they deal with. The Jaguars could also cause trouble.
 
Kicker hurting himself in a walkthrough and/or the Browns not signing Gould probably cost us a 50/50 shot at the top pick.
 
Drew Brees will turn 38 in January. Its easy to imagine the Saints trading him to a contender with "only $54 million in dead money" this season
 
Unless Brady has an anti-trade clause it still wouldn't shock me to see Belichick do him dirty and trade him and his team friendly contract away.
 
Drew Brees will turn 38 in January. Its easy to imagine the Saints trading him to a contender with "only $54 million in dead money" this season

I believe he also has a no trade clause.
 
I have a bad feeling Cutler will be coming to Miami in the off season, because no one will want him as a starter, but Gase will give him a chance to compete.
 
Didn't the Jets just sign Fitzpatrick to a fairly big contract?
 
Just a 1 year contract.

Ah, OK, so then they were actually smart this time cause Fitz is a journeyman who just had a career year last year. He's most likely gone after the season. And according to my calculation the Jets are picking in the top 5 right now.
 
Ah, OK, so then they were actually smart this time cause Fitz is a journeyman who just had a career year last year. He's most likely gone after the season. And according to my calculation the Jets are picking in the top 5 right now.

What, no faith in Hackenberg? Just think of all the terrible puns used car dealers in Hackensack can use if he gets the gig. Why do you hate small businesses?
 
Wow, the Browns might go winless with that schedule. Right now it seems the Dolphins are gunning for a Top 3 pick. The only teams that have looked worse so far are the Browns and Bears. The bad thing is that both would probably go with a QB in that spot.

If Rivers is somehow available I'd grab him as a stopgap until we can get things back on track.
 
I have a bad feeling Cutler will be coming to Miami in the off season, because no one will want him as a starter, but Gase will give him a chance to compete.

As far as Jay Cutler relationships go, he and Gase were best of friends. As far as human beings relationships go, they were acquaintances. Cutler didn't actively try to burn Gase's career to the ground. If i recall correctly he was closer to Dowell Loggains than Gase, though i could be mistaken. Ironic given the recent reports. Then again, Jay Cutler isn't exactly known for his accuracy and decision making abilities.

---------- Post added at 07:43 PM ---------- Previous post was at 07:42 PM ----------

Wow, the Browns might go winless with that schedule. Right now it seems the Dolphins are gunning for a Top 3 pick. The only teams that have looked worse so far are the Browns and Bears. The bad thing is that both would probably go with a QB in that spot.

If Rivers is somehow available I'd grab him as a stopgap until we can get things back on track.

Philip Rivers' extension with Chargers includes no-trade clause

http://www.espn.com/nfl/story/_/id/...l-san-diego-chargers-includes-no-trade-clause

:bobdole:

I really should have waited to make this thread until i had coffee the following morning.

Rivers and Brees being off the table is better for Tannehill's value though. So theres that.
 
Back
Top Bottom