Thomas Davis played on Sunday witha compound fracture. | FinHeaven - Miami Dolphins Forums

Thomas Davis played on Sunday witha compound fracture.

dolpns13

Taste the Burn
Club Member
Joined
Nov 6, 2005
Messages
30,450
Reaction score
1,570
Location
New Jersey
I don't question a players toughness based on injuries, everyone threshold of pain is different.....having a hurt finger and playing is quit different than having a bad leg and playing.....once you injure your groin only way to get better is with rest....not a fair comparison
 
Regardless of ode's to toughness.
Playing a game like football on a compound fracture of a isn't tough. Its stupid. You are only risking greater injury and greater layoff down the road. Without the bone to protect it what if his finger had come off. His career would be over.

Also would like to echo what jvw said. Patterson's injury issues could have started with him trying to rush himself back to early and constantly re-aggravating a muscle that wasn't properly healed. Now it may have so much scar tissue that it will never heal to full strength.

Add to that our experience with Cam Wake who was inneffective for several weeks likely trying to "go" too early on his hurt MCL. Resulting in multiple weeks of diminished effectiveness.
 
I dont know. I think playing with a compound fracture is much worse than playing with a pulled groin. There are things you can do to manage the pain of a pulled muscle. Ice, a cortozone shot, stretch. There is nothing you can do for a compound fracture.
 
Just cut it off like ronnie lott did.

1986

Aug. 2: In April, doctors looked at the badly damaged finger on Ronnie Lott's left hand and gave him two choices. They could operate, graft a bone from the wrist, insert a pin and have him wear a cast for the next eight weeks. Or they could amputate just above the first joint. Lott made what coaches like to call "the football decision." He told them to cut off the end of his finger. It was a simple procedure. He held out his hand, they numbed it and snipped off the finger tip and put his hand in a cast. After three weeks he went back to have the cast removed. The doctor took off the last dressing. "What do you think?" he asked. Lott couldn't answer. He was staring at a stub. Instead of a fingernail there was only a whitish, rounded stump. "The ugliest thing I've ever seen," Lott says. "I was trying to laugh it off, but I felt sick. I tried to stand up, but I broke into a cold sweat. It was just a total shock. I thought, 'Oh, man, I should have had the pin put in.' " Lott has had worse injuries, but emotionally this one was different. It made him feel that football was biting off bits and pieces of him, of everyone who plays. And no one seems to care. "We are losing the compassionate side of sports," he says. "We're becoming gladiators. If I ever become a coach, I hope I never lose sight of the fact that players are people. They feel, they have emotions. I could have all of Eddie DeBartolo's corporations and it isn't going to buy me a new finger. It has given me a new perspective on life."
 
I dont know. I think playing with a compound fracture is much worse than playing with a pulled groin. There are things you can do to manage the pain of a pulled muscle. Ice, a cortozone shot, stretch. There is nothing you can do for a compound fracture.

I would agree, but when comparing a finger to a groin? I think that is not a very fair comparison, in fact not even close.
 
I would agree, but when comparing a finger to a groin? I think that is not a very fair comparison, in fact not even close.

Sometimes fingers and groins are VERY close.

clear.gif
 
Only used Patterson as an example. Point is can anyone name one player on this team that would play through an injury like that? I dont think there is.
 
No this stupid.

A muscle is like a rope therefore a damaged or torn muscle is like a frayed rope.

Could you play with a partially torn muscle, yes. But the likely hood that you are going to injury it further is EXTREMELY high.

Therefore unless we are dealing with playoffs or Super Bowl where it is the end of the line anyway it doesn't make sense to play on it.

Nothing is going to accelerate that process. Local cortisone injections may numb it but it wont make it stronger and it will likely be more susceptible to injury.


I have no idea what the issue is with Patterson except to assume that he has injured it so many times that there is scar tissue there now. Unfortunately scar tissue is weaker than muscle and more apt to tear under stress. He needs to be shut down for a while and unfortunately cut.
 
I dont know. I think playing with a compound fracture is much worse than playing with a pulled groin. There are things you can do to manage the pain of a pulled muscle. Ice, a cortozone shot, stretch. There is nothing you can do for a compound fracture.

Except for the fact that he probably couldn't cover my slow ass. So what's the point having him in there? So he can get beat every play?
 
Now if he would have played after suffering a compound fracture to the groin we'd all be impressed.
 
Only used Patterson as an example. Point is can anyone name one player on this team that would play through an injury like that? I dont think there is.

i believe Elerby is playing with some kind of chest contusion which is probably the reason he bounces off most of those tackles, Long had a harness on his separated shoulder and did his best to keep his QB clean, but a compound fracture? probably not many guys in the league could or would play like that....not sure if that's toughness or stupidity
 
Back
Top Bottom